List Mgmt. 2015 Trade, Free agency and draft rumours

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Would Carlisle agree to come to us after settling on St Kilda? There's still plenty of trade period of for St Kilda to come around to trading pick 5.

Also Carlisle claimed the whole reason he wanted to go to St Kilda was so that he could come through at the bottom and help a young side reach a flag rather than join a Hawthorn who are already established. The possibility that he could serve a drugs ban, and that he's a apparently a massive flog aside, do we really want a player whose motivation isn't aligned with ours and never had his heart set on joining us?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

So, it goes like this:

1. Sign Carlisle
2. Roll over on the WADA case, dob in all the Essendon players (and Hird)
3. Take a 3 month penalty, reduced to Nil for cooperation
4. ?
5. Profit
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Would Carlisle agree to come to us after settling on St Kilda? There's still plenty of trade period of for St Kilda to come around to trading pick 5.

Also Carlisle claimed the whole reason he wanted to go to St Kilda was so that he could come through at the bottom and help a young side reach a flag rather than join a Hawthorn who are already established. The possibility that he could serve a drugs ban, and that he's a apparently a massive flog aside, do we really want a player whose motivation isn't aligned with ours and never had his heart set on joining us?

First tier quality CHB with lots of good years ahead.
Yup, we'll take him!
 
First tier quality CHB with lots of good years ahead.
Yup, we'll take him!
I agree he'll be a good pick up if he comes and will have more of an immediate impact on our 2016 chances than Anderson likely could. Just mildly concerned about Carlisle's motivations not aligning with Hawthorns or that it's just a cover for his real motivation (ie. money).

I trust that if Clarko speaks to him that the right decision will be reached.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top