- Nov 20, 2022
- 2,855
- 13,116
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Yep…they were ignorant and delusional!
List Mgmt. 2023 Draft Thread - Part I
- Thread starter bird_man
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Dr Spaceman
Premium Gold
Well to be fair some journos were running with that angle also.
Oh that’s right I forgot; those journos are already included in the deluded group you refer to
Diehard Saint
Brownlow Medallist
Meantime, our “nothing pick” #62 got us a hopefully much more suitable, long term player instead of a broken down old guy. Win/win
Banger9798
Team Captain
- Jul 28, 2023
- 573
- 1,914
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Much better policy to take the young bloke. A hungry 18 year old with his career ahead of him, or an injured 30 year old mercenary?
Sos has proven to be canny at the trade table and at drafting.
Stocker and Caminiti
️
Dow for cheap️
Henry for a future second️
In the draft Lyon wanted pace (got it with Henry and Dow in trades)
Wilson speed, endurance, great skills, runs like Hill, @ pick 18 and a free future second, ( Henry therefore free)️
Collard. Speed X factor, high risk, high reward️
Hastie, good size, runs like the wind, good intercept️
Garcia, good inside mid, designated kick out for his team, means a good kick and decision making. will need some time, but a mid what we needed️
Schoenmaker a free hit, Sheahan reckons could be steal of the draft. Only one not quick but has other huge weapons️
Bonner, another with run who is a very good backup️
So everyone bar Schoenmaker is very quick ( obviously with other skills), just what Lyon wanted. He loves run and one of the reasons he took on this list.
So for me SOS has really passed his first test.
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
Stocker and Caminiti
️Dow for cheap
️Henry for a future second
️In the draft Lyon wanted pace (got it with Henry and Dow in trades)
Wilson speed, endurance, great skills, runs like Hill, @ pick 18 and a free future second, ( Henry therefore free)
️Collard. Speed X factor, high risk, high reward
️Hastie, good size, runs like the wind, good intercept
️Garcia, good inside mid, designated kick out for his team, means a good kick and decision making. will need some time, but a mid what we needed
️Schoenmaker a free hit, Sheahan reckons could be steal of the draft. Only one not quick but has other huge weapons
️Bonner, another with run who is a very good backup
️So everyone bar Schoenmaker is very quick ( obviously with other skills), just what Lyon wanted. He loves run and one of the reasons he took on this list.
So for me SOS has really passed his first test.
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
gringo2011
Premium Platinum
Sos has proven to be canny at the trade table and at drafting.
Stocker and Caminiti
Dow for cheap
Henry for a future second
In the draft Lyon wanted pace (got it with Henry and Dow in trades)
Wilson speed, endurance, great skills, runs like Hill, @ pick 18 and a free future second, ( Henry therefore free)
Collard. Speed X factor, high risk, high reward
Hastie, good size, runs like the wind, good intercept
Garcia, good inside mid, designated kick out for his team, means a good kick and decision making. will need some time, but a mid what we needed
Schoenmaker a free hit, Sheahan reckons could be steal of the draft. Only one not quick but has other huge weapons
Bonner, another with run who is a very good backup
So everyone bar Schoenmaker is very quick ( obviously with other skills), just what Lyon wanted. He loves run and one of the reasons he took on this list.
So for me SOS has really passed his first test.
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
Probably too early to call but so far Sos and Toce have been very good. Billings and Gresham walking out means we need to get more from what we got for them but other than that they have done a lot with a little.
St.Kilda probably would have taken Wilson regardless.
SteeleSaints
Premiership Player
- Mar 26, 2022
- 3,709
- 11,507
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Sos has proven to be canny at the trade table and at drafting.
Stocker and Caminiti
Dow for cheap
Henry for a future second
In the draft Lyon wanted pace (got it with Henry and Dow in trades)
Wilson speed, endurance, great skills, runs like Hill, @ pick 18 and a free future second, ( Henry therefore free)
Collard. Speed X factor, high risk, high reward
Hastie, good size, runs like the wind, good intercept
Garcia, good inside mid, designated kick out for his team, means a good kick and decision making. will need some time, but a mid what we needed
Schoenmaker a free hit, Sheahan reckons could be steal of the draft. Only one not quick but has other huge weapons
Bonner, another with run who is a very good backup
So everyone bar Schoenmaker is very quick ( obviously with other skills), just what Lyon wanted. He loves run and one of the reasons he took on this list.
So for me SOS has really passed his first test.
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
Couldnt agree more, its like SOS and Gubby were given $20 to bet on the horses and turned it into a million.
Diehard Saint
Brownlow Medallist
Yep. True. The raw material looks good.Sos has proven to be canny at the trade table and at drafting.
Stocker and Caminiti
Dow for cheap
Henry for a future second
In the draft Lyon wanted pace (got it with Henry and Dow in trades)
Wilson speed, endurance, great skills, runs like Hill, @ pick 18 and a free future second, ( Henry therefore free)
Collard. Speed X factor, high risk, high reward
Hastie, good size, runs like the wind, good intercept
Garcia, good inside mid, designated kick out for his team, means a good kick and decision making. will need some time, but a mid what we needed
Schoenmaker a free hit, Sheahan reckons could be steal of the draft. Only one not quick but has other huge weapons
Bonner, another with run who is a very good backup
So everyone bar Schoenmaker is very quick ( obviously with other skills), just what Lyon wanted. He loves run and one of the reasons he took on this list.
So for me SOS has really passed his first test.
