Teams 2019 Rate My Pre-Season Team

[Son_Of_God29]

Any Assistance would be much appreciated

 

[go you pups]

Got a feeling I'll do a massive brainfart today and stuff my team up as I haven't settled on it at all aside from my rucks and going 4 premos 1 midpricer in the mids or 5 premo mids (pretty similar structure there)

I'll post two versions that I'm comfortableish with then decide on what's more cookie cutter I guess

Or

 

[Judd_Magic]

View attachment 638404View attachment 638403View attachment 638402

Or

View attachment 638407View attachment 638406View attachment 638405

I like the second team way more mate.

 

[go you pups]

Hold your nerve, last minute changes will
haunt you all year.

Yeah it screwed me up in DT last year, played the catch up game but peaked just after the byes and plateaued

Anyways, the two teams above are the ones I'd roll with GnR vs the more value team

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

I am set.

See you later campaigners

 

[Metapod]

Good old Guns and Rookies. 13 keepers Locked and Loaded.
**** Mid-Price Madness.
$55k left over for inevitable ****-ups.

BRING ON THE FOOTY!

View attachment 638386

Balta Captain

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

Here it is lads. Bit too much cash sitting on my DEF bench, but hopefully they make bank.

 

[JRyan23]

VERY similar to myself. Exactly the same structure

I am happy with my team would love to maybe have a Laird at D1 but I feel Hurn's game will only improve this year, and unless i downgrade Macrae or Grundy, all I can afford is Hurn. I like having the 4 premo forwards

 

[Red Syrah]

Okay - last minute tweaks coming up: $80K in the bank

1. Considering bringing Oliver in, but like top 4 so then it would be Brouch+Libba > Oliver + rookie
2. Considering bringing Telly in at F3 - but who to drop? Darling or Billings? I think Darling has the highest ceiling and most risk and Billings ???
3. Should I trade out both Moore/Burgess (if 1 goes both goes bc value in DPP) and upgrade Moore > mid pricer?

 

[go you pups]

Here it is lads. Bit too much cash sitting on my DEF bench, but hopefully they make bank.


View attachment 638420

Will Hore get a gig?

I see you're not selecting him

 

[go you pups]

Bailey Scott to debut

There's one for potential M8 duties

 

[jd2010]

go you pups thoughts on this?

DEF: Lloyd, Hurn, Williams, Collins, Clark, Scrimshaw (Burgess and Hore)
MID: Macrae, Cripps, Oliver, Martin, M.Crouch, Walsh, Butters, Constable (Gibbons, Drew and Scott)
RUCK: Grawndy
FWD: Danger, Heeney, SPS, Moore, Setterfield, Balta (Petrucelle and Parker)

Really wanted to get either Parfitt or Taranto into my squad but going a bit safer in midfield with Crouch over Taranto. My other way to fit them in was going slightly cheaper at D1 and D2. But I only really want 2-3 mid price risks and I’m more comfortable doing that with Williams, Moore and SPS

 

[joop]

Finally happy with my team (pending rookie selections). Give me some feedback that I plan to ignore. CheersView attachment 638235

On SM-G955F using BigFooty.com mobile app

No point having Dunkley in the mids when he's a FWD.
Get rid of Billings, chuck Dunkley FWD and then get a mid.
I'd probably go Goldy over Westoff too.

 

[GenuineMatchWinner]

Bailey Scott to debut

There's one for potential M8 duties

Awesome now just waiting to hear on Constable

 

[GenuineMatchWinner]

go you pups thoughts on this?

DEF: Lloyd, Hurn, Williams, Collins, Clark, Scrimshaw (Burgess and Hore)
MID: Macrae, Cripps, Oliver, Martin, M.Crouch, Walsh, Butters, Constable (Gibbons, Drew and Scott)
RUCK: Grawndy
FWD: Danger, Heeney, SPS, Moore, Setterfield, Balta (Petrucelle and Parker)

Really wanted to get either Parfitt or Taranto into my squad but going a bit safer in midfield with Crouch over Taranto. My other way to fit them in was going slightly cheaper at D1 and D2. But I only really want 2-3 mid price risks and I’m more comfortable doing that with Williams, Moore and SPS

SPS is an interesting buy, like him as a player and can see him being relevent in SC terms soon, maybe not yet though. Overall a pretty solid looking side

 

[go you pups]

go you pups thoughts on this?

