List Mgmt. 2015 LIST Discussion - trades, free agency etc

[thylacine60]

Someone on the Geelong board suggested Hendo and our 1st round pick, so Pick One, for Motlop. Yep. That's what they said.

I read that and had to walk outside for a while.

 

[thylacine60]

Where do we sign.

Do they need one of my kidneys to get it over the line?

You utter laughoid! Gold.

 

[Broadside]

Where do we sign?

Do they need one of my kidneys to get it over the line?

we should do this before the premiership window closes, imagine Motlop and Daisy running rampant in our forward line, crumbing off Liam Jones and fed lace out by Ed Curnow and David Ellard.

 

[thylacine60]

please kill me

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

please kill me

NO!

 

[FoeverBlues]

Shame if Hendo has fallen out of favour. I would be making him skipper and rebuilding around him, Doc, Kreuzer and Cripps.

If Hendo was on the market, would we trade our first rounder for him?????

i would.

 

[thylacine60]

NO!

that's cruel

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

that's cruel

If I have to suffer then so do you!

 

[thylacine60]

geez

 

[Wickzki]

If Hendo was on the market, would we trade our first rounder for him?????

i would.

Typical Carlton trade. Carlton's first for Hendo.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

If Hendo was on the market, would we trade our first rounder for him?????

i would.

Not on this years form

 

[Madblue]

If Hendo was on the market, would we trade our first rounder for him?????

i would.

When you put it like that then the answer is No.

 

[1981]

If Hendo was on the market, would we trade our first rounder for him?????

i would.

Borderline

Will kick the odd bag of 4 or 5, which not many players can do, but with the same token he is not a power forward who can take big strong contested marks and kick goals from these marks. He gets most of his goals from marks on the lead and oddly enough also from plays on the run. He is a good key forward but not a great one.

Similarly, as a key defender he does his best work when playing loose down back. As a 1-on-1 defender he is actually not that great. Jamison is better body on body.

Hendo for me is a 7/10 KPP.

Now, you could argue even a 7/10 KPP is worth gold as god KPPs are hard to find. So I guess it is very much a subjective thing, whether one thinks he is worth a 1st rounder. Age wise I think he is still young enough though he is pretty injury prone.

Another way to put it is, if you had a good midfield and flankers and rucks and good depth on your list, and were well coached, if you had x4 Hendos as your KPPs would you think you could win a premiership?

I wouldn't mind 4 Hendos as my 4 KPPs ... you could do worse ...

 

[Big Sim]

Henderson is better than Frawley so yes he is worth a first rounder. If its Geelong's at about 12-14 I would be asking for Josh Walker as knives.

 

[1981]

Like the Hendo as captain idea
He's probably the most vocal of the leaders

Can he stay on the park though??

 

[lachie charm]

Geelong gave pick 21 for Stanley. I'd imagine they'd give a fair amount more for Lachie.

 

[rp84]

Henderson is better than Frawley so yes he is worth a first rounder. If its Geelong's at about 12-14 I would be asking for Josh Walker as knives.

I want Corey Gregson and their first

 

[DaVillaBlues]

Lets bring in big Will Minson in as a delisted free agent, we ain't gonna get a better ready made ruckman out there ..

 

[RAPPA]

Someone on the Geelong board suggested Hendo and our 1st round pick, so Pick One, for Motlop. Yep. That's what they said.

Does Motlop come with his 10-12 standard drinks?

 

[Paulski19]

Lets bring in big Will Minson in as a delisted free agent, we ain't gonna get a better ready made ruckman out there ..

I just vomited in my mouth a little bit.

Heard a rumour that Hendo could be a straight swap for James Aish. Would love to keep him...would also love to see a player of Aish's ability at the club...

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

I just vomited in my mouth a little bit.

Heard a rumour that Hendo could be a straight swap for James Aish. Would love to keep him...would also love to see a player of Aish's ability at the club...

Would rather Geelongs pick 12

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Lets bring in big Will Minson in as a delisted free agent, we ain't gonna get a better ready made ruckman out there ..

I actually dont mind this, especially if Kruezar leaves via FA

 

[Paulski19]

Would rather Geelongs pick 12

As long as we actually used it wisely. At least with Aish, you'd know what you were getting.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

As long as we actually used it wisely. At least with Aish, you'd know what you were getting.

No you dont, he is still just spruik.. has played a handfull of good games in his first year and this year has been in and out of the side.

I would rather us pick 12 to pick up Nick O'Kearney

 

[ferrisb]

Where do we sign?

Does Tom Lonergan need one of my kidneys to get it over the line?

EFA