
For me I was disappointed that we did not go with one of my more favoured guys. That is a personal thing but I do rate my own ability to assess talent and if guys I rate are there I get disappointed in us not taking them. It is all well and good to say trust the professionals because they get to see a lot more of the talent than we do but at some stage you have to assess how well these guys actually assess talent and on past performance you have to say they do not have a significantly higher success rate than many one man band amateurs.
They have been really poor in recent years with the ability to assess tall talent and their reaches have invariably failed. When they have succeeded it has pretty much been by playing the odds and taking the obvious pick. They also have had much better success when they have drafted on best available rather than for positional need.
Interesting that it appears that Canole flat out lied several times going into the draft that we would be drafting for best available. At the functions it appears that they were told it was positional picks and who they took seemed to bear that out.
This year I understand what they were trying to do with the picks and I sincerely hope they hit home runs with both but based on track record I think supporters have every right to question Canole and his team. They are midfield at best and they could do with some scrutiny coming their way.
They have been really poor in recent years with the ability to assess tall talent and their reaches have invariably failed. When they have succeeded it has pretty much been by playing the odds and taking the obvious pick. They also have had much better success when they have drafted on best available rather than for positional need.
Interesting that it appears that Canole flat out lied several times going into the draft that we would be drafting for best available. At the functions it appears that they were told it was positional picks and who they took seemed to bear that out.
This year I understand what they were trying to do with the picks and I sincerely hope they hit home runs with both but based on track record I think supporters have every right to question Canole and his team. They are midfield at best and they could do with some scrutiny coming their way.