2013 Player/s X versus Y

[SCchamp]

Griffen still has Boyd to come back in and steal points from him (buyer beware for the Griff)
Selwood - hmmmm, not sure his form warrants consideration - just plodding along for whatever reason #inbefore150thisweekend

I have been saying Jelwood 150 this week for the past 3 and just keeps letting me down! Big disappointment.

 

[toxic]

I have been saying Jelwood 150 this week for the past 3 and just keeps letting me down! Big disappointment.

he and buddy must be holding hands

 

[Zach Package]

I have been saying Jelwood 150 this week for the past 3 and just keeps letting me down! Big disappointment.

posed the question on the cats board, some of them seem to think he's carrying a niggle of some sort. They mentioned a Hand injury but not with any certainty

 

[karaoke]

Kyle Martin or Tommy Mitchell to bring in...

Who has the better job security?

Could be the 2nd half of the years equivalent to Dwyer or O'Meara?

In hindsight now, who would you have preferred to have picked up at the start of the year, if it was the choice of only one? Dwyer or O'Meara?

Although Martin has no DPP, unlike Dwyer & O'Meara is not playing in top 8 team (yet!).

 

[toxic]

Could be the 2nd half of the years equivalent to Dwyer or O'Meara?

In hindsight now, who would you have preferred to have picked up at the start of the year, if it was the choice of only one? Dwyer or O'Meara?

Although Martin has no DPP, unlike Dwyer & O'Meara is not playing in top 8 team (yet!).

O'Meara has made more money and been more reliable

 

[karaoke]

O'Meara has made more money and been more reliable

Yep, and Mitchell has that 'something' about him like JOM, that's my thinking & why I am looking to get him in after rd 12, ATM.

Hrovat after his rd 11 bye as well.

Martin would leave me with rd 13 bye player 'overload'.

 

[toxic]

Yep, and Mitchell has that 'something' about him like JOM, that's my thinking & why I am looking to get him in after rd 12, ATM.

Hrovat after his rd 11 bye as well.

Martin would leave me with rd 13 bye player 'overload'.

Martin and Mitchell must haves IMO, Hrovat I'm not sold on just yet.
Mitchell is a Rd13 grab if his forms continues to warrant selection. RO'k or Goodes or Bolton or Jack going down injured for 6 weeks would be a real shame....

 

[Zach Package]

Martin and Mitchell must haves IMO, Hrovat I'm not sold on just yet.
Mitchell is a Rd13 grab if his forms continues to warrant selection. RO'k or Goodes or Bolton or Jack going down injured for 6 weeks would be a real shame....

Hrovat comes along at a perfect time though. and i'd only be turfing sam rowe to get him.

I plan on having grabbing all 3, then from there it's a lottery as to who will get upgraded for my last midfield upgrade

 

[rocker_oz33]

W)Lecrae > Kmart.
Neade > rookie
JOM > Pberry.
plus cash.
V's
X)Lecrae > kmart.
neade > walker.
JOM >swallow/dusty OR hambuger swan.

 

[toxic]

W)Lecrae > Kmart.
Neade > rookie
JOM > Pberry.
plus cash.
V's
X)Lecrae > kmart.
neade > walker.
JOM >swallow/dusty OR hambuger swan.

Option X - Swan provided he plays is at his lowest $$$ he'll ever be
Walker - continues to impress
kmart - looks to have good JS

 

[karaoke]

Martin and Mitchell must haves IMO, Hrovat I'm not sold on just yet.
Mitchell is a Rd13 grab if his forms continues to warrant selection. RO'k or Goodes or Bolton or Jack going down injured for 6 weeks would be a real shame....

Hrovat may have JS issues with Boyd & Cooney likey to come in over next few rounds(?).

With a near to full playing list, do you see Kmart as top 22 for pies?

Both Hrovat & Kmart likely to be on the 'bubble' heading into rd 12, so will be interesting discussion up until then.

I'm not sure I've seen too many mention they are going Kmart & Hrovat and not getting Mitchell.

 

[toxic]

Hrovat may have JS issues with Boyd & Cooney likey to come in over next few rounds(?).

With a near to full playing list, do you see Kmart as top 22 for pies?

Both Hrovat & Kmart likely to be on the 'bubble' heading into rd 12, so will be interesting discussion up until then.

I'm not sure I've seen too many mention they are going Kmart & Hrovat and not getting Mitchell.

Kmart spot will be good if his form continues. With no Daisy, Beams, Toovey there are holes everywhere in pie land.
Dwyer may or may not come back in, Broomhead will get games before years end, Sinclair may also come back in at some stage.
Irish Clarke is here nor there, Ben Johnson still injured but would be penciled in to our best 22
Opportunities exist for a contested ball winner, and Kmart is that

 

[rocker_oz33]

Option X - Swan provided he plays is at his lowest $$$ he'll ever be
Walker - continues to impress
kmart - looks to have good JS

Sorry I forgot to say its a 4 way trade inc gawn > nicholls my first X Y post was rushed.sorry again.

gawn > nicholls.
frenchy > Kmart.
jom > swan.
neade > walker i think i will have enough to do these.

 

[toxic]

Sorry I forgot to say its a 4 way trade inc gawn > nicholls my first X Y post was rushed.sorry again.

gawn > nicholls.
frenchy > Kmart.
jom > swan.
neade > walker i think i will have enough to do these.

4 trades - hmmm do you have supercoach platinum or someother upgrade i'm unaware of?

either way all 4 trades are good trades

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

4 trades - hmmm do you have supercoach platinum or someother upgrade i'm unaware of?

either way all 4 trades are good trades

It's Supercoach diamond package mate.
Basically you pay $59 and you get to increase your trades to 4 a round!

 

[GOAUS!]

It's Supercoach diamond package mate.
Basically you pay $59 and you get to increase your trades to 4 a round!

Judd Magic would run out of trades by Round 8!

 

[toxic]

It's Supercoach diamond package mate.
Basically you pay $59 and you get to increase your trades to 4 a round!

Judd_Magic has just become rather ROCK hard

 

[Krujan]

How many trades will you have left after this week Judd_Magic ?

 

[toxic]

Suban out...

Choice of heppell or Dixon to come in... but bloody who?

 

[christoff91]

Please help me!
Riewoldt, Cox, Bartel or Walker (who might be injured with hammy)?

 

[toxic]

Please help me!
Riewoldt, Cox, Bartel or Walker (who might be injured with hammy)?

Of those 4, bartel.... kinda depends on who else u have already tho

 

[Slawk]

Suban out...

Choice of heppell or Dixon to come in... but bloody who?

I'd say Heppell seems like the safer option.

Please help me!
Riewoldt, Cox, Bartel or Walker (who might be injured with hammy)?

If Walker plays tonight I'd go Walker. Then probably Cox, then Riewoldt - but for both of them I'd wanna wait until after their bye if you could (both possiblities to go down in price after this game, then a week off). Then Bartel last because of price/risk of being rested at some stage.

 

[Slawk]

Gibbs or Hibberd?

 

[Krujan]

Gibbs or Hibberd?

Pretty similar price & average. If I was bringing one of them in now, I'd probably choose Hibberd due to him being the more unique pick. Hibberd only 7% ownership compared to Gibbs 33%

 

[tubes82]

Kyle Martin v Tom Mitchell? Cant decide who to bring in. I am bringing in Hrovat next week after the bye