Thats a pretty good side too
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
2020 best 22 discussion
- Thread starter heavho
- Start date
- Tagged users None
No Hogan?
Barra_Mundy
Rookie
- Nov 27, 2018
- 32
- 67
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Tasmania
You don't rate Hogan?
Probably should of stated that this is the B22 that I predict to see named come R1 all variables considered.
Fair enough. I think Jesse's doing pretty well btw. I know we've all been burnt with the whole Bennell injury crap but the signs look brighter for Hoges. He;s really confident he's going to be ok.
I hope so, but what's happening with him and the commentary around how his rehabilitation is progressing is literally the same story as this time last year during the off-season. "Yeah the foot is tracking better than expected" is what they tell us, until it inevitably gets injured again during the season. Easier to just think about him not playing
- Apr 16, 2014
- 10,410
- 23,358
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Logue - Hamling - Ryan
Wilson - Pearce - Aish
Acres - Brayshaw - SHill
Walters - Hogan - Switta
Matera - Taberner - Henry
Darcy - Fyfe - Tucker
Lobb - Mundy - Conca - Cerra
Peel
Hughes - Watson - xxxxx
Carter - O'Reilly - Duman
Giro - Blakely - Crowden
Sturt - Dixon - McCarthy
Schulz - Cox - xxxxx
Meek - Banfield - Valente
Bewley - Colyer - Pick 7 - Pick 10
Wilson - Pearce - Aish
Acres - Brayshaw - SHill
Walters - Hogan - Switta
Matera - Taberner - Henry
Darcy - Fyfe - Tucker
Lobb - Mundy - Conca - Cerra
Peel
Hughes - Watson - xxxxx
Carter - O'Reilly - Duman
Giro - Blakely - Crowden
Sturt - Dixon - McCarthy
Schulz - Cox - xxxxx
Meek - Banfield - Valente
Bewley - Colyer - Pick 7 - Pick 10
Looks about right but Blakely is a big omission. Pick 7, Pick 10, Henry and Sturt will probably be given opportunities.
Our two Category B rookies conveniently cover both spots you’ve put down xxxxx. Probably gives us extra flexibility in terms of our final two list spots, assuming picks 7 and 10 are mids.
- Apr 16, 2014
- 10,410
- 23,358
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Yeah, couldn't believe I was leaving out Blakely tbh. But would be harsh to put him ahead of Conca, Tucker or Brayshaw considering they all had the better seasons. Cerra potentially could make way for him but think we need to keep pumping games into him and start exposing him to more midfield minutes.
Peel is going to have a very good midfield if we don't have too many injuries. It actually looks like a really well balanced side, can see Peel doing very well.
And yeah, Thomas and Butters have their names all over those last two spots.
Wally Walpamur
Norm Smith Medallist
- Sep 23, 2016
- 6,150
- 11,930
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
FB: Hughes - Hamling - Logue
HB: Wilson - Pearce - Ryan
C: Hill - Acres - Aish
HF: Walters - Tabs - McCarthy
FF: Lobb - Hogan - Henry
FOLL: Darcy - Fyfe - Mundy
INT: Conca - Brayshaw - Tucker - Cerra
HB: Wilson - Pearce - Ryan
C: Hill - Acres - Aish
HF: Walters - Tabs - McCarthy
FF: Lobb - Hogan - Henry
FOLL: Darcy - Fyfe - Mundy
INT: Conca - Brayshaw - Tucker - Cerra
Usung Wally’s as a base as I mostly agree;
FB: Hughes - Hamling - Logue
HB: Wilson - Pearce - Ryan
C: Hill - Fyfe - Aish
HF: Walters - McCarthy - Sturt
FF: Lobb - Hogan - Henry
FOLL: Darcy - Brayshaw - Tucker
INT: Conca - Pick 7 - Duman - Cerra
I prefer a smaller more mobile forward line. I’m predicting Duman to step up this year, so too Sturt and I think pick 7 will most likely be Robertson who will play year 1, so too Henry.
