Trades 2023 Round 13 trades - second week of the byes

[WaynesWorