Analysis 2023 Draft Watch

[FlowersByIrene]

Fox had him at 30.

Yes, but all that meant was the bunch of guys in the 15-30 range who are all much of a muchness moved into the 14-29 range.

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

There's still a crazy amount of talent still there on the board....

Mitch Edwards
Ollie Murphy
Logan Morris
Archie Roberts
Archer Reid
Arie Schoenmaker
Cooper Simpson
Koen Sanchez
Luaman Lual
Tew Jiath
Angus Hastie
Zane Zacostelsky

The list goes on.

Can't see Edwards getting past WCE, Lions and Geelong. Same with Reid. Saints possibly looking to Murphy as a key defender or possibly Schoenmaker. Either way, I reckon there'll be some talls being selected by that lot.

Hoping we take Simpson though. If not Simpson, Logan Morris would be a great pick up.

Plenty of talls left. I wouldn't mind selling the pick and sliding back. There will clubs keen to pay up for Edwards, Murphy and Reid.

 

[Aphrodite]

Always up and about. Nick loves his sliders more than I do at my father in law's bbq so if he gives me Edwards might have to get a Austin tattoo

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Suns have another 2 years of this sort of talent

I'd be really cherry picking their fringe types now

We did. Hollands.

 

[JuddgementDay]

View attachment 1857175

Thanks for this - it’s a great list to reference.

We have quite a wide range of good players to choose from

My order:
1. MEdwards
2. Simpson
3. Lual
4. ZZ

 

[Stig O'Hara]

We did. Hollands.

After his 2 weeks in the toilet.

He ain’t done nothing.

A nobody with a big tag.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

After his 2 weeks in the toilet.

He ain’t done nothing.

A nobody with a big tag.

Worst case of constipation ever.

 

[Elmer_Hauser]

Pretty impressed with the Intel and or footy IQ of some posters on our board saying Moir was our guy weeks ago from the draft

I was hoping for Schoenmaker with our pick, but maybe still available with our pick tomorrow in the 2nd round.

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Worst case of constipation ever.

3 laps of Princes Park don’t make you a superstar.

 

[Bletch]

Thanks for this - it’s a great list to reference.

We have quite a wide range of good players to choose from

My order:
1. MEdwards
2. Simpson
3. Lual
4. ZZ

Welcome. Updated list for tomorrow night (with top 23 hidden):



Got a few more names beyond this, but the above should cover it.

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

I'll have a crack at it....

Pick 30 (WCE) - Mitch Edwards
Pick 31 (Lions) - Archer Reid
Pick 32 (Cats) - Archie Roberts
Pick 33 (Saints) - Ollie Murphy
Pick 34 (Blues) - ???

 

[TENACIOUS]

Will McCabe, refreshing young man, spoke well

I know they have training throughout the year, but it's amazing how media ready these kids are...

 

[marcmurphy3]

I'll have a crack at it....

Pick 30 (WCE) - Mitch Edwards
Pick 31 (Lions) - Archer Reid
Pick 32 (Cats) - Archie Roberts
Pick 33 (Saints) - Ollie Murphy
Pick 34 (Blues) - ???

Good effort. Westcoast could go Roberts or Zakostelsky. Both fill a need and have been linked but would put my money on Edwards. Think Lions should go a tall and Reid fits the bill or potentially Schoenmaker. Pretty confident Saints will go tall too.

Under your scenario I could see Simpson or Schoenmaker going to us or even Jiath or Lual. Have a feeling we will take Edwards if he's there though.

 

[The Return of the Paf]

Worst case of constipation ever.

To quote The Goodies - "that was a unique experience".

 

[GT619]

Edwards DeMattia Collard Moir Simpson Hardeman Murphy all left

Amazing murphy is still on the board. Clubs think differently I guess

 

[GT619]

Collard gone

Sos is too predictable. Was always going to happen. Made our choice easier it didn't take us long to select our choice

 

[GT619]

Cooper Simpson now and I will be happy

How likely you reckon or does depend if Edwards is still there

 

[Limestone]

I wonder if the Carlton recruitment team just rocked up at 9.30pm, lol .

 

[Arr0w]

How likely you reckon or does depend if Edwards is still there

I think Simpson is gone by our pick

 

[Arr0w]

I'll have a crack at it....

Pick 30 (WCE) - Mitch Edwards
Pick 31 (Lions) - Archer Reid
Pick 32 (Cats) - Archie Roberts
Pick 33 (Saints) - Ollie Murphy
Pick 34 (Blues) - ???

Not bad. Mail is Lions want Freijah, think Reid will be taken after Murphy, Zakostelsky, Edwards come off the board

So

WC Edwards
Lions Freijah
Cats Murphy
Saints I would say they need a tall, but likely take another Ross endurance player

Then us

Spanner in the works, WC and Cats likely to swap 2nd round picks

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Edwards at 34 and Mannagh rookie?

 

[TerryWallet]

Gut feel:

30. WC Sanchez
31. BL Freijah
32. Gee Reid
33. StK Edwards

34 Carl Jiath or Simpson
Rookie: Carroll

 

[The Return of the Paf]

Sos is too predictable. Was always going to happen. Made our choice easier it didn't take us long to select our choice

That seems like a bit indirect for a spiteful act (if it even was one) because it was probably always going to be Moir. Then again, it probably takes Edwards off the board for us.

 

[GT619]

Not bad. Mail is Lions want Freijah, think Reid will be taken after Murphy, Zakostelsky, Edwards come off the board

So

WC Edwards
Lions Freijah
Cats Murphy
Saints I would say they need a tall, but likely take another Ross endurance player

Then us

Spanner in the works, WC and Cats likely to swap 2nd round picks

Murphy and O'Sullivan chb fb for cats impressive pick ups if cats go murphy

 

[Coona Blues]

Arr0w Edwards little indiscretion has certainly played a part here.

With clubs undoubtedly coming hard for TDK in a couple of years, surely we don’t leave him in the board if he gets that far.

Otherwise Simpson, Sanchez and Zakostelsky, would be happy with any of them. The “Smokey” here would be Billy Wilson from links. Carroll enters discussion if no one else slides to our rookie pick.