Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Wellsy35]

Who gets the better candidate for the E loop tonight? Oskar Baker or Matt Johnson?

This is my dilemma too - I need to field one and loop the other with Phillipou.

Tempted to roll the dice with Johnson on field and loop Baker - Johnson is named in the mid rotations, while Baker is out on the wing and has only scored above 60 once. Johnson is going at 0.8 PPM while Baker goes at 0.5 FWIW.

Who are you looping them against?

 

[PoopingHindi]

Ser..right at 500k at the start would of been a winner ..

I probably would have traded him out after round 1 anyway

 

[SloppyJoe]

This is my dilemma too - I need to field one and loop the other with Phillipou.

Tempted to roll the dice with Johnson on field and loop Baker - Johnson is named in the mid rotations, while Baker is out on the wing and has only scored above 60 once. Johnson is going at 0.8 PPM while Baker goes at 0.5 FWIW.

Who are you looping them against?

Me too.

Leaning towards Johnson. He's at home, whereas Baker has back to back travel.

 

[cheeseypizza]

De Goey misses too many games for mine. Serong more durable, younger and hungrier, but less value and playing in a shitter team.

Guess it depends - what is that $60k extra gonna get you?

Yeh that's a good point on De Goey missing games, nothing immediate springs to mind with the 60k but sometimes I always end up paying for these types of trades at the end of the season by not going for more value.

 

[Korupt]

This is my dilemma too - I need to field one and loop the other with Phillipou.

Tempted to roll the dice with Johnson on field and loop Baker - Johnson is named in the mid rotations, while Baker is out on the wing and has only scored above 60 once. Johnson is going at 0.8 PPM while Baker goes at 0.5 FWIW.

Who are you looping them against?

Looping against LEdwards.

I agree with your points, however Baker has played in wet conditions recently and on a fast, dry Optus track tonight could get plenty of outside ball and get close to a repeat of his 95 a few weeks ago. Johnson's TOG worries me and up against some decent opposition inside-mids (if that's his role) in Libba, Treloar and Bont.

 

[Wellsy35]

Looping against LEdwards.

I agree with your points, however Baker has played in wet conditions recently and on a fast, dry Optus track tonight could get plenty of outside ball and get close to a repeat of his 95 a few weeks ago. Johnson's TOG worries me and up against some decent opposition inside-mids (if that's his role) in Libba, Treloar and Bont.

Wasn't wet against Melbourne or St. Kilda though, and still scored sub-60.

In my mind, it's probably a gain of +10 if both score to the mean (more likely) or a loss of -30 if Baker goes big (less likely).

 

[SC fish]

Who gets the better candidate for the E loop tonight? Oskar Baker or Matt Johnson?

I'm leaning towards Johnson over Baker but might change my mind

 

[Northernsoul74]

I'm leaning towards Johnson over Baker but might change my mind

 

[Mr_Cantaloupe]

Chandler v Phillipou v F.Greene v Rowston on field?

Can’t E-loophole their scores

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Chandler v Phillipou v F.Greene v Rowston on field?

Can’t E-loophole their scores

Fergus is starting to find his rythum I think he will do well down in tassie this week.

 

[weltschmerz]

Serong or Merrett?

 

[PoopingHindi]

Serong or Merrett?

Merrett
proven performer in a better side

 

[PoopingHindi]

Luke Ryan or Cogs?

 

[King_Steele]

Luke Ryan or Cogs?

Cogs

 

[Petrify]

Day vs Ziebell

i hate that i might bring Ziebell in now so late but the kent is driving me insane with his cheapies and is still good value

 

[HEYTRUEROO]

Sicily vs Sinclair vs Parish vs Mills

 

[PoopingHindi]

Sicily vs Sinclair vs Parish vs Mills

Sinclair seems to be the flavour of the month in these parts but I’d take Parish.
His role is set in stone unlike Sinc or Mills and he can get hot and go on big scoring runs.
I like Sicily the least but it’s pure gut feel.

 

[HEYTRUEROO]

Sinclair seems to be the flavour of the month in these parts but I’d take Parish.
His role is set in stone unlike Sinc or Mills and he can get hot and go on big scoring runs.
I like Sicily the least but it’s pure gut feel.

Thanks for response.
Why do you think Sic is scoring less this year do you think?

 

[toxic]

Coz saints are winning, less b

Thanks for response.
Why do you think Sic is scoring less this year do you think?

Coz saints are winning

Less ball in backline

 

[HEYTRUEROO]

Coz saints are winning, less b
Coz saints are winning

Less ball in backline

Sorry, Sic was meant to be Sicily

 

[gutsroy]

Day + 100k vs Sinclair

 

[rocker_oz33]

Sinclair seems to be the flavour of the month in these parts but I’d take Parish.
His role is set in stone unlike Sinc or Mills and he can get hot and go on big scoring runs.
I like Sicily the least but it’s pure gut feel.

Mills is a gun but is used in other areas .because he's good anywhere

If both used in the same role I feel mills can win .

 

[rocker_oz33]

Day + 100k vs Sinclair

Depends on what thank 100 gets you .

Mullet boy a bit more proven ...

 

[HEYTRUEROO]

Day + 100k vs Sinclair

Sinc. I feel like I'm the only one on here not even remotely interested in Day.

 

[PoopingHindi]

Thanks for response.
Why do you think Sic is scoring less this year do you think?

He’s taking less kick ins but overall possessions and marks are about the same as last season. it’s probably a DE/effectiveness thing