2023 mid season draft - Name your player you want

which player you want richmond to select in the mid season draft

  • Luke Teal - 19 year old 190cm 85kgs smart HBF Tigga replacement

    Votes: 29 24.0%
  • Mutaz El Nour - 22 year old 192cm 85gks 3rd tall defender Nathan Broad replacement

    Votes: 12 9.9%
  • Tyreece Leiu - 20 year old 195cm 93kgs KP Defender Tarrant Replacement

    Votes: 5 4.1%
  • Ethan Phillips - 24 year old KP Defender Another Tarrant Replacement

    Votes: 3 2.5%
  • Archie May - 21 year old KPF /Ruck 198cm 94kgs Never can have enough Rucks that can play foward

    Votes: 17 14.0%
  • Archie Lovelock - 18 year old Mid /Small Foward 179cm 75kgs missed out last year playing glenelg

    Votes: 7 5.8%
  • Liam McBean - 28 year old 202cm 100kgs Small Foward shows enormous potential as a castagna replace

    Votes: 30 24.8%
  • Other - Name in a post

    Votes: 18 14.9%

  • Total voters
    121

Remove this Banner Ad

Just a bit of chatter around that West Coast or Hawthorn will pick up Hunter; and no one knows the direction that North will go.
Been hanging out around the water cooler down at AFL HOUSE too?
Jimmy Fallon Lol GIF by The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon
 
Don’t think I’d take such a short term view in terms of availability ruling the decision, my only beef with Hunter is he looks mighty similar to Bauer his highlights were exactly the same and we haven’t played him
Taller, faster, higher is Hunter, he is elite in speed 2.9 over 20 and leap, Top10 national for standing leap at 2020 combine and grown to 196cm

Bauer is more like your smooth moving Gunston third tall at 191cm.

Regardless, you got to be able to play them to develop and we have a free hit for the rest of the season with JR8 around to teach forward craft.

I like Buller, he is a footballer and attacks the ball and man fiercely. Nank has forged a career out of this. If fit he could walk straight into the game against GWS and that may have you choose him if it was line ball, but he ain't so it doesn't
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I worry about Buller ability next level a bit more than Hunter. Think Hunters athletic tools will allow him a better chance to play well at the next level. As you stated, he has elite level athletic ability and he’s the exact type you take here.

Not saying Buller can’t or won’t make it, but working on percentage wise, think for me, it’s Hunter.
 
Taller, faster, higher is Hunter, he is elite in speed 2.9 over 20 and leap, Top10 national for standing leap at 2020 combine and grown to 196cm

Bauer is more like your smooth moving Gunston third tall at 191cm.

Regardless, you got to be able to play them to develop and we have a free hit for the rest of the season with JR8 around to teach forward craft.

I like Buller, he is a footballer and attacks the ball and man fiercely. Nank has forged a career out of this. If fit he could walk straight into the game against GWS and that may have you choose him if it was line ball, but he ain't so it doesn't

Nice summation.

Our key forward stocks are the worst in the league. The sad reality is I could go through nearly every single AFL list and I could pick a key forward (or multiple) that would walk into our best 22.

We need a base to start somewhere. A big, solid young key forward with good form behind him is a huge upgrade on what we have to pick from (even if upside is capped). I still maintain Ryan is our future first ruck. Don't see it with him as a forward.
 
Nice summation.

Our key forward stocks are the worst in the league. The sad reality is I could go through nearly every single AFL list and I could pick a key forward (or multiple) that would walk into our best 22.

We need a base to start somewhere. A big, solid young key forward with good form beyond him is a huge upgrade on what we have to pick from (even if upside is capped). I still maintain Ryan is our future first ruck. Don't see it with him as a forward.
Yeah, Ryan's hands give me zero confidence he'll be a KPF. Great ruck potential though. I have even less confidence in Bradke... Could've already had Teal on our list. Bauer is a better defender than forward imo. Stocks are low.
 
I worry about Buller ability next level a bit more than Hunter. Think Hunters athletic tools will allow him a better chance to play well at the next level. As you stated, he has elite level athletic ability and he’s the exact type you take here.

Not saying Buller can’t or won’t make it, but working on percentage wise, think for me, it’s Hunter.
Richmond also looks more favourably on pressure acts and forward defence. Hence why Noah C cant get into the side
 
Maric, Buller, Hunter, and Tresize. At least one of these players (and other KPFs) will be available at our first pick, so surely we don’t stuff this draft up and pick a pure ruck…

Carry On Crying GIF by michael a. salter
We'll take Tucker and Matty Clarke will strut out with a cigar between his teeth and his arms draped over a couple of floozies and rattle off 'we like his versatility, he can play in the ruck and go forward and go back and clunk marks in defence'.
Later on we learn that he's like 99.99% of ruckmen and is shit at everything but rucking.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Nice summation.

Our key forward stocks are the worst in the league. The sad reality is I could go through nearly every single AFL list and I could pick a key forward (or multiple) that would walk into our best 22.

We need a base to start somewhere. A big, solid young key forward with good form behind him is a huge upgrade on what we have to pick from (even if upside is capped). I still maintain Ryan is our future first ruck. Don't see it with him as a forward.
Not worse than Melbourne's. They have JVR then literally no one under 30. They do have Ben Brown, Tom McDonald and a resting ruck :sick:
Do West Coast have anyone outside of Allen? Darling is cooked.
 
I worry about Buller ability next level a bit more than Hunter. Think Hunters athletic tools will allow him a better chance to play well at the next level. As you stated, he has elite level athletic ability and he’s the exact type you take here.

Not saying Buller can’t or won’t make it, but working on percentage wise, think for me, it’s Hunter.
That’s exactly what I am worried about with Buller. Hunter though looks agile and athletic. Kinda like Charlie Curnow and Jeremy Cameron (although I’m not saying they’re similar in skill level). I think athletic KPFs like that adapt better to the modern AFL game.
 
Key forward first pick or the clubs list management team should be fired


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
It's a rookie draft. There ain't much to choose from. If we feel the most likely player to succeed is a half back flanker, then we should take them.
 
It's a rookie draft. There ain't much to choose from. If we feel the most likely player to succeed is a half back flanker, then we should take them.

This is an overlooked point IMO.

I haven’t done a deep dive into the upcoming draft, but on face value it would seem that the likes of Maric may go somewhere around 30. Guys like Buller maybe in the 40s.

Ultimately, take the players you think have the best opportunity to be AFL players. If two are ranked relatively equal, the position of need should be tie breaker.

No point taking a player just because they play a position if they are unlikely to ever be an AFL player if there are likely AFL players available.

That said, we should get a KPF at some point.
 
Nice summation.

Our key forward stocks are the worst in the league. The sad reality is I could go through nearly every single AFL list and I could pick a key forward (or multiple) that would walk into our best 22.

We need a base to start somewhere. A big, solid young key forward with good form behind him is a huge upgrade on what we have to pick from (even if upside is capped). I still maintain Ryan is our future first ruck. Don't see it with him as a forward.
Is that incl Tom lynch
Who are Coll tall key forwards
Melb ?
PA we’re finlayson and lord
I wouldn’t get to hysterical the benchmark isn’t very high
 
Is that incl Tom lynch
Who are Coll tall key forwards
Melb ?
PA we’re finlayson and lord
I wouldn’t get to hysterical the benchmark isn’t very high
That's a good point, not many gun KPF's in the comp right now.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

2023 mid season draft - Name your player you want

Back
Top