Teams 2021 Rate My Pre-Season Team

Who are you selecting in your starting Team - Vote Yes to Multiple Players, Votes can be changed


  • Total voters
    237

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Last edited:
Roast away kents.

I'm not here for back patting about 'astute selections' or any of that nonsense.

Treat this like Rate My Plate, but for SuperCoach :thumbsu: :thumbsu:

View attachment 1039791
View attachment 1039792
Probably one of the worst SuperCoach teams to ever grace these pages !

from the back

Llllooydd : Congratulations your only half decent pick 👍
Ridley. : Last years money 🤑
McDonald : Unknown team role #Risk
Milera. : Probable breakdown # Risk 🚑
Stocker : Who ?? Sos’ parting gift ? likely non starter #Risk
Gollant : Astute pick but PENALTY for listening to @ Waynes World

Oliver. : OK , your only other half decent pick
Fyfe. : Forward role / Breakdown ">#Risk🚑
Cripps. : see Fyfe # Risk🚑
Rowell. : Returning from major injury ">#Risk🚑
Cunni. : Returning from something #Risk 🚑
Phillips : Possible non starting donut with no cover #Risk
Pedlar. : see Phillips donut with no cover #Risk
Powell : see Phillips and Pedlar donut with no cover #Risk

Gawn. : Overpriced.
Preuss. : Returning from major Injury # Risk🚑
Dunkley : Wants out , lack of mid minutes
Marshall : 2nd Ruck to Ryder
Heeney. : Probable breakdown # Risk🚑
Cameron : Too cold for him @ Geelong # underperform 🥶
Campbell. : See Phillips, Pedlar , Powell donut with no cover #Risk
O’henry. : WTF ? please refer Phillips,Powell,Pedlar and bloody Campbell unless team name DONUT KINGS !

Other than that Yeah Pretty Good 👍

Welcome back Kent.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Probably one of the worst SuperCoach teams to ever grace these pages !

from the back

Llllooydd : Congratulations your only half decent pick 👍
Ridley. : Last years money 🤑
McDonald : Unknown team role #Risk
Milera. : Probable breakdown # Risk 🚑
Stocker : Who ?? Sos’ parting gift ? likely non starter #Risk
Gollant : Astute pick but PENALTY for listening to @ Waynes World

Oliver. : OK , your only other half decent pick
Fyfe. : Forward role / Breakdown ">#Risk🚑
Cripps. : see Fyfe # Risk🚑
Rowell. : Returning from major injury ">#Risk🚑
Cunni. : Returning from something #Risk 🚑
Phillips : Possible non starting donut with no cover #Risk
Pedlar. : see Phillips donut with no cover #Risk
Powell : see Phillips and Pedlar donut with no cover #Risk

Gawn. : Overpriced.
Preuss. : Returning from major Injury # Risk🚑
Dunkley : Wants out , lack of mid minutes
Marshall : 2nd Ruck to Ryder
Heeney. : Probable breakdown # Risk🚑
Cameron : Too cold for him @ Geelong # underperform 🥶
Campbell. : See Phillips, Pedlar , Powell donut with no cover #Risk
O’henry. : WTF ? please refer Phillips,Powell,Pedlar and bloody Campbell unless team name DONUT KINGS !

Other than that Yeah Pretty Good 👍

Welcome back Kent.

Just tell him we're frightened and want to go home!
 
As long as everyone realises that ‘every’ player will suffer as a result. Not just Gawn and Neale.

Pffft don't be silly. Only the overpriced players are affected by this. Only Gawn and Neale. Maybe Lloyd.
All other players will maintain their prices. Because duh!

Everyone should stay away from them, as they can be traded in for roughly $520k-$550k somewhere about round 6!





























;)
 
Pffft don't be silly. Only the overpriced players are affected by this. Only Gawn and Neale. Maybe Lloyd.
All other players will maintain their prices. Because duh!

Everyone should stay away from them, as they can be traded in for roughly $520k-$550k somewhere about round 6!





























;)
When all those legendary rookies have maxed out at 400-450K.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

No doubt they’re overpriced. It’s still a game of scoring the most points though.
I'd say it's a game of scoring the most points "per dollar spent", so players being greatly overpriced is extremely relevant.

Best examples are probably Steele and NicNat who both had histories of scoring well while on the field but having low TOG in previous years. Those types of players got so many more points for playing the same minutes in 2020 as they did in 2019 and will probably drop to their old scores playing the same minutes in 2021, but burst players like Gawn were also advantaged.

As long as everyone realises that ‘every’ player will suffer as a result. Not just Gawn and Neale.
That's simply not true mathematically. Players with different fitness levels and different playing styles would have received very different levels of scaling. Players with lower usual TOG advantaged over those with a usual high TOG and burst players advantaged over accumulators.
 
Last edited:
I'd say it's a game of scoring the most points "per dollar spent", so players being greatly overpriced is extremely relevant.

Best examples are probably Steele and NicNat who both had histories of scoring well while on the field but having low TOG in previous years. Those types of players got so many more points for playing the same minutes in 2020 as they did in 2019 and will probably drop to their old scores playing the same minutes in 2021, but burst players like Gawn were also advantaged.


That's simply not true mathematically. Players with different fitness levels and different playing styles would have received very different levels of scaling. Players with lower usual TOG advantaged over those with a usual high TOG and burst players advantaged over accumulators.

But they were all scaled as u said....

Every player benefited from the scaling etc at some point.
 
As long as everyone realises that ‘every’ player will suffer as a result. Not just Gawn and Neale.
But they were all scaled as u said....

Every player benefited from the scaling etc at some point.
Yes they were all scaled up but the points they scored before the scale up were proportionately higher or lower than in a usual season due to their different usual playing styles and TOGs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top