2019 Player X v Y v Z

[Keg on legs]

The Chad

Witherden vs Blakely

Cogs vs Neale

Withers and neale

 

[King_Steele]

The Chad

Witherden vs Blakely

Cogs vs Neale

Blakely
Neale

 

[Keg on legs]

Miles v Libba
SexyRobbie v Chad
Piggerd v Roberton

Libba
Sexy robbie
A half eaten potato cake is better than piggerd, so robbo easily

 

[Keg on legs]

Williams and sexy robbie / dunkley

Vs

Lairdy and gresh / parshit?

 

[King_Steele]

Williams and sexy robbie / dunkley

Vs

Lairdy and gresh / parshit?

1st option

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Neale, Def Rookie & 76k
V
Libba, B.Smith & 174k

 

[King_Steele]

Neale, Def Rookie & 76k
V
Libba, B.Smith & 174k

1st option

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

1st option

Interested in your thoughts regarding option 1 over option 2 Bob Cobb. I see Neale avg 115 and def Rookie 55(170 between them) and Libba 90 with Smith 85(175). Now that’s obviously just my opinion. As you can see I think they’re fairly close in comparison but the extra 100k is handy no doubt. Obviously also depends on who that def Rookie could be. They could come out and avg 70 but I’m leaning on the lower side of avg’s for all 4 of these players(And the fact that def rookies seem to avg less than mid rookies etc). I think all of Libba, Smith and Neale have worthy merit to be selected. Libba and Smith underpriced, Neale with the chance up in Brisbane to be the #1 scorer stepping out of Fyfe’s shadow.

 

[ArdentEagle]

L.Parker and Z.Clarke vs T.Goldstein and H.Bennell?

 

[toxic]

Harris Andrews vs. Alex Witherden

Brisbane = no

 

[toxic]

L.Parker and Z.Clarke vs T.Goldstein and H.Bennell?

L.Parker and Z.Clarke vs T.Goldstein and H.Bennell?

No

 

[SterlingArcher]

Interested in your thoughts regarding option 1 over option 2 Bob Cobb. I see Neale avg 115 and def Rookie 55(170 between them) and Libba 90 with Smith 85(175). Now that’s obviously just my opinion. As you can see I think they’re fairly close in comparison but the extra 100k is handy no doubt. Obviously also depends on who that def Rookie could be. They could come out and avg 70 but I’m leaning on the lower side of avg’s for all 4 of these players(And the fact that def rookies seem to avg less than mid rookies etc). I think all of Libba, Smith and Neale have worthy merit to be selected. Libba and Smith underpriced, Neale with the chance up in Brisbane to be the #1 scorer stepping out of Fyfe’s shadow.

Libba and Smith are both stepping stones though. Most people would prefer the safe option (Neale 3x 110 years missing 1 game in that time) and 1 upgrade, over 2 awkward upgrades.

The extra 100k does make it interesting though.

 

[ArdentEagle]

No

Believe it or not, I need it for team balance.

I have $716700 and need a ruck and M6/Rookie.
What would be your choice mate?

 

[toxic]

Believe it or not, I need it for team balance.

I have $716700 and need a ruck and M6/Rookie.
What would be your choice mate?

Goldy and a rookie

Bewley

 

[ArdentEagle]

Goldy and a rookie

Bewley

Already have Bewley on the pine.
From what I've think I've heard, it sounds like Bennell is going well.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Already have Bewley on the pine.
From what I've think I've heard, it sounds like Bennell is going well.

Put Harlz there for now until his ultimate melt/break down.

 

[ArdentEagle]

Put Harlz there for now until his ultimate melt/break down.

Yep - Every part of my fibre tells me not to do it yet here I am still considering it.
Is he the real deal or a Thailand special that has a not so happy ending??

 

[Hai_Newman]

Yep - Every part of my fibre tells me not to do it yet here I am still considering it.
Is he the real deal or a Thailand special that has a not so happy ending??

View attachment 611209

Ummm....WAT was the question?

 

[ArdentEagle]

Ummm....WAT was the question?

Harley Bennell - Real deal or not?

 

[Hai_Newman]

Yep - Every part of my fibre tells me not to do it yet here I am still considering it.
Is he the real deal or a Thailand special that has a not so happy ending??

View attachment 611209

Oh yes Harley...

I reckon he's a lock at that price and well worth risk...now cont...

 

[ArdentEagle]

Oh yes Harley...

I reckon he's a lock at that price and well worth risk...now cont...

Not bad for a Lady Boy....Very hard to tell sometimes! Just like Harley.

 

[Jonzi]

Goldy + Oliver or
Gawn + Wingard

 

[Asho81]

Hanners Vs Libba Vs Miles


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Asho81]

Goldy + Oliver or
Gawn + Wingard

Goldy Oliver for me


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Red Syrah]

Steele v JOM v Sloane