List Mgmt. 2023 List Management and Trading

[Soggy2112]

What’s happens if Strauny decides he is sick of being stuck behind ROB and looks elsewhere? We would be in a world of hurt

No we would not.

Collingwood currently sit top after choosing to get rid of an AA ruck and have run with Cox as their ruck at times.

Port sit 3rd and have run with four different rucks this season.

Geelong have rarely given a second thought to their ruck.

A quality ruck can add a lot to a side but is far from a necessity. We could pluck any 200cm+ player from the state leagues in the MSD if need be and it would probably be fine.

 

[The Perfect Stranger]

Mutineer - tell me how you could possibly give Hamish anything but a fail for those 2 drafts?

2018 super draft - Jones, McHenry, Hamill and Sholl
2019 - McCasey

 

[Sanders]

Mutineer - tell me how you could possibly give Hamish anything but a fail for those 2 drafts?

He’s a bit confused these days

 

[fuic08]

No we would not.

Collingwood currently sit top after choosing to get rid of an AA ruck and have run with Cox as their ruck at times.

Port sit 3rd and have run with four different rucks this season.

Geelong have rarely given a second thought to their ruck.

A quality ruck can add a lot to a side but is far from a necessity. We could pluck any 200cm+ player from the state leagues in the MSD if need be and it would probably be fine.

There's always a back up ruckman on the scrap heap, we'd just pick one of them the same period.

 

[Hate the pear]

Tell me... who picks the team again??? (Hint: Victorians). We had 4 (and that didn't include MAX) in the whole squad.

The team is selected by fans voting, ...

 

[Gtowncrow]

It's not a thought to him because we haven't leaked our intentions one way or the other to him.

I wonder if our trading around Rankine was mutually beneficial.
Gold Coast might appreciate us as trading partners. Who knows?

 

[fuic08]

The team is selected by fans voting, ...

Where are most fans located though

 

[jackster83]

Mutineer - tell me how you could possibly give Hamish anything but a fail for those 2 drafts?

2018 super draft - Jones, McHenry, Hamill and Sholl
2019 - McCasey

2016 a disaster also.

 

[Gtowncrow]

You would hope a Jones and Hinge to the wings leaves no place for Sloane

I know your comment has an element of tongue in cheek to it....but there isn't actually a spot in our 2024 team for Sloane. Especially if Crouch is back in the 22.

 

[Sanders]

2016 a disaster also.

2016 is a war crime
2015 is a disappointing fizzer too

 

[Burtonsgottago]

You would hope a Jones and Hinge to the wings leaves no place for Sloane

We’ll make a spot

 

[1990crow]

2016 a disaster also.

2017 producing Fogarty (a decent but not excellent key forward) and nothing else.
Plus the Gibbs debacle.

2016-2019 club wide dumpster fire list management.

 

[ABAB]

Hamish should have been given the boot for the 2018 and 2019 drafts. Back-to-back wasted years for a club about to enter a deep rebuild.

What? We entered the season as one of the premiership favourite in 2018 but got hit with injuries and then entered the 2019 season again as one of the premiership favourite and then fall out from the CM happened. If this didn't occurred then we would have still be contenders for another few years, instead we correctly did a very big list rebuild and the entire coach group got changed. Talk about harry hindsight lol.

 

[Sanders]

What? We entered the season as one of the premiership favourite in 2018 but got hit with injuries and then entered the 2019 season again as one of the premiership favourite and then CM happened. If this didn't occurred then we would have still be contenders for another few years, instead we correctly did a very big list rebuild and the entire coach group got changed. Talk about harry hindsight lol.

CM happened in 2019?

Interesting

 

[George Kramer]

CM happened in 2019?

Interesting

Basic football knowledge

 

[ABAB]

CM happened in 2019?

Interesting

The fall out from the review, I meant. Thanks for correcting me (have edited my post, FAITH wouldn't have made that misunderstanding like me)

 

[GreyCrow]

That appears to be someone short of options, who thinks a universal declaration of allegiance will extract greater value from his current team

Will work too

 

[George Kramer]

The fall out from the review, I meant. Thanks for correcting me (have edited my post, FAITH wouldn't have made that misunderstanding like me)

Doh, we didn’t enter the season after the review as premiership favourite, basic football knowledge.

Better to acknowledge you made a mistake rather than dig a bigger hole for yourself

 

[ABAB]

Doh, we didn’t enter the season after the review as premiership favourite, basic football knowledge.

Better to acknowledge you made a mistake rather than dig a bigger hole for yourself

Read my edited post and then you will finally get what I meant. I said the "fall out from the CM happened" and we now know there was a big divide between the coach and playing group after the CM review.

 

[ABAB]

Basic football knowledge

Correct, which is why I'm not FAITH's alias lol. Last time I replied to his/her post, s/he correctly told me about Rankine will request a trade to us well before the media reported.

 

[The Perfect Stranger]

2016 a disaster also.

Thank god we sacked the guy who was responsible for these disasters.

Hamish reviews his work on the 2016 draft.

 

[Punchy Bassett]

Doedee took the gamble and has lost, it's that simple really.

 

[Crow till I die]

Doedee took the gamble and has lost, it's that simple really.

And likely we now get a decent player at well under what was market value assuming he can recover well from the ACL

 

[The Perfect Stranger]

And likely we now get a decent player at well under what was market value assuming he can recover well from the ACL

I like Doedee - I hope he stays (at a reasonable price).

 

[Crow till I die]

I like Doedee - I hope he stays (at a reasonable price).

Signing him for lower money benefits our overall salary cap going forward. If we have saved potentially 500k over 3 years for example on what we were initially prepared to spend, it allows us be more flexible with upping other contracts to retain players or to go after what we need trade wise.