FB: Hughes - Hamling - Logue
HB: Wilson - Pearce - Ryan
C: Hill - Fyfe - Aish
HF: Walters - McCarthy - Sturt
FF: Lobb - Hogan - Henry
FOLL: Darcy - Brayshaw - Tucker
INT: Conca - Pick 7 - Duman - Cerra
I prefer a smaller more mobile forward line. I’m predicting Duman to step up this year, so too Sturt and I think pick 7 will most likely be Robertson who will play year 1, so too Henry.
Confucius
Senior List
- Jan 7, 2016
- 182
- 598
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Backline picks itself. Solid AF.
Aish Pearce Logue
Ryan Hamling Wilson
Midfield is where it gets interesting... so many options. I really liked Lobb playing Ruck this year. I think he offers heaps more around the ground than Darcy. I'd Give Darcy a bit more time to develop which allows us to play an extra tall forward who knows that if he doesn't perform he'll be gone. Cerra and Hill running off the wings delivering lace out to the forward line (both are wasted in defence IMO) I'd rather Mundy rotating through defence. It's a young group but Mundy, Conca and Acres rotating off the bench and walters rotating from the forward line.
Lobb Fyfe Brayshaw
Hill Blakely Cerra
Hogan high CHF. Walters rotating through the midfield. Cox and Darcy itching for a spot, these blokes better kick some goalz.
Walters Hogan McCarthy
Matera Taberner Henry
Bench: Mundy, Acres, Conca, Pick 7
Mundy can play literally any position but I'd really love him to spend some time in the backline, intercept marking and directing traffic.
I'd love us to play Henry and pick 7 straight up ahead of Tucker who I do't really rate, or Colyer but round 1 is a long way away.
Depth: Duman, Hughes, Cox, Darcy, Colyer, Tucker, Banfield, Bewley, Swita, Pick 10.
I reckon that's a pretty solid side. Backline is solid and the forward line could light things up with a slightly more attacking gameplan. Lacks a bit of genuine A grade in the guts but who knows how much Cerra and Brayshaw will step up next year and we still have Mundy who can slot in anytime. And of course Stephen Hill is one of the most underrated players in AFL history. Tucker and Bewley could surprise me too.
Fingers crossed for an injury free pre season... Happy days.
Aish Pearce Logue
Ryan Hamling Wilson
Midfield is where it gets interesting... so many options. I really liked Lobb playing Ruck this year. I think he offers heaps more around the ground than Darcy. I'd Give Darcy a bit more time to develop which allows us to play an extra tall forward who knows that if he doesn't perform he'll be gone. Cerra and Hill running off the wings delivering lace out to the forward line (both are wasted in defence IMO) I'd rather Mundy rotating through defence. It's a young group but Mundy, Conca and Acres rotating off the bench and walters rotating from the forward line.
Lobb Fyfe Brayshaw
Hill Blakely Cerra
Hogan high CHF. Walters rotating through the midfield. Cox and Darcy itching for a spot, these blokes better kick some goalz.
Walters Hogan McCarthy
Matera Taberner Henry
Bench: Mundy, Acres, Conca, Pick 7
Mundy can play literally any position but I'd really love him to spend some time in the backline, intercept marking and directing traffic.
I'd love us to play Henry and pick 7 straight up ahead of Tucker who I do't really rate, or Colyer but round 1 is a long way away.
Depth: Duman, Hughes, Cox, Darcy, Colyer, Tucker, Banfield, Bewley, Swita, Pick 10.
I reckon that's a pretty solid side. Backline is solid and the forward line could light things up with a slightly more attacking gameplan. Lacks a bit of genuine A grade in the guts but who knows how much Cerra and Brayshaw will step up next year and we still have Mundy who can slot in anytime. And of course Stephen Hill is one of the most underrated players in AFL history. Tucker and Bewley could surprise me too.
Fingers crossed for an injury free pre season... Happy days.
Our best front six lacks serious speed & pressure...Should be interesting on how Jlo deals with this weakness.
