Viney and Crouch.
2013 Player/s X versus Y
- Thread starter Super Hans
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Viney and Crouch.
Ewwww, yuck.
Surely Viney gets back into side this week though. With a foot up the a$$ can maybe produce like he did vs PA and WC
Monya Meow Meow
Club Legend
- Apr 24, 2013
- 1,557
- 873
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Crouch is still out this week I think
I dunno, I kind of like the look of Ablett, Swan, Pendlebury, Watson, Kennedy in the mids.
Swan wasn't on my radar as an upgrade target (too dear) and Fyfe was a keeper until this suspension. Now I'm contemplating it.
Swan wasn't on my radar as an upgrade target (too dear) and Fyfe was a keeper until this suspension. Now I'm contemplating it.
skilfulgun
Debutant
Very strong midfield that!
I'm tossing up whether to go Dwyer -> Murphy or Watson?
Know what you're gonna get with Watson, but Murphy is underpriced and could go bang with the easy draw.
I'm tossing up whether to go Dwyer -> Murphy or Watson?
Know what you're gonna get with Watson, but Murphy is underpriced and could go bang with the easy draw.
karaoke
Norm Smith Medallist
- Mar 26, 2013
- 6,814
- 14,571
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
To retain - M Jones v J Pittard?
Jones - ave 66 (played 5), increased ~$140k, worth $300-350k (IMO) + net $140k if traded to 115k rookie
Pittard - ave 76 (4), increased ~$107k, worth $350-400k (IMO) + net $120k if traded to 115k rookie
Was thinking M Jones >> Laird/ Docherty (Goodes to Mid bench)??
Pittard & Gibbs on Def bench
Still waiting on Thursday night teams......
Jones - ave 66 (played 5), increased ~$140k, worth $300-350k (IMO) + net $140k if traded to 115k rookie
Pittard - ave 76 (4), increased ~$107k, worth $350-400k (IMO) + net $120k if traded to 115k rookie
Was thinking M Jones >> Laird/ Docherty (Goodes to Mid bench)??
Pittard & Gibbs on Def bench
Still waiting on Thursday night teams......
Jones is playing this week, bar injury.
Pittard is out and will have missed a fortnight minimum, maybe more.
Pittard's worth is compromised.
Keep Jones.
Pittard is out and will have missed a fortnight minimum, maybe more.
Pittard's worth is compromised.
Keep Jones.
rocker_oz33
TheBrownDog
Pittard is most likely to miss another match atfter this one doubt they would risk him hes had injury worries before.
rocker_oz33
TheBrownDog
Pity about pittard so hes got to go had injury worries before also have 3 port backs so hes time is up trade out for who?
Laird V's Wright (saint)V's V's Dochery who i think might be in and out fighting for a spot with Yeo.Laird has kinda unknown role played well after been subbed in kinda played browns role because he got knocked out if brown plays wheres laird fit in??
Laird V's Wright (saint)V's V's Dochery who i think might be in and out fighting for a spot with Yeo.Laird has kinda unknown role played well after been subbed in kinda played browns role because he got knocked out if brown plays wheres laird fit in??
- Sep 9, 2012
- 15,600
- 22,655
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- EAD Jiska
- Banned
- #1,610
Wright has the best JS out of those 3. Don't think any of them will be good scorers though. Bench fodder.
toxic
Hall of Famer
crouch will be out for at least another 2 weeks
rocker_oz33
TheBrownDog
Yeah thats the downside,trade out a player with av of 75 ish plus for a player likely to 50's but there not much else only other ones i can think of are ellis and Vlastin are more pricey both should score more but both could be subs with morris comming back.
- Sep 9, 2012
- 15,600
- 22,655
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- EAD Jiska
- Banned
- #1,613
Try and upgrade Pittard if you can.
rocker_oz33
TheBrownDog
Dont think i can unless i downgrade a pemo ruffhead and danger the worst ones.Quiet funny really if i had of (key word "had") pulled the trigger on the viney> mayes trade i could of gone bilcaves> gawn and pittard Hshaw.So might just do the double downgrade up grade viney to fallen cheapish premo murphy/swallow.
rocker_oz33
TheBrownDog
Well it sounded good in my head**** your posts are hard to read!
.
I think Shaw you're paying unders (because he will knock out a few 120s and get back up to $540K or so) whereas Dixon you might be paying marginal overs (because his average might flatten out from here on in).
The attraction of Shaw is that you know his role, you know he can score, you know he's solid. Negative is durability.
The attraction of Dixon is that he's sharing ruck duties with Smith while playing as the go-to tall forward for the likes of Ablett, Swallow and O'Meara. He loves the contested stuff and is having his breakout season. And he has a higher ceiling than Shaw. And he's a P.O.D. Negative is he's unproven beyond more than five games.
I'm thinking Dixon if only for the rollercoaster ride.
The attraction of Shaw is that you know his role, you know he can score, you know he's solid. Negative is durability.
The attraction of Dixon is that he's sharing ruck duties with Smith while playing as the go-to tall forward for the likes of Ablett, Swallow and O'Meara. He loves the contested stuff and is having his breakout season. And he has a higher ceiling than Shaw. And he's a P.O.D. Negative is he's unproven beyond more than five games.
I'm thinking Dixon if only for the rollercoaster ride.
I like your thinking.
They're both probably gonna be rollercoasters - but Dixon is a new and exciting one whereas I've ridden the Shaw one a few times before, sometimes with disastrous consequences...
Monya Meow Meow
Club Legend
- Apr 24, 2013
- 1,557
- 873
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I am very willing to take the chance with this Dixon guy 
Stealthchicken
All Australian
I've had Shaw most years and he's always seems to get suspended and a corked thigh at least one year.
Shaw v Taylor for Gibbs
toxic
Hall of Famer
Shaw - going to average higher than Harry
toxic
Hall of Famer
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
