Analysis 2021 trade thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Bring in Parker as FA
Neale to Freo for 6 (Cerra trade) and 27
Next year's first rounder + 27 + 47 + 51 + 57 to Dogs for their first rounder this year
Go to draft with 6, 14 and 2 picks from 15-18
Ashcroft next year
???
Profit!
 
Yeah like I said previously we can turn it into a positive if we get some good picks, however it may set us back a couple of years until the young blokes we have now are ready to shoulder the load full time and hit their peak.

The other option is, as others have said to stay in the window in the interim. That would probably require bringing in another top grade talent. If that doesn’t happen I don’t see how we don’t regress at least in the short term.
Lachie hasn't been great this season and I think the young guys, Bailey in particular is ready to play mid full-time. Could also open a full-time spot for McCluggage and the Starcevich switch.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Well signing Matho to a two year contract makes a lot more sense now. Though a Mathieson and Lyons midfield is just as one paced, and doesn’t offer any more defensive run.

If this is true, I can live with it, and wouldn’t necessarily go looking for a ready made replacement, unless we find one in free agency.

I also do not believe Neale’s value has gone up. Of course I would like as much as possible, but don’t believe 6 and 8 is a reasonable request, even if we’re sending 18 back.

6 plus a current or future second round pick would satisfy me.
 
Bring in Parker as FA
Neale to Freo for 6 (Cerra trade) and 27
Next year's first rounder + 27 + 47 + 51 + 57 to Dogs for their first rounder this year
Go to draft with 6, 14 and 2 picks from 15-18
Ashcroft next year
???
Profit!
Who do we move on. Could be some nervous players on our list right about now
 
Well signing Matho to a two year contract makes a lot more sense now. Though a Mathieson and Lyons midfield is just as one paced, and doesn’t offer any more defensive run.

If this is true, I can live with it, and wouldn’t necessarily go looking for a ready made replacement, unless we find one in free agency.

I also do not believe Neale’s value has gone up. Of course I would like as much as possible, but don’t believe 6 and 8 is a reasonable request, even if we’re sending 18 back.

6 plus a current or future second round pick would satisfy me.
If the deal is 6 and a future second I would be filthy at the club. That is way under market value. That just can't happen.
Look at the Tim Kelly and Jeremy Cameron deals.
 
You reckon we could get Noble to create a abn family trust and get him into consulting our list for a month ….. cmon any accountants and lawyers out there that can just wrap it up for him ….🥱
 
briztoon

It's top of the draft time. Get excited

Back in 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018 we had nothing to look forward to other than draft threads. Those threads are for losers that don't make finals.

This year we have both finals & the excitement of a draft thread. Boy oh boy. Wowee.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

And so begins our downfall... We start losing coaches, we'll likely lose tapping as well. Now our best player wants out.

Any chance our worst poster wants out?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Analysis 2021 trade thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top