Discussion 2021 Player X v Y v Z

[Lord De Goey]

Duggan v Houston

 

[Flander]

Here's the 'X v Y v Z v W v Meat Pie' decision I've whittled it down to.

Which set would you prefer?

(Obviously there's countless alternate players that could suit these combinations, but this is the group I've been considering)

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Here's the 'X v Y v Z v W v Meat Pie' decision I've whittled it down to.

Which set would you prefer?

(Obviously there's countless alternate players that could suit these combinations, but this is the group I've been considering)

View attachment 1077766

Option D but I love spending other people's money

 

[Gene Simmons]

Oliver v Macrae
Zerrett v Tracca

 

[toxic]

Here's the 'X v Y v Z v W v Meat Pie' decision I've whittled it down to.

Which set would you prefer?

(Obviously there's countless alternate players that could suit these combinations, but this is the group I've been considering)

View attachment 1077766

D easily

 

[zoomba23]

Oliver v Macrae
Zerrett v Tracca

Macrae
Zerrett until Melb have a functioning forward line, but Petracca thereafter

 

[MacStradbroke]

What do you see them averaging? I see Cripps at 110 and Gaff at 107, for about 217 pts per week.

Reckon Rowell goes about 103 and Bont goes 115 odd.But that’s with the risk of Bont playing forward cos the Dogs have no forwards. Don’t know if it’s as clear cut as you make out.

I see Bont as an absolute keeper and Rowell a possible game breaking pick if he explodes again.
Cripps looks like he’s 38 yo and new rules cannot assist him, Gaff solid pick but cant See him obscuring the big guns, will only end up M8ish.

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Here's the 'X v Y v Z v W v Meat Pie' decision I've whittled it down to.

Which set would you prefer?

(Obviously there's countless alternate players that could suit these combinations, but this is the group I've been considering)

View attachment 1077766

D

 

[MacStradbroke]

Here's the 'X v Y v Z v W v Meat Pie' decision I've whittled it down to.

Which set would you prefer?

(Obviously there's countless alternate players that could suit these combinations, but this is the group I've been considering)

View attachment 1077766

D

 

[MacStradbroke]

Macrae
Zerrett until Melb have a functioning forward line, but Petracca thereafter

I’m keen on Tracc. Cant see him leaving the ground for a rest too often, they need him everywhere!

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Bont/Jelly/Trac/Fyfe?

Need one

 

[MacStradbroke]

Bont/Jelly/Trac/Fyfe?

Need one

Bont Tracc Fyfe Kelly in order for me. Tad injury prone the last two.

 

[zoomba23]

I’m keen on Tracc. Cant see him leaving the ground for a rest too often, they need him everywhere!

Mate I’m keen on him too. Had him locked in till I saw both brown and weideman were injured and some on the dees board were naming him at full forward in their R1 sides. Would tip him for the Brownlow if I thought he was gonna play predominantly mid but the Dees are gonna need him up forward. Especially as they already have plenty in the engine room stocks. I’m tipping a 30/70 mid fwd split

 

[zoomba23]

I see Bont as an absolute keeper and Rowell a possible game breaking pick if he explodes again.
Cripps looks like he’s 38 yo and new rules cannot assist him, Gaff solid pick but cant See him obscuring the big guns, will only end up M8ish.

Fair reasoning but I think people are reading too much into the new rules. Can’t see the contested beasts dropping in performance. There’ll still be plenty of contested ball to be won. Also, I think Gaff’s more of an M5/M6 than an M8. Cannot remember a season where I, or anyone else for that matter, had an M8 that averaged 105. Everything else you said makes sense though

 

[EFL Boy]

Laird & Mitchell vs Lloyd & Heeney

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Laird & Mitchell vs Lloyd & Heeney

 

[GT619]

Neale v steele

 

[MagicGnome97]

Short vs Daniel

 

[MagicGnome97]

Neale v steele

neale

 

[Jiska]

Short vs Daniel

Daniel

 

[stevebbb]

Dusty vs Butters/Taranto/De Goey/Phillips and cash to spend on better cows and the rest banked for future

 

[MagicGnome97]

Dusty vs Butters/Taranto/De Goey/Phillips and cash to spend on better cows and the rest banked for future

dunkley in a 1 premo fwd line

 

[stevebbb]

dunkley in a 1 premo fwd line

Already got Dunks. Position doesn't matter, got DPP to sort it.

Out of the players I listed?

 

[hoddo]

Here's the 'X v Y v Z v W v Meat Pie' decision I've whittled it down to.

Which set would you prefer?

(Obviously there's countless alternate players that could suit these combinations, but this is the group I've been considering)

View attachment 1077766

Option D by a big margin

Dusty vs Butters/Taranto/De Goey/Phillips and cash to spend on better cows and the rest banked for future

If it turns out you need extra cash to get the rookies right I'd go with Phillips. Dusty only if you don't need the cash.

 

[Judd_Magic]

No idea what to do with Laird.

Which 3 out of Laird vs Stewart vs Daniel vs Short?

Which 2 out of Steele vs Oliver vs Laird (in midfield)

Do I just not pick Laird at all and go for the other options?