Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[King Max]

Does the HH shadow loom large?

Anyone have HH in their team? PS watch for me.

 

[MacStradbroke]

Anyone have HH in their team? PS watch for me.

Too much uncertainty isn’t there? If he was def back I’d have him in for sure.

 

[kananooks]

touk and salem vs cumming and warner?

 

[Significant]

touk and salem vs cumming and warner?

Touk Salem

 

[mattsmob]

Steele, Salem and Bowes vs Dawson, Daicos and Ginbey/(expensive rookie)

 

[King_Steele]

Steele, Salem and Bowes vs Dawson, Daicos and Ginbey/(expensive rookie)

Dawson, Daicos & Ginbey

 

[Obese Arachnid]

N. Daicos, or H. Young?

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Parish vs Merrett? Taking one of them due to their fixture is pretty easy early on for players of their quality, hoping they are a little pod which will give me a better chance at a better rank early on.

Parish always try and avoid the tag target in those x/y situations
Like Bont vs Macrae over the past few years if it came down to the two I’d always go Macrae

Reckon Parish is a great pick this year personally

 

[Significant]

Salem & Sheed vs Goater & Grundy

 

[Bjchan13]

Parish always try and avoid the tag target in those x/y situations
Like Bont vs Macrae over the past few years if it came down to the two I’d always go Macrae

Reckon Parish is a great pick this year personally

Depends whether Scott lets Parish play the same way as Rutten did. Which was essentially ball hunter, dont worry about a man. All Essendon supporters would rather see Darcy have 20 odd while being accountable defensively, rather than 40 stats and loose. Still a couple of unknowns with Essendons midfield set up but i have Merrett at this stage

 

[kananooks]

Salem & Sheed vs Goater & Grundy

salem and sheed. both capable of 90 avg. grundy is about 100 and goater wouldnt be more than 60ish

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

salem and sheed. both capable of 90 avg. grundy is about 100 and goater wouldnt be more than 60ish

Both capable of 75 too.

Grundy could go 110+ if Gawn is LTI, and Goater scored 70 on debut and is a year bigger and stronger.

 

[JRyan23]

Hi guys, back for another year!

First one off the bat
Hopper, English and T.Thomas
or
Titch, Cameron, Allen


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Hi guys, back for another year!

First one off the bat
Hopper, English and T.Thomas
or
Titch, Cameron, Allen


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Hopper, English and T.Thomas (If he plays)

 

[DazzaE]

Petracca or Neale*

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Petracca or Neale*

Neale could be a good trade in target, as Brisbane have the first bye. Also gives you a chance to see how Dunkley effects his scoring.

Flip side is he usually starts the season fast.

In summary - dunno

 

[DazzaE]

Neale could be a good trade in target, as Brisbane have the first bye. Also gives you a chance to see how Dunkley effects his scoring.

Flip side is he usually starts the season fast.

In summary - dunno

Not sure if Dunkley with help or reduce Neale’s scoring - may take some attention from him

 

[Exambolor]

I’m trying to slightly differentiate my SC side from my Fantasy side so I’m trying to decide on who my M2 will be

Touk v Clarry

I’m thinking I can’t go wrong with either of them, but it’s a tough choice. I’m thinking of going with Clarry as I have Touk in my Fantasy side.

 

[marcmurphy3]

I’m trying to slightly differentiate my SC side from my Fantasy side so I’m trying to decide on who my M2 will be

Touk v Clarry

I’m thinking I can’t go wrong with either of them, but it’s a tough choice. I’m thinking of going with Clarry as I have Touk in my Fantasy side.

I think Clarry will average slightly more though Touks bye makes he tempting

 

[1989]

Oliver

I’m trying to slightly differentiate my SC side from my Fantasy side so I’m trying to decide on who my M2 will be

Touk v Clarry

I’m thinking I can’t go wrong with either of them, but it’s a tough choice. I’m thinking of going with Clarry as I have Touk in my Fantasy side.

Not factoring in the price difference, I'd take Oliver, as I think he's a bettter VC/C option. Factoring in the price difference, I think Touk is a must have at 662K.

Mine is:

Bontempelli & Macrae

versus

Oliver & LDU

???

 

[Exambolor]

I think Clarry will average slightly more though Touks bye makes he tempting

Thats the thing. Neither will be terrible picks but it’s more a strategy thing which makes it tough lol

 

[Exambolor]

Oliver

Not factoring in the price difference, I'd take Oliver, as I think he's a bettter VC/C option. Factoring in the price difference, I think Touk is a must have at 662K.

Mine is:

Bontempelli & Macrae

versus

Oliver & LDU

???

I’d go with the latter purely becuase LDU is primed for a breakout season.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Oliver

Not factoring in the price difference, I'd take Oliver, as I think he's a bettter VC/C option. Factoring in the price difference, I think Touk is a must have at 662K.

Mine is:

Bontempelli & Macrae

versus

Oliver & LDU

???

Bont and Macrae are both underpriced imo. Macrae especially could easily go back to 125+

Can't see LDU outscoring either of them.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Bont and Macrae are both underpriced imo. Macrae especially could easily go back to 125+

Can't see LDU outscoring either of them.

Ok so who taking lachie hunters role in their match aims?

 

[Northernsoul74]

I’m trying to slightly differentiate my SC side from my Fantasy side so I’m trying to decide on who my M2 will be

Touk v Clarry

I’m thinking I can’t go wrong with either of them, but it’s a tough choice. I’m thinking of going with Clarry as I have Touk in my Fantasy side.