Teams 2020 Rate My Pre-Season Team

[WaynesWorld19]

Spoiler: 2020 Official AFL Fixture

 

[CrozaN]

i dont understand the love for cogs/ceglar.
cogs with the uncertain role + never having been a sp before.
ceglar just seems to be spudish. makes my team uglier.
the others i can all understand.

Uncertain role? Cogs will play midfield

 

[CrozaN]

Only 35k.

Yeah I use windows snipping tool the trouble is supercoaches scrolling view on my browser won't let me capture it in one shot.

Print screen, open paint, paste, use cut tool to capture wat u want, copy, then paste here in chat....easy

 

[buttox]

Uncertain role? Cogs will play midfield

up forward last marsh game.
hes a gun player. hes just never been a SP.
your picking him for a break out.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

i dont understand the love for cogs/ceglar.
cogs with the uncertain role + never having been a sp before.
ceglar just seems to be spudish. makes my team uglier.
the others i can all understand.

Cegs yes I agree why would you but Cogs he is like Danger and he also gets the captains call.

 

[CrozaN]

up forward last marsh game.
hes a gun player. hes just never been a SP.
your picking him for a break out.

he drifts forward yes but he also scores 2-3 goals often with it....don't see a problem.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

he drifts forward yes but he also scores 2-3 goals often with it....don't see a problem.

He averaged 108.4 in 2018 last year was injury interupted he is in the same league as Treloar and Bont I think so $550k is underpriced

 

[Andrew Birch]

i dont understand the love for cogs/ceglar.
cogs with the uncertain role + never having been a sp before.
ceglar just seems to be spudish. makes my team uglier.
the others i can all understand.

Terrible selections. You don't want them.

 

[buttox]

Cegs yes I agree why would you but Cogs he is like Danger and he also gets the captains call.

after all my fussing and mass changes this pre season this is what i settled on.
imo oliver is the cheapest guaranteed premo available this year.
telly mcluggage cogs type picks will all go ok.
just not guaranteed imo.
they have never done it before.
thats not the risk i want to take with my mids.
if im going to go cheap. it will be a pick who has more room to move in terms of $. ie the hately pick

 

[A Bit Dusty]

View attachment 836995
after all my fussing and mass changes this pre season this is what i settled on.
imo oliver is the cheapest guaranteed premo available this year.
telly mcluggage cogs type picks will all go ok.
just not guaranteed imo.
they have never done it before.
thats not the risk i want to take with my mids.
if im going to go cheap. it will be a pick who has more room to move in terms of $. ie the hately pick

Show the rest of your team not just the mids

 

[buttox]

Show the rest of your team not just the mids

thats it
lacking a def premo on what most folks are posting
plan is to loophole picket r1.
assuming most folks play him on field

 

[Andrew Birch]

He averaged 108.4 in 2018 last year was injury interupted he is in the same league as Treloar and Bont I think so $550k is underpriced

In 2018 Cogs split his time 70/30 M/F and kicked 24 goals 17 and had a career high 85% TOG so when people say he's not a good selection based on the mooted 60/40 Mid/Fwd this year, they fail to understand that this actually benefits his inside/outside game since he's not an 'contested beast' (averages 10 CPs over his career) but is a great link man and excellent finisher. He's over his injury, is in his prime and is the new club captain and short of another horror team injury run he will be leading a team that won't lose more than 4 games all year. If he's ever going 110+ "SP" it will be this year. At 550k he's well unders.

 

[buttox]

In 2018 Cogs split his time 70/30 M/F and kicked 24 goals 17 and had a career high 85% TOG so when people say he's not a good selection based on the mooted 60/40 Mid/Fwd this year, they fail to understand that this actually benefits his inside/outside game since he's not an 'contested beast' (averages 10 CPs over his career) but is a great link man and excellent finisher. He's over his injury, is in his prime and is the new club captain and short of another horror injury run he will be leading a team that won't lose more than 4 games all year. If he's ever going 110+ "SP" it will be this year. At 550k he's well unders.

hope the pick works for you bud.
fair chance it does he is a gun.
i just dont see room for improvement in him.
im adverse to midfield risk i guess.
holding angus brayshaw last year does that to you.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

View attachment 837008View attachment 837009
thats it
lacking a def premo on what most folks are posting
plan is to loophole picket r1.
assuming most folks play him on field

How do you loophole Pickett?

 

[buttox]

How do you loophole Pickett?

mahoney if he doesnt play. id prefer he doesnt.
hibberd may come in otherwise.
60ppg at a guess for picket this year.

 

[JuddgementDay]

View attachment 836991

I thought you were sticking with Gawndy - ooops I've forgotten it has been 30mins since you've changed your mind

 

[A Bit Dusty]

mahoney if he doesnt play. id prefer he doesnt.
hibberd may come in otherwise.
60ppg at a guess for picket this year.

Really???
So for the sake of a few possible points either way Round 1 your considering looping a rookie with another rookie not starting

 

[pincrusher]

Jiska pincrusher

Can we open a round one discussion thread yet?

Normally the Monday prior to the first game from memory, but as I'm a rookie I'll defer to Jiska for the final word. If anything probably a post marsh series rate my team thread? Over to you Jiska

 

[buttox]

Really???
So for the sake of a few possible points either way Round 1 your considering looping a rookie with another rookie not starting

im taking xerri at r3 and he will play r1
therefore my loop will be at m11.
i think the m11/f8 loop is perfect this year
it adds a cheap rookie to these lines.

 

[shiva25]

You realise that players DO breakout? Obviously they all won't, but some definitely will

11 players in the top 10-15 averaging DEFs and FWDs last year were mid-pricers, where 7/11 had never previously averaged over 90 for a season

Marsh Community Series Discussion Thread

How many midprices is to many in a side. We will be out of trades to premo up

www.bigfooty.com

Great stat but i cant see any of the 4 players mentioned breaking out. Youll probably get 75-80 out of them at best which is not enough to justify having them

 

[Jiska]

Jiska pincrusher

Can we open a round one discussion thread yet?

Normally the Monday prior to the first game from memory, but as I'm a rookie I'll defer to Jiska for the final word. If anything probably a post marsh series rate my team thread? Over to you Jiska

I'm about to lock the Marsh thread.

Danger is that all the info between now and next Mon will be useless by the time the Round comes around, so a post Marsh thread makes sense.

 

[Lord De Goey]

After changing my team 1000 times i think im finally happy with it

.

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Great stat but i cant see any of the 4 players mentioned breaking out. Youll probably get 75-80 out of them at best which is not enough to justify having them

Wasn't his point that, this time last year, you wouldn't have picked 7 of the 11 as breakouts?

 

[vast]

I thought you were sticking with Gawndy - ooops I've forgotten it has been 30mins since you've changed your mind

he was back in 10 seconds later.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

im taking xerri at r3 and he will play r1
therefore my loop will be at m11.
i think the m11/f8 loop is perfect this year
it adds a cheap rookie to these lines.

I still don't understand the logic if you loop Pickett(Mid) it has nothing to do with fwd/ruck so if he scores poorly round 1 who will be on the field mid?

 

[SavDog23]

Version 1673.2