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
Now it’s over to development coaches.
goodie23
Tragic Saint
Veteran
St Kilda - Marcus Windhager Player Sponsor 2023
St Kilda - Marcus Windhager Player Sponsor 2022
St Kilda - James Frawley Player Sponsor 2021
Saints Pledge Contributor
St Kilda - Doulton Langlands Player Sponsor 2020
St Kilda - Robbie Young Player Sponsor 2019
St Kilda - Nathan Freeman Player Sponsor 2018
We were, but Hawthorn and North were also coming for our pick to get Leake. Lucky for GWS we wanted Wilson because North's future 2nd will certainly be a better pick than the Adelaide one GWS gave us.
gringo2011
Premium Platinum
And we actually have those now. We had a terrible recruiter and zero development before. We are spending in all the right areas now.
- Oct 28, 2018
- 611
- 1,397
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Garcia, good inside mid, designated kick out for his team, means a good kick and decision making. will need some time, but a mid what we needed
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
Joffaboy - don't forget Dougal takes most of our kick outs. A good kick maybe, but 'decision maker'?
On SM-T290 using BigFooty.com mobile app
Yes agreed, too early. However there have been questions all year about SOS and choosing Stocker and Hammer from Carlton didn't quash those fears.
Then Dow from Carlton.
My analysis is looking at the coaches requirements, which was more run. I think we got that with all but Schoenmaker who was a free hit at a real slider.
We won't know the draftees for seasons, however Dow and Henry and even Bonner can have an immediate impact, Wilson may get a gig early,and hopefully a couple of Hotton, Keeler and Van Es can get a gig.
Will start to look like a Ross Lyon team.
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
Irrespective of the reasons for or differences of opinion, we we're getting previously nothing out of Billings and not that much out of Gresh.
Dow and Henry will easily produce more for the team than what we were getting. Probably Dow alone.
JB was pushed, didn't walk out. Gresh they let go knowing that an end of first round would eventually land about where it did, so clearly they didnt rate him and he was on the edge of the 22 by season's end.
At the very least we didn't lose any blood this offseason. Whilst not improving the top end they did well on building the base and on paper the squad should be better even before you factor in growth from the obvious ones and general improvement from time in the RTB system.
Last edited:
StFly
Space to Rent
- Moderator
- #4,615
Really bullish on Keeler, as him and Ming will legit stretch any of the best defenses in the league and we'll no longer have Higgins trying to body people twice his size in aerial, legit transform our F50 to something with actual bite when you then have blokes that can reliably kick 50+ to them favourably as both just have natural ability when forward obviously.
I'm happy for Keeler to build time as his body shapes up to AFL standard, last thing we need is another Kosi and random breaks curtailing a trajectory.
As best l can figure, on balance it was:Sos has proven to be canny at the trade table and at drafting.
Stocker and Caminiti
Dow for cheap
Henry for a future second
In the draft Lyon wanted pace (got it with Henry and Dow in trades)
Wilson speed, endurance, great skills, runs like Hill, @ pick 18 and a free future second, ( Henry therefore free)
Collard. Speed X factor, high risk, high reward
Hastie, good size, runs like the wind, good intercept
Garcia, good inside mid, designated kick out for his team, means a good kick and decision making. will need some time, but a mid what we needed
Schoenmaker a free hit, Sheahan reckons could be steal of the draft. Only one not quick but has other huge weapons
Bonner, another with run who is a very good backup
So everyone bar Schoenmaker is very quick ( obviously with other skills), just what Lyon wanted. He loves run and one of the reasons he took on this list.
So for me SOS has really passed his first test.
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
Collard -- Gresh
Garcia -- Billings
Henry -- free
Shoey -- free
Bonner -- free
Dow & Hastie -- Coff + 3rd & f4th
Wilson -- FRDP
Though there'sa strong element of luck attached, there's no doubt SOS made his own this time around.
If you want to add Stocker and Hammer to the freebies group (personally l wouldn't) then so much the better.
Last edited:
- Mar 14, 2011
- 17,086
- 87,837
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Leeds united, Chicago Bulls
Billings walked.
Your manager doesn’t go on gettable and talk you up if you don’t want to move.
He was contracted to us for another year. He could have sat there and worked his tail off to get back into this side
I think it was clear to JB that he wasn't in plans going forward. Perhaps he was also told something to that effect.
His contract was too big and the talk we're still paying some of it says go away IMO.
gringo2011
Premium Platinum
Gresham was one of the only ones that kept up in the GWS final. Not sure he was fringe. Think he improved. He was one of our few that looked on his way to elite early on, injury ruined a few years but he has potential to still be a gun. Billings wanted out because he saw the writing on the wall. I probably would have held him as depth and hoped that he could push back in rather than pay him to play elsewhere. If the kids coming in to his empty list spot spot end up guns I'll eat my words.
Anyway, so far it looks like we have done well topping up the list with not a great starting spot so fingers crossed to was an inspired move. I'm still stuck in the Trout era where we'd trade players out and take a shit downgrade with the picks.
- Nov 7, 2012
- 10,804
- 35,349
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Bristol City FC, Urawa Red Diamonds FC
Yes, because he read the room correctly. His manager was desperate because his client's career was at the crossroads. He could have stayed and fulfilled his contract but been finished as a footballer. He's got a chance for a fresh start at Melbourne. My prediction is his decline will simply continue but he was never ever going to get a chance to flip the script at St Kilda. We should have traded him years ago.
love it.
What a name - I'll be champing everyone.
Has a bit of mongrel about him too.
Last edited:
- Nov 20, 2022
- 2,855
- 13,116
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Yes it’s a nice haul…good to hear SOS & Chris Toce getting some kudos they deserve!
Dr Spaceman
Premium Gold
The quality of kids is obviously still TBD but Garcia is the one is the one I'm looking at to give us an indication as to Toce's acumen. We overpaid for him and he didn't appear on any radars prior to being drafted. Bit of a James Gwilt moment.
SOS was very canny, the more l look into it the more impressive it's getting. Again some luck was involved but he squeezed absolutely every drop out of it.
