MRP / Trib. 2023 MRP Lotto

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Round arm that does nothing - 2 weeks

Errant elbow that concussed someone - not cited.

AFL - the most poorly run sporting organisation in the world and by a hefty margin. People are leaving the sport in droves because of the blatant inconsistencies in almost all facets of the game.

Gils legacy will be ******* the game beyond repair.

On SM-G991B using BigFooty.com mobile app
Biggest joke

Zero consistency
 
I guess the head is back to being sacrosanct this week.
See post below…Only matters when the head high contact is to a non north player.
Kelly gets up and runs out the game . Horne gets 2 weeks
McKay gets concussed, gets subbed out of the game and has to miss the next week too because of protocol’s . Carrara McDonalds player no case to answer 🤔


In all seriousness Buddy only got a week for smacking Cotchin in the chin. How is that any worse than what JHF did to Kelly.

The inconsistency is laughable.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Someone get onto the phone to Josh Kelly and guilt him into saying he staged. Used us to bump up your contract a few times, it's the least he could do.
Hopefully Josh goes into his backyard tonight and steps in some of his dogs sh$t, slips and misses 2 weeks with concussion.
 
Club should appeal both to downgrade. Jhf definitely deserves a week but not 2 Lachie? Nothing in that
110%

To suspend Young is verging on corruption - his action was totally aimed at the ball. De Boer basically face planted himself. That is a travesty.

I also cannot believe 2 weeks for JHF. I expected one, even though we've all seen other players do worse and get off or a week.

It looks to me that the MRP is the part of the AFL that displays the least integrity of all - and that is saying something.
 
Someone get onto the phone to Josh Kelly and guilt him into saying he staged. Used us to bump up your contract a few times, it's the least he could do
He'd only say he was gonna say he staged it ... farkin poser
 
2? you're joking.

Have to challenge based on the absurdity of that.
That action has never been graded as intentional.

This bloke comes up with new gradings to contradict his previous headings on every occasion a North player is involved.

The Young suspension is even more laughable. This guy isn’t even hiding the vendetta he has against our club.
 
I suppose we should be grateful Flynn Perez escaped sanction for damaging Perryman's ribs
Not so quick

butters stotch jail GIF by South Park
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Just make it up as you go.

It looked bad, so it must be worth something.

It didn't look bad. I was about 30 metres away. Kelly contributed to it by diving into it.

But, I would be prepared to accept it as a reportable offence, if the same had happened to Ainsworth last week when he ran to the contest with Ben McKay and LIFTED, yes LIFTED his elbow to connect with the left side of Ben's head, causing him to be concussed.

This is a classic case of one rule for one club and another rule for another club and it is simply scandalous.
 
It didn't look bad. I was about 30 metres away. Kelly contributed to it by diving into it.

But, I would be prepared to accept it as a reportable offence, if the same had happened to Ainsworth last week when he ran to the contest with Ben McKay and LIFTED, yes LIFTED his elbow to connect with the left side of Ben's head, causing him to be concussed.

This is a classic case of one rule for one club and another rule for another club and it is simply scandalous.
At first glance it looks like the initial strike is to the top of the shoulder and then slips up.

Look I can understand the week. It wasn’t necessary and regardless he made contact with the head.

My issue is the 2 weeks. Franklin clenched a fist and threw a punch off the ball, yet that’s worth less according to this ********.
 
It didn't look bad. I was about 30 metres away. Kelly contributed to it by diving into it.

But, I would be prepared to accept it as a reportable offence, if the same had happened to Ainsworth last week when he ran to the contest with Ben McKay and LIFTED, yes LIFTED his elbow to connect with the left side of Ben's head, causing him to be concussed.

This is a classic case of one rule for one club and another rule for another club and it is simply scandalous.
It looked bad insofar as it was a late swinging arm in the head region.

I agree with the rest of what you said.
 
Both have accepted their bans.

 
Both have accepted their bans.

Nice. Totally deserved.

More North players should be reported and suspended on a more frequent basis. On the other hand, Buddy, accidentally slapping and punching Cotchin should have been let off because he's kicked more than 1000 goals.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top