DEF: Lloyd, Hurn, Williams, Collins, Clark, Scrimshaw (Burgess and Hore)
MID: Macrae, Cripps, Oliver, Martin, M.Crouch, Walsh, Butters, Constable (Gibbons, Drew and Scott)
RUCK: Grawndy
FWD: Danger, Heeney, SPS, Moore, Setterfield, Balta (Petrucelle and Parker)

Really wanted to get either Parfitt or Taranto into my squad but going a bit safer in midfield with Crouch over Taranto. My other way to fit them in was going slightly cheaper at D1 and D2. But I only really want 2-3 mid price risks and I’m more comfortable doing that with Williams, Moore and SPS

I've got SPS on my bench in draft, could get a rise from him hopefully, though be prepared he could burn you too

One of my 2 squads I've settled on is very similar in structure to your team, just I didn't pick Macrae, he's a Brayshaw type and the extra cash has gone to F3 for Dunkley

Also feel you'll need Duursma somewhere, but shouldn't be hard to squeeze him in


Other than that, the team can work, alot of similar structured teams out there

 

[Metapod]

Dusty’s back in. Seeing Lynch in the squad warms my heart and I’ve gotta back my gut that Dusty will be launching it down his throat all season. Team was set but ultimately went Fyfe > Dusty to fund Moore > Greene. Greene has potential to be top 6 & I’m hoping Dusty can match Fyfe without the durability ???s.

 

[jd2010]

I've got SPS on my bench in draft, could get a rise from him hopefully, though be prepared he could burn you too

One of my 2 squads I've settled on is very similar in structure to your team, just I didn't pick Macrae, he's a Brayshaw type and the extra cash has gone to F3 for Dunkley

I’m giving SPS the first two to show what I think he can do being a permanent midfielder. The thought with the pick is for him to have a 2018 Zac Fisher type rise in scoring moving in there more (so 20-25 up on LY).

Is macrae not worth the extra $$$? Is there a decent chance he only averages 100-110 and drops in value early? A macrae to Taranto swap would allow me to turn Parker into Parfitt and have a very settled forward line.

 

[rocker_oz33]

View attachment 638414

I am set.

See you later campaigners

Pity there not many DPP players .
Having one in the mid in your team would handy with the chol like forward line would give you some flexibility there.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Pity there not many DPP players .
Having one in the mid in your team would handy with the chol like forward line would give you some flexibility there.

yep, real bummer this year.

I could technically move drew to Gibbons' position and get someone else in

 

[Sainter93]

Would love some advice on what to do from here. Defence is a little under done but the forward line has been a SC weakness for a long time now.

Also unsure whether to get Sam Walsh in.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Think l will run with this, some cash in the bank for some flex .
[

 

[go you pups]

I’m giving SPS the first two to show what I think he can do being a permanent midfielder. The thought with the pick is for him to have a 2018 Zac Fisher type rise in scoring moving in there more (so 20-25 up on LY).

Is macrae not worth the extra $$$? Is there a decent chance he only averages 100-110 and drops in value early? A macrae to Taranto swap would allow me to turn Parker into Parfitt and have a very settled forward line.

I feel Macrae had a career year last year and he's only just an upgrade target for me

Should be in the top 8 mids conversation still though, but will look at getting him for low 600s midseason

Reckon if Bont had an injury free, midfield heavy role all season he'd bust 120+ out too. But the chopping and changing of him from forward to mid stuffs his consistency up

Going by weight of numbers, I don't think Parfitt will be close to Danger, Menegola or Kelly, they're the only Cats forwards I'd look at for now. How are the points going to be shared for example too in their midfield/forward rotations? Danger, Menegola, Kelly, Hawkins, Dahlhaus, Parfitt, Gazza, Jelwood, Duncan etc

They're simply loaded. Scoring history is with Danger and Menegola, while Kelly looks to have the better scoring role than Parfitt I'd say too.

 

[JRyan23]

I’m second guessing myself guys ****. Big query

Whitfield, Collins, Neale: 15k in bank
or
Hurn, Moore, Cogs: 2k in bank




On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[rocker_oz33]

Would love some advice on what to do from here. Defence is a little under done but the forward line has been a SC weakness for a long time now.

Also unsure whether to get Sam Walsh in.

View attachment 638448

View attachment 638450

Every team will have a weak spot in it thats a given at the start of the season.
Your mids , rucks and forward are pretty strong.

Given Walsh price he has to score more than the cheap rooks.