2019 Player X v Y v Z

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Darling v Chad

Has to be Chad

Darling for a POD

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Darling v Chad

Chad for mine. Don’t think he’s chance to play mid (With Titch going down) is as high as some on here may believe but still think he will be a decent fwd option and avg over 90. Think he will predominantly play fwd with the odd hit out through the middle. I see the percentages being something like 75/25 fwd/mid. In saying that, I can still see him averaging 20 disposals and a goal or two a game. Have big hopes on him as a Hawks fan

 

[SterlingArcher]

860 for a D3 and F4.

A couple of combos would be
A) Z.Williams & a speculative forward (Billings, Parfitt, Curnow, Worpel)
OR
B) Hanley/Roberton (one at D3 & other one at D4) & Heeney

Both options leave with me approx 40-70k (depending on who I pick), although I could go Greene at F4 and have 100k left over which I feel is important if I'm picking a couple of possible 'fix-its' in the first 2-3 rounds (i.e. Kreuzer...).

I'm leaning option B because I feel more confident in Hanley/Roberton than the forward speculative picks, plus at this early stage (and seemingly most years) defender rookies seem to bat deeper than forwards (Doedee, Murray etc last year meant a lighter backline wasn't setting you back too much).

 

[JustInsideFifty]

Not sure if Gawn can back up what he produced last year. Toying around with Kreuzer to see what else I could do to my side with the spare coin. Have just enough leftover money to change Smith to Williams if I want. Gawn is less risk than Kreuzer. But I can see Gawn’s avg dropping and Kreuzer’s rising. By how much no one knows. Hopefully the gap is bridged enough that my upgrades from rookies to mid pricers/potential keepers is covered by the Gawn/Kreuzer difference in avg. Someone(Can’t remember who) posted in one of the threads they are running a different setup then previous years as they have finished top 2k regularly but can’t make ground on the front runners due to having the same team as many others come the mid-late part of the season. I’m in a similar boat. Normally finish pretty high(Top 5k ever since I’ve started playing) haven’t played for a couple years but the last year I played I finished 93rd overall(Was top 10 for a stretch of 6-7 weeks towards the end-Even won the weekly top score along the way), but couldn’t make ground on #1 overall fielding a very similar side. A few risks this year and who knows what can happen. It could well work, or all end in tears. That’s the beauty of this game

FWIW I agree on Gawn. If I had to guess, I'd say he goes at around 115 and he's far from a sure thing to play every game. Still, I don't see any other ruck (other than Reg) averaging higher, so he's probably saving you a trade anyway.
If you're good enough at SC that you finish that high consistently, you're unlikely to find the answer to finishing #1 on a forum anyway . You're more likely to be put off your "gut feel" or POD picks.

 

[Kadog]

Sicily Brouch Gawn Gray vs
Blakely Macrae Goldy Wingard

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Sicily Brouch Gawn Gray vs
Blakely Macrae Goldy Wingard

Option one. The Italian stallion ball hawking the footy down back sets your side up niiiiicely

 

[Dark Sharks]

Gawn and Libba + $$

Vs

Hoff and Zerrett/Martin

 

[King_Steele]

Sicily Brouch Gawn Gray vs
Blakely Macrae Goldy Wingard

1st option

Gawn and Libba + $$


Vs

Hoff and Zerrett/Martin

Gawn & Libba

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Miles & Libba
v
Zerrett/Mrouch/Beams & Mid rookie

 

[Keg on legs]

Darling v Chad

Chode

 

[Keg on legs]

Williams, quaynor, zerrett, maxxx and chad

Vs

Simmo, hore, steele, goldy and heeney

 

[Huttabito]

Williams, quaynor, zerrett, maxxx and chad

Vs

Simmo, hore, steele, goldy and heeney

1

 

[King_Steele]

Williams, quaynor, zerrett, maxxx and chad

Vs

Simmo, hore, steele, goldy and heeney

1st option

 

[Keg on legs]

Miles & Libba
v
Zerrett/Mrouch/Beams & Mid rookie

If fit, zerrett easily. An underpriced keeper

 

[Keg on legs]

Ok in that case then kenties

Gawn, chad and billings

Goldy, lunchmeat and heeney

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Ok in that case then kenties

Gawn, chad and billings

Goldy, lunchmeat and heeney

Anything but Billings

 

[Keg on legs]

Anything but Billings

Haha


Very true. Can't believe I'm even considering him tbh

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Haha


Very true. Can't believe I'm even considering him tbh

My team is as midpriced bullshit as you can get and even Im not considering him

 

[Red Syrah]

For onfield:
z.wililams + $124K def rookie
vs
B.Smith + T. Williamson

 

[Keg on legs]

For onfield:
z.wililams + $124K def rookie
vs
B.Smith + T. Williamson

1st one

 

[Kadog]

Sicily Brouch vs Roberton Macrae

 

[Blaknight]

Whitfield v Laird

 

[King_Steele]

Sicily Brouch vs Roberton Macrae

Roberton & Macrae

Whitfield v Laird

Laird

 

[Red Syrah]

wingard v worple to pick up the missing Mitchell dsiplosals?

 

[King_Steele]

wingard v worple to pick up the missing Mitchell dsiplosals?

Wingard easily