List Mgmt. 2022 List Management: Draft, Trade and FA Pt2: Electric Boogaloo

[SlipperySlipperyPete]

So Geelong must be sweeping all of Narkle’s issues under the rug ?

Geelong is out of Melbourne city and Narkle doesn’t have his family and friends with him. When he is over here in the off-season around his family and friends he has had some troubles. If a club like geelong can’t harness his talents, and they gave him a fair crack not like Jordan Clark. Why would we be able to.

It would be best for him and us if he doesn’t come back west.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Johnny Dalmas]

Belly never said he wouldn't trade Neale. Neale requested a trade, Bell said it would be nice to keep him, and that the club would TRY to keep him, but a trade request was never ruled out. There was no media release that said "Lachie has asked for a trade, we have categorically denied his request". We would have lost Neale for nothing as a FA the following year.

Lobb has a year left and we lose him for a pick in the 35-50 next year. There is no benefit of trading him this year UNLESS we get a first round pick. We're not trading him for pick 30 this year after denying his trade request a few weeks earlier.

If we kept Neale and just picked up the FA compo for him, we probably would have got #7 the next year

 

[SlipperySlipperyPete]

AFL star Sydney Stack fined for COVID-19 quarantine breach in Perth

AFL star’s massive fine for COVID breach

www.foxsports.com.au

You really want this guy on our list


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Johnny Dalmas]

It won’t be much more… if they get a first rounder they should build belly a statue.

Don’t get it, all season fans bag him now he wants out they want way overs

C.O.N.T.R.A.C.T.E.D.

 

[Joao]

We didn't want Stack pre-draft because of off-field stuff and if he is getting delisted with his talent, its obvious he hasn't worked through them. I'd say we are 0% chance as gifted as he is.

 

[SlipperySlipperyPete]

Narkle? Problems?? Please share. Know people that know him. Zero issues from what I’ve been told.

Oh well if you have such intimate knowledge of his character by all means get him in.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Taylor]

I don't think it's appropriate that it happened but Stack spent a long time behind bars here at the start of this year or last, he wouldn't spend any time outside of the club or his home without a camera in his face.

Talented, question marks over professionalism leading to his sliding right out of the draft

 

[s_wd6]

If we kept Neale and just picked up the FA compo for him, we probably would have got #7 the next year

And instead we got what? I don't remember but it was something like 6 and 19? (Which we wasted). We ended up with pick 7,8,9 in the 2019 draft anyway so another pick from neale wouldn't have made a big difference

 

[Dockeroo]

They might be flogs but they have a point here you know…
What a joke of a comp!!

 

[Lach72]

Poor old Rendell. Off the top of his head tried telling SOS and Barrett as well as getting Brodie we used 19 on Johnson who is a quality mid…complete silence in the room from the other two blokes. They either don’t care or have NFI.

Rendell gets a lot of s**t but knows a bit more than most these duds on Trade Radio.

In Fairness sos is like this:

Going through the detail of a deal where the trader doesn’t get ****ed

 

[Johnny Dalmas]

Ball in Bowes' court as Suns chase 'fair' Rankine deal

Gold Coast will let Jack Bowes decide the club he wants to play for in 2023 as the Suns look for 'fair recompense' from Adelaide for Izak Rankine

www.afl.com.au

Don't understand why we aren't all over him

 

[Cobbler]

Oh well if you have such intimate knowledge of his character by all means get him in.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

I’m very interested as to what you think you know? Or were you just making a stereotypically poor judgement?

 

[gungho]

This is why Lobb leaving is a good thing long term.
Treacy needs to play 20 odd games next year in the AFL. He should be ready to really contribute strongly and consistently from then on

The only question with Treacy is his height. Key defenders are 200cms these days. The pav 193m forward is hard to cut it unless you are truly a gifted footballer b

 

[Johnny Dalmas]

And instead we got what? I don't remember but it was something like 6 and 19? (Which we wasted). We ended up with pick 7,8,9 in the 2019 draft anyway so another pick from neale wouldn't have made a big difference

By trading Neale + 30 we got: 6, 19, 55.

By not trading Neale, we would of had: at least 1 more year of Neale, 2019 #7 (if he left anyway), 30.

Really wished we kept him for 2019.

 

[Pussinbootz]

Ball in Bowes' court as Suns chase 'fair' Rankine deal

Gold Coast will let Jack Bowes decide the club he wants to play for in 2023 as the Suns look for 'fair recompense' from Adelaide for Izak Rankine

www.afl.com.au

Don't understand why we aren't all over him

He’s probably not interested in moving to WA

 

[Nickos66]

^yep, He's stated that he'll only go to Vic.

 

[FreoMatt]

Why are they future picks? Brisbane have a 2nd and Dogs have a 3rd they can use.

probably because Brisabne needs picks this year to match two father sons who will go 1 and probably top 20

 

[gungho]

So, looks like we're going back to the Gold Coast well with Corbitt and Sharp. Are they Brodie, Clark, Aish quality or Kersten/Matera quality? Must admit I'm a little concerned with Corbitt playing 4 games this year as a forward and only kicking 1 goal. At least with Brodie and Clark you could see that they were talented players who just hadn't gotten an opportunity. I'm not quite as sold on these two, but obviously the club must see something in them.

 

[King Huskii]

Poor old Rendell. Off the top of his head tried telling SOS and Barrett as well as getting Brodie we used 19 on Johnson who is a quality mid…complete silence in the room from the other two blokes. They either don’t care or have NFI.

Rendell gets a lot of s**t but knows a bit more than most these duds on Trade Radio.

SOS and Barrett wouldn't know our list

 

[FreoMatt]

The only question with Treacy is his height. Key defenders are 200cms these days. The pav 193m forward is hard to cut it unless you are truly a gifted footballer b

the Coleman medalist is 192cm, Treacy is 195cm

 

[MadMundy]

Amiss and Treacy need to play AFL level football next year. The only way you develop is by playing in the big leagues.

Both have potential to be elite key forwards, amongst the best in the competition in eventual time. Let them work their way against the best defenders.

 

[malpaso]

Oh well if you have such intimate knowledge of his character by all means get him in.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Your the one who has claimed intimate knowledge of Narkle by comparing him to Stack's issues. There is no substance to what you said.

 

[malpaso]

Amiss and Treacy need to play AFL level football next year. The only way you develop is by playing in the big leagues.

Both have potential to be elite key forwards, amongst the best in the competition in eventual time. Let them work their way against the best defenders.

This. I believe FFC think the same thing as both of them were limited by injury/sickness this year.

 

[tonygeeks]

As a reminder, I'll be locking this thread temporarily and opening up a trade period match thread tonight where all trade talk is to be directed - Freo or not

Drunk with power

 

[Swiggy]

C.O.N.T.R.A.C.T.E.D.

yes so how much more should they pay? He’s not worth a first. Belly will take what he can get in the end