- Nov 7, 2018
- 2,126
- 6,925
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
The lack of sizzle that's been mentioned a few times on here, would surely mean Stephens is in our sights for our first pick...aggressive in both mind and body
Hopefully we have the chance.
We’ve long been linked to Robertson so we may even prefer him?
Really, really looking forward to seeing him back to his best and have a great feeling he might hit new heights now we’re making positive changes at the club
Maybe Switta still fits into our best forwardline then.
- Thread starter
- #122
I want to see switta to rotate middle and forward. He puts the most pressure acts on the opposition than prob any Other player on the list. It’s just he doesn’t kick many goals which may make him start on the bench or just miss the 22
- Dec 26, 2010
- 5,907
- 7,828
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Matildas
Got to be careful we don't put out a side that doesn't have a bit of dash.
Good ball use covers for lack of speed - so it can be overrated, but we've lost probably our 2 quickest players in Langdon and B. Hill - and wings have a lot of space to be first to the loose ball/receive in the 6-6-6 set up.
Who do we have on our list that's really quick? Carter, Switkowski, Colyer, Sturt, Duman - Wilson and S Hill if they're not hampered by injury.
Most aren't established players but I think they'll always be in the mix when we're selecting for some extra zip to balance the side.
Good ball use covers for lack of speed - so it can be overrated, but we've lost probably our 2 quickest players in Langdon and B. Hill - and wings have a lot of space to be first to the loose ball/receive in the 6-6-6 set up.
Who do we have on our list that's really quick? Carter, Switkowski, Colyer, Sturt, Duman - Wilson and S Hill if they're not hampered by injury.
Most aren't established players but I think they'll always be in the mix when we're selecting for some extra zip to balance the side.
Barra_Mundy
Rookie
- Nov 27, 2018
- 32
- 67
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Tasmania
Imagine if Switta could turn into a goal a game player... He'd be seriously handy then.
I’m putting Lobb, Tabs and Hogan every day.
Tabs gave Hogan a foil, just needed to expand on that but injuries came.
Lobb as a second ruck will exploit sides.
What worries me is the lack of real small forward star power. Ideally we’d play a mosquito fleet but it’s all meh, same same.
Matera closer to goal is lethal but other then that he’s a liability. Schulz, Switta, Crowden otter good pressure but don’t have goal kicking ability.
Henry coming straight in isn’t going to happen. That’s tough on a 18 year old colt.
FB: Ryan, Hamling, Wilson
HB: Aish, Pearce, Logue
C: S. Hill (be amazing if he was fit), Acres, Tucker
HF: Walters, Tabs, Lobb
FF: Switta, Hogan, Mundy
R: Darcy, Fyfe, Blakely
Bench: McCarthy, Brayshaw, Cerra, Conca
Emergency: Banfield, Crowden, Duman
Logue can be a swing man. Play defence and forward. Would be bloody useful inside.
Blakely, Acres and Aish to actually play their natural roles would go a long way to making Freo successful.
Tabs gave Hogan a foil, just needed to expand on that but injuries came.
Lobb as a second ruck will exploit sides.
What worries me is the lack of real small forward star power. Ideally we’d play a mosquito fleet but it’s all meh, same same.
Matera closer to goal is lethal but other then that he’s a liability. Schulz, Switta, Crowden otter good pressure but don’t have goal kicking ability.
Henry coming straight in isn’t going to happen. That’s tough on a 18 year old colt.
FB: Ryan, Hamling, Wilson
HB: Aish, Pearce, Logue
C: S. Hill (be amazing if he was fit), Acres, Tucker
HF: Walters, Tabs, Lobb
FF: Switta, Hogan, Mundy
R: Darcy, Fyfe, Blakely
Bench: McCarthy, Brayshaw, Cerra, Conca
Emergency: Banfield, Crowden, Duman
Logue can be a swing man. Play defence and forward. Would be bloody useful inside.
Blakely, Acres and Aish to actually play their natural roles would go a long way to making Freo successful.
Similar threads
