2013 Player/s X versus Y

[BuddysBuddy23]

Birchall or Duffield? Leaning towards the Duff

 

[Embleberry]

Birchall or Duffield? Leaning towards the Duff

Duffield hands down

 

[toxic]

Birchall or Duffield? Leaning towards the Duff

Birchall - averaging as much as duff, had 5 games over 100 compared to duffs 3, is 100K cheaper and does not have Ross f****n Lyon as his coach.

 

[karaoke]

Birchall or Duffield? Leaning towards the Duff

Do you have Hanley?

Similar coin to Duff, 516k v 515k,

10 pt higher ave ATM, would expect to be top 6 defenders at EOY,

Doesn't play got Ross Lyon (although he does play for Vossy )

Both due for further price drops over next 1-2 weeks though,

I'm actually trading in Birch this week, looking to Hanley in a few weeks, hopefully........

 

[toxic]

Do you have Hanley?

Similar coin to Duff, 516k v 515k,

10 pt higher ave ATM, would expect to be top 6 defenders at EOY,

Doesn't play got Ross Lyon (although he does play for Vossy )

Both due for further price drops over next 1-2 weeks though,

I'm actually trading in Birch this week, looking to Hanley in a few weeks, hopefully........

Same except will be gambling on Beau Waters and his dodgy hammy, quad, calf,groin,shoulder,hip,spine,balls,lung,kidney,little finger,big toe and ankle i think as a defensive POD, currently in 3.4% of teams

 

[Embleberry]

Birchall - averaging as much as duff, had 5 games over 100 compared to duffs 3, is 100K cheaper and does not have Ross f****n Lyon as his coach.

The only problem with Birch atm is his inconsistency. You can bank on Duff to go 70-80 on a bad week and 100+ on a good week. But Birchall is all over the shot I've got Duff tho so a bit biased, had him since the start
I think i'll do the highly popular Terlich > Birchall this week too FWIW. And plan to bring in Hanley possibly. Will have Goodes and Vlastuin as D5/6 so still unsure on Hanley.

 

[toxic]

The only problem with Birch atm is his inconsistency. You can bank on Duff to go 70-80 on a bad week and 100+ on a good week. But Birchall is all over the shot I've got Duff tho so a bit biased, had him since the start
I think i'll do the highly popular Terlich > Birchall this week too FWIW. And plan to bring in Hanley possibly. Will have Goodes and Vlastuin as D5/6 so still unsure on Hanley.

After this week I'll have:
Goddard, Gibbs, Ellis, Birchall, Vlastuin, Goodes, Heppell, Thurlow.
Using Vlastuin as a mid this week.

Someone will make way for GAJ in Rd 14.
Luxury items later on would be Beau Waters or heath Shaw but right now I'm pretty happy with that combo of defenders

 

[rocker_oz33]

Awalker V's Nroo
i like walker hes next 3 games are super tough hawks,swans,pies.
While roo form/scores dropped of abit.Is walker still the better pick for the rest of the year?
with walker low b/e i have to get him this week grrr.

 

[Daniels]

Awalker V's Nroo
i like walker hes next 3 games are super tough hawks,swans,pies.
While roo form/scores dropped of abit.Is walker still the better pick for the rest of the year?
with walker low b/e i have to get him this week grrr.

Walker

Iv'e had him now for 7 weeks and havn't looked back. Been really solid. Plays the "QB" role perfect.

 

[JPod_31]

Im upgrading Wines to a premium and i dont known who to choose between
Mitchell v Watson v Dangerfield v Cotchin

 

[Embleberry]

Im upgrading Wines to a premium and i dont known who to choose between
Mitchell v Watson v Dangerfield v Cotchin

Jobe out of that lot!

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Im upgrading Wines to a premium and i dont known who to choose between
Mitchell v Watson v Dangerfield v Cotchin

Don't do Jobe this week. He will drop a lot in price.

 

[JPod_31]

Don't do Jobe this week. He will drop a lot in price.

How much you think?

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

How much you think?

Well he has a BE of 206, that tells me he's gonna drop at least $38k if he scores 120.

 

[karaoke]

How much you think?

Footy Wire is predicting down to 551k, then 541k - this based on him scoring his exact 2013 average (115) in each of the next 2 games,

FWIW

 

[Kadog]

Griffen vs Deledio vs Cotchin??

 

[Jmac2225]

Griffen vs Deledio vs Cotchin??

Faced this dilemma this week. Went Cotchin for value but thinking of upgrading JBomb to Griffen next week for a bit of a PoD.

 

[stevebbb]

Thurlow or Neade???
one is out for a premium defender
the other will remain bench cover for the rest of the season

 

[Kadog]

Tr

Thurlow or Neade???
one is out for a premium defender
the other will remain bench cover for the rest of the season

Trade Neade.

 

[stevebbb]

Tr
Trade Neade.

cheers.
was thinking that, just hoping Thurlow keeps his spot for the year

 

[Stickers32]

Cotchin V K.Jack

Cheers

 

[Krujan]

Cotchin v Barlow?

If Barlow - 12 scores from Barlow, or 11 from Kieren Jack (plus a score from Staker/BenKen this week)?

Thinking beyond this week for a minute, Freo has 8 home games at Patersons + 2 easy away games Vs Dee's and Saints. They could realistically win 9-10 out of their last 12 games.

12 Brisbane Patersons Stadium
13 North Patersons Stadium
14 Geelong Simonds Stadium
15 St Kilda Patersons Stadium
16 West Coast Patersons Stadium
17 Richmond MCG
18 Adelaide Patersons Stadium
19 Carlton Etihad Stadium
20 GWS Giants Patersons Stadium
21 Melbourne MCG
22 Port Adelaide Patersons Stadium
23 St Kilda Etihad Stadium

Barlow is also much more unique than Cotchin (4% Vs 24% ownership)

Having said that, I'll probably go Fyfe over both of them.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Cotchin V K.Jack

Cheers

Very very interesting one. I say Jack over Cotchin.
Has been very very good this year and can only get better in a winning team oozing with confidence.

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Do you have Hanley?

Similar coin to Duff, 516k v 515k,

10 pt higher ave ATM, would expect to be top 6 defenders at EOY,

Doesn't play got Ross Lyon (although he does play for Vossy )

Both due for further price drops over next 1-2 weeks though,

I'm actually trading in Birch this week, looking to Hanley in a few weeks, hopefully........

Yes already have Hanley. Decided i'll go with Birchall over Duff as next week i'll need the cash to go O'Meara to Selwood. Leaving Vlastuin as my only non premium player on the field

 

[Stickers32]

Gotta question...

Is it worth trading Scotland for birchall period?

And is it worth trading Scotland to birchall just to make up the 18 players for next weeks bye round?