2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

[dlanod]

Murphy and Gaff v Gibbs and Barlow?

I'd go the latter two because Gaff just strikes me as the odd man out in that collection scoring-wise.

 

[Yazz13]

Murphy and Gaff v Gibbs and Barlow?

I'd defenitely go with Murphy and Barlow..

Who should i go with out of

Heppell & Hanley?

 

[SoupAStars]

I'd defenitely go with Murphy and Barlow..

Who should i go with out of

Heppell & Hanley?

No contest: Heppell. He has bulked up, will definitely improve, is an extremely slick & classy player and will start to get a bit of an outside-mid role this year.

 

[Yazz13]

No contest: Heppell. He has bulked up, will definitely improve, is an extremely slick & classy player and will start to get a bit of an outside-mid role this year.

All i needed to hear, Cheers!

 

[Pocket_Pears]

I'd defenitely go with Murphy and Barlow..

Who should i go with out of

Heppell & Hanley?

Tough one. As has been mentioned Heppell has bulked up heaps.
Hanley is one who improved heaps in 2011. And then racked up the numbers in the International Rules series (if that's any indicator).

I expect Heppell to average mid 90s, and Hanley to average around high 80's to 90. I'm saving Hanley as an upgrade target myself.

 

[V_23]

Probably not the right thread for these two questions but here goes:

1. Wingard vs. Cheaper rookie + upgrading mid-pricer/premium to better premium?

2. Barlow, yay or nay?

 

[Nasty Penguin]

Christiansen vs Gunston vs Dalhaus as F6 ?

 

[mike1234]

Phil Davis v Marty Clarke ? ??

 

[Goats]

Clarke, if he is a certain starter like most are saying, then no doubt he'll score more points than Davis.

Which two out of Lewis, Zaha, Riewoldt or Sidebottom?

 

[MightyMark]

Zaha.

Murphy vs Selwood?

 

[Shade]

Lenny Hayes v Michael Barlow ?

 

[SSSSSS]

Priddis VS Murphy?

 

[MightyMark]

Lenny Hayes v Michael Barlow ?

Toss a coin!
Personally im going with Barlow, simply because of the age factor with Hayes.

 

[MightyMark]

Priddis VS Murphy?

Murphy. He has more potential to get the big 130 or 140 plus scores, where as Priddis tends to stick around the 100-120 max mark. Both reliable, but Murphy deserves the extra price tag.

 

[Donslad]

Watson, Hodge or Mundy (Choosing 2 out of 3)

 

[MightyMark]

Watson and Hodge.

Really hoping Hodge gets back to full flight this year.

O'Keefe vs. Pavlich?

 

[Gentlemen]

Buntine vs Wilkes vs Mohr vs Spur?

 

[Donslad]

Buntine vs Wilkes vs Mohr vs Spur?

Buntine.

Fyfe v Thomas v Mundy v Griffen

 

[shaun1800]

Zaha was carrying an injury most of last year and in now back to full fitness, no interruptions this preseason. He will most definetly play more midfield this year regardless of Watson playing ( completely different roles).

According to the afl website his knee tendatnits has effected his preseason and and he has pronounced himself " sorer than he had been in any of his previous three years at the club"

http://www.bigpondsport.com/dream-team-builder-david-zaharakis/tabid/91/newsid/82816/default.aspx

 

[Nasty Penguin]

According to the afl website his knee tendatnits has effected his preseason and and he has pronounced himself " sorer than he had been in any of his previous three years at the club"

http://www.bigpondsport.com/dream-team-builder-david-zaharakis/tabid/91/newsid/82816/default.aspx

He's been weaponised and will be good to go come round one expect an even bigger year than last. Kicks goals and ear marked for midfield time cant go wrong.

 

[T4P]

defender rookie (not marty clarke or brandon ellis) + Kreuzer + Barlow + Hawkins/Darling
or
Jake Carlisle + Leuenberger + Morabito + N.Riewoldt

 

[V_23]

Wingard or T. Mitchell?

Secondly, an extension of that question, which option out of the following?

1. Enright, Wingard, Saad
2. Broughton, T. Mitchell, Porplyzia

Thanks

 

[SugarRayRichard]

Rockliff vs priddis???

 

[back2cat]

Id say rockliff over priddis

Enright, Wingard, Saad

but id pick Mitchell over Wingard as a 1 on 1

my question is Kruezer v mcintosh

 

[MightyMark]

Kreuzer for sure.