2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[PoopingHindi]

So Simpson over Smith?
Interested to get some opinions on this. Have smith ATM, haven't had Simpson for the past two seasons, and my thoughts on him usually range from "damn I wish I had him this week" to "thank f*** I don't have him" when he spuds it up
As it stands, my back line is Smith, Shaw, Gibson, Newnes, Pearce, Rookie

i really like this backline. going to start with it as my base and see what the rest of my team ends up looking like, although i'll probably have to make too many sacrifices in other areas to make it work

 

[CotchyPls]

Fyfe, Sloane and T.Mitch V Beams(or Sloane), A.Swallow and Buddy

 

[TN25]

Fyfe, Sloane and T.Mitch V Beams, A.Swallow and Buddy

125 + 110 + 85 V 120 + 95 + 100

So option 1 will score slightly more IMO

 

[HTPunter]

Fyfe, Sloane and T.Mitch V Beams(or Sloane), A.Swallow and Buddy

The first one has the mids, but I wouldn't be picking Mitchell, so taking into account Sydneys start to the year I'd be picking the 2nd option.

For me: Beams, Shiel & Goldstein v Kennedy, Sloane & Naitanui...

 

[karaoke]

125 + 110 + 85 V 120 + 105 + 100

So option 1 will score slightly more IMO

IMO

ASwallow, has a 4 yr ave of 105, inc his 93 ave of last year.

I reckon he'll ave slightly more than this even (107-110).

 

[TN25]

IMO

ASwallow, has a 4 yr ave of 105, inc his 93 ave of last year.

I reckon he'll ave slightly more than this even (107-110).

He's on the down I feel. This'll be his last year he'll be relevant in SC probably

 

[Lums23]

He's on the down I feel. This'll be his last year he'll be relevant in SC probably

What makes you think that?

 

[TN25]

What makes you think that?

Just can't see him being a main part of your midfield for much longer.

 

[Lums23]

Just can't see him being a main part of your midfield for much longer.

I don't know about that, he was easily our best clearance player when he came back

 

[Jiska]

Jelwood vs Fyfe vs Beams vs Sloane vs Kennedy

Need to pick one and sick of tossing a coin

 

[TN25]

Jelwood vs Fyfe vs Beams vs Sloane vs Kennedy

Need to pick one and sick of tossing a coin

Jelwood. Always delivers and is a reasonable price

 

[Krujan]

Jelwood vs Fyfe vs Beams vs Sloane vs Kennedy

Need to pick one and sick of tossing a coin

Geelong play 3 of their first 4 games at Simonds, so Selwood for me.

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Jelwood vs Fyfe vs Beams vs Sloane vs Kennedy

Need to pick one and sick of tossing a coin

Selwood>Fyfe>Beams>Sloane>Kennedy IMO

 

[rocker_oz33]

Aswallow V BCrouch V JSteven V LNeale V DTyson please.

 

[anfa18]

Just can't see him being a main part of your midfield for much longer.

North have a few aging mids in Harvey 35, Dal Santo 31 and Wells 30... Swallow is 27, the captain and a clearance machine, i'm sure he'll be around in the mids for a few years to come.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Sutcliffe v. Pittard

 

[Big Fozza]

Aswallow V BCrouch V JSteven V LNeale V DTyson please.

ASwallow for me. Think he was playing injured last year and see him going 105-110 this year. I personally have steven but just for the extra money

 

[Big Fozza]

Sutcliffe v. Pittard

Why are you considering either if these blokes? Not being an ass, serious question. I've seen their names tossed around a bit and mustbe missing something

 

[Viva la Mattner]

JPK v Gibbs

B.Ebert v Boak (cheaper option allowing an upgrade in another area)

 

[saint_nick]

JPK v Gibbs

B.Ebert v Boak (cheaper option allowing an upgrade in another area)

Jpk by a country mile!

Boak over ebert although boaks scoring is like a heart monitor...

 

[Kishkobi]

Martin vs Goldy as my R1

Ryder vs NN vs Maric as my R2

 

[The Grover]

Taylor v Thompson

Salem v Lennon

 

[Lums23]

Aswallow V BCrouch V JSteven V LNeale V DTyson please.

I'd rank them in that order

 

[rocker_oz33]

Taylor v Thompson

Salem v Lennon

Harry and Salem for mine.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Why are you considering either if these blokes? Not being an ass, serious question. I've seen their names tossed around a bit and mustbe missing something

I reckon these two are big chances of breaking out this season. Both playing rebounding roles of half back. Pittard has looked impressive from limited game time in NAB. He averaged 80 over his last 9 games last year looks to have improved his kicking which will help his scoring.

Freo rate sutcliffe highly. If Duffield is out I think he could pick up some points filling in that role. Both risky picks but just reckon one or even both could have breakout years. Port don't really have a rebounding half back (only Broadbent) so leaning towards Pittard