Mega Thread 2013: Trade Hypotheticals

[Tragic sainter]

Douglas signed a 3 year deal last year. So until the end of 2015. He's from Vic, but if he's signing a deal for that length of time, you'd assume he's perfectly happy there.

Fair enough. We just gone bent over in the Luke ball trade and I've wanted to bend someone over for a while.

 

[Igloo]

Fair enough. We just gone bent over in the Luke ball trade and I've wanted to bend someone over for a while.

Be wary, it can have horrible consequences (Jade Rawlings)

 

[saintsrfreak]

Give us back Tom Lynch and you can have Milera

 

[Matz]

Thomas to GC. Heard some whispers and praying they are true

Hes pretty close to his mum who lives in Melbourne so I doubt it but anything is possible I guess....Although I think it will be the blues.

 

[CutAboveTheRest]

Wouldn't be at all surprised if Milera get's delisted end of the year.

 

[saintsrfreak]

Wouldn't be at all surprised if Milera get's delisted end of the year.

Probably will be to be honest, we have a surplus of smalls and he's the oldest of the young bunch, a tad soft and inconsistent.

 

[Sydswans0512]

If Douglas chose to leave he would command a pick around 15-18 in my eyes he is fairly handy Milera on the other hand a pick around 50 would get it done

 

[5 GB USB]

If Douglas chose to leave he would command a pick around 15-18 in my eyes he is fairly handy Milera on the other hand a pick around 50 would get it done

I disagree, I'd keep my pick 50 over Milera.

 

[coniglio_number1]

Do gc need Thomas? JOM, ablett, prestia, swallow, Martin, Brennan, risca, campaigner, bennell, etc. Surely the money could be spent on retaining the current players eg JOM

 

[Sydswans0512]

I disagree, I'd keep my pick 50 over Milera.

So would I but we managed to offload TDL to the saints last year for pick 47 similar sort of trade. Saints will be kicking themselves tho I think we got Membrey with that.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

What kind of trade would interest you, if he were to come to St Kilda?

I have no idea to be honest - I'm guessing if it were to happen it would be for something like a third round pick?

Carlton unlikely to trade for picks and only trade for quality players, makes most sense to me. Whoever makes an approach, Carlton will ask for a quality player instead of picks.

I disagree with this.

If you read between the lines and have listened to what Swann has said over the past few weeks - we are looking to make some major changes to personnel and a large number of players will be turned over; I'm thinking somewhere around 8 players?

I doubt we'd be able to bring in another 8 quality listed/senior players ... we'll look to the draft as well and need to maximise our position within the first 2 rounds (and early third round).

 

[goodie23]

With all this quality SA talent in the up coming draft there's a few rumours about the Crows wanting to enter the first round with a few names being suggested for trade.

Or they could just wait and Ebert clubs in a few years

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Or they could just wait and Ebert clubs in a few years

They already did that to us and snared Jacobs.

 

[Silvagnis]

Hes pretty close to his mum who lives in Melbourne so I doubt it but anything is possible I guess....Although I think it will be the blues.

It will probably take Daisy two years to get his ankle right like Brock.

 

[TheJaegerBomb]

Do gc need Thomas? JOM, ablett, prestia, swallow, Martin, Brennan, risca, campaigner, bennell, etc. Surely the money could be spent on retaining the current players eg JOM

GWS fan telling us we have too much midfield talent. That's a tad hypocritical.

If we get Thomas either Brennan or Rischa will be disposed of.

 

[Bert Man]

GWS fan telling us we have too much midfield talent. That's a tad hypocritical.

If we get Thomas either Brennan or Rischa will be disposed of.

You could dispose of either if you get Thomas, but should definitely keep one. I would dispose of Rischa, he can be a very vanilla footballer at times, and it's needless to say Brennan isn't a vanilla footballer.

 

[Bert Man]

GWS fan telling us we have too much midfield talent. That's a tad hypocritical.

If we get Thomas either Brennan or Rischa will be disposed of.

You could dispose of either if you get Thomas, but should definitely keep one. I would dispose of Rischa, he can be a very vanilla footballer at times, and it's needless to say Brennan isn't a vanilla footballer.

 

[riolimagic]

I'd prefer A defender

what about we give west coast out first pick they give you Mitch brown and you give us Parker

 

[swansfan51]

what about we give west coast out first pick they give you Mitch brown and you give us Parker

If we trade Luke Parker for Mitch Brown we are being absolutely Milned.

 

[riolimagic]

If we trade Luke Parker for Mitch Brown we are being absolutely Milned.

well u said key defender you didn't say how good

 

[saintsrfreak]

So would I but we managed to offload TDL to the saints last year for pick 47 similar sort of trade. Saints will be kicking themselves tho I think we got Membrey with that.

Meh, TDL's been decent for us

 

[smashbox gill]

Pinot is not a representative of the rest of carlton bigfooty posters. I thnk most of us would know parker holds far far more value than matty watson.

One trade i would see as somewhat fair would be Watson for Membrey. I know he has only been on your list for 6 months but i see with ur gigantic forward line you may not be able to fit him in and will be surplus to your needs. Could add to our forward line and your depth in key defensive stocks

 

[TheJaegerBomb]

You could dispose of either if you get Thomas, but should definitely keep one. I would dispose of Rischa, he can be a very vanilla footballer at times, and it's needless to say Brennan isn't a vanilla footballer.

Brennan is a weird one. His best is great and his bad is really bad.

Rischa is just a shadow of his Brissy days. No idea what's going on with him.

 

[Sydswans0512]

Meh, TDL's been decent for us

I guess it's a win win situation then.

 

[Sydswans0512]

Pinot is not a representative of the rest of carlton bigfooty posters. I thnk most of us would know parker holds far far more value than matty watson.

One trade i would see as somewhat fair would be Watson for Membrey. I know he has only been on your list for 6 months but i see with ur gigantic forward line you may not be able to fit him in and will be surplus to your needs. Could add to our forward line and your depth in key defensive stocks

We'l see how Membrey goes this weekend