Onetonylockett
Team Captain
- May 9, 2011
- 355
- 148
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Re: Player X v Player Y
Guthrie v smedts?
Guthrie v smedts?
2012 Player X v Player Y
- Thread starter Jolldo87
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
GiantForce
Club Legend
- Apr 24, 2011
- 1,314
- 4
- AFL Club
- GWS
Re: Player X v Player Y
Guthrie seems more likely to play games and less of the chance to get the vest constantly (Smedts will get the vest a lot I imagine, just look at Geelong's history using it last year). Guthrie probably likely to average more as well...but he is 50K more expensive. But in the end if money isn't as issue then it would be Guthrie for me.
---
McEvoy or Mumford?
McEvoy is pretty much St. Kilda's only ruck. Sydney have a few like Seaby snapping at Mumford's heels (Plus pinch hitters like Pyke and LRT). I feel Mumford is likely to average a little more, but I feel McEvoy is a much better chance at playing all 22 games compared to Mumford.
Decisions decisions
Guthrie seems more likely to play games and less of the chance to get the vest constantly (Smedts will get the vest a lot I imagine, just look at Geelong's history using it last year). Guthrie probably likely to average more as well...but he is 50K more expensive. But in the end if money isn't as issue then it would be Guthrie for me.
---
McEvoy or Mumford?
McEvoy is pretty much St. Kilda's only ruck. Sydney have a few like Seaby snapping at Mumford's heels (Plus pinch hitters like Pyke and LRT). I feel Mumford is likely to average a little more, but I feel McEvoy is a much better chance at playing all 22 games compared to Mumford.
Decisions decisions
Onetonylockett
Team Captain
- May 9, 2011
- 355
- 148
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Re: Player X v Player Y
Mumford definitely has no one at his heels. Pyke and Seaby are miles off
Mumford definitely has no one at his heels. Pyke and Seaby are miles off
lmach
Naitanui2Yeo
Re: Player X v Player Y
Cloke + 67k v Goodes + 49k?
Cloke + 67k v Goodes + 49k?
Hank93
Brownlow Medallist
Re: Player X v Player Y
Neale in the mids with D Smith in the forwards
or
D Smith in the mids with J Cameron in the forwards?
Neale in the mids with D Smith in the forwards
or
D Smith in the mids with J Cameron in the forwards?
Re: Player X v Player Y
I'd go Cloke, hands down the best CHF in the game and is good chance on improving on last years numbers.
I'd go Cloke, hands down the best CHF in the game and is good chance on improving on last years numbers.
- Jul 31, 2010
- 2,743
- 642
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Re: Player X v Player Y
Am i the only one that doesn't think Goodes will have THAT good of a game?
If i had that cash spare, id just get stevie J...if you already have him...then i'd say Cloke.
Am i the only one that doesn't think Goodes will have THAT good of a game?
If i had that cash spare, id just get stevie J...if you already have him...then i'd say Cloke.
FromDaics2Dids
Team Captain
Re: Player X v Player Y
1) Deledio, Selwood, SJ, Clay smith
vs
2) Birchall, Swan, Sidebottom, Coniglio
???
1) Deledio, Selwood, SJ, Clay smith
vs
2) Birchall, Swan, Sidebottom, Coniglio
???
Re: Player X v Player Y
Bro as much as its good to ask for advice, first ask yourself which combination will net you more points. Surely you have an idea of how much these players will average for the year.....
Having said that, i would go with option 2.
Bro as much as its good to ask for advice, first ask yourself which combination will net you more points. Surely you have an idea of how much these players will average for the year.....
Having said that, i would go with option 2.
FromDaics2Dids
Team Captain
Re: Player X v Player Y
Obviously i have looked into it pal, but both options have different merits for choosing them, if i wasn't tossing them up and thinking about them i wouldn't post it on the player x vs player y thread.
Obviously i have looked into it pal, but both options have different merits for choosing them, if i wasn't tossing them up and thinking about them i wouldn't post it on the player x vs player y thread.
- Jan 24, 2012
- 302
- 0
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Banned
- #537
Re: Player X v Player Y
Maybe give us an insight into what you think those 8 players each will score individually. Also give reasons as to why you think they will score that. Also what are some factors you take into consideration when determining score?
Maybe give us an insight into what you think those 8 players each will score individually. Also give reasons as to why you think they will score that. Also what are some factors you take into consideration when determining score?
Re: Player X v Player Y
The inevitable radical change that occurs on a Thursday night.
Drop Thompson to a rookie - 3/0/3 structure in mids.
Upgrade Golby, Morris, Clarke to Duffield, Malceski and Waters
Backline now Goddard, Deleds, Broughts, Duff, Mal, Waters, Hardgrave - Ellis, Bugg
A positive move?
The inevitable radical change that occurs on a Thursday night.
Drop Thompson to a rookie - 3/0/3 structure in mids.
Upgrade Golby, Morris, Clarke to Duffield, Malceski and Waters
Backline now Goddard, Deleds, Broughts, Duff, Mal, Waters, Hardgrave - Ellis, Bugg
A positive move?
- Jan 24, 2012
- 302
- 0
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Banned
- #540
Re: Player X v Player Y
Why would you do that based on 2 team selections?
Yes agree too much coin in the back for me. The greatest strength of the backs is the rookie depth.
Why would you do that based on 2 team selections?
Yes agree too much coin in the back for me. The greatest strength of the backs is the rookie depth.
Re: Player X v Player Y
Oh no, those changes aren't based on the two teams, just random playing around with a team. Seems to be common on a Thursday night after teams get announced people get jittery haha.
and yeah i doubt this will stay as is, i just can't decide between Waters, Mal and Duffield so thought i'd try get all 3 haha. Think i'll settle on Waters.
Oh no, those changes aren't based on the two teams, just random playing around with a team. Seems to be common on a Thursday night after teams get announced people get jittery haha.
and yeah i doubt this will stay as is, i just can't decide between Waters, Mal and Duffield so thought i'd try get all 3 haha. Think i'll settle on Waters.
Re: Player X v Player Y
Shiel or Magner to start?
2 years ago, i would've avoided the player Vs Sydney, but now.... i just don't know. They both look like fair magnets!
Shiel or Magner to start?
2 years ago, i would've avoided the player Vs Sydney, but now.... i just don't know. They both look like fair magnets!
JDWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
Re: Player X v Player Y
You'd have to go Magner. We have seen him play in the flesh and he has been one of Melbourne's shining lights through the midfield. For all we know, especially with lack of match practice, Shiel could be sporting the vest to begin the match
You'd have to go Magner. We have seen him play in the flesh and he has been one of Melbourne's shining lights through the midfield. For all we know, especially with lack of match practice, Shiel could be sporting the vest to begin the match
- Sep 22, 2008
- 698
- 244
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Knicks, Arsenal, A.C Milan
Re: Player X v Player Y
Still cant decide on my rucks strategy
Either cox/3 rookies
or kreuzer/minson
Atm has come down to
Swan/Goddard/cox/rookie and 115k vs Mitchell/Broughton/cox/cruizer and 5k
Only problem with above is i feel i lose a bit of flexibility by only having 5 k left say if i need to trade in a booking rookie or out a failed midpricer
Obviously if i choose a less premium ruck then cox say mumford then i could swap either mitchell or broughton with swa/goddard respectively
Still cant decide on my rucks strategy
Either cox/3 rookies
or kreuzer/minson
Atm has come down to
Swan/Goddard/cox/rookie and 115k vs Mitchell/Broughton/cox/cruizer and 5k
Only problem with above is i feel i lose a bit of flexibility by only having 5 k left say if i need to trade in a booking rookie or out a failed midpricer
Obviously if i choose a less premium ruck then cox say mumford then i could swap either mitchell or broughton with swa/goddard respectively
Re: Player X v Player Y
deledio & masten
or
waters and hayes?
deledio will be my 4th premium back, so i have godo scorers already.
hayes concerns me of being able to score like when he was a premium and if the saints are going to nurse him through the season early
thoughts?
deledio & masten
or
waters and hayes?
deledio will be my 4th premium back, so i have godo scorers already.
hayes concerns me of being able to score like when he was a premium and if the saints are going to nurse him through the season early
thoughts?
Re: Player X v Player Y
Porps + $$$$ vs Dangerfield?
Porps + $$$$ vs Dangerfield?
- Sep 24, 2010
- 7,310
- 8,057
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Phili Eagles + Sixers
Re: Player X v Player Y
Still convinced Danger is more of a SC player so I would go Porps because he is cheaper.
Bugg or Darley? Would have been Darley but he isn't named. Don't know whether to hold onto him or go with Bugg. Got to admit, Bugg is one I hadn't looked into enough this preseason.
Still convinced Danger is more of a SC player so I would go Porps because he is cheaper.
Bugg or Darley? Would have been Darley but he isn't named. Don't know whether to hold onto him or go with Bugg. Got to admit, Bugg is one I hadn't looked into enough this preseason.
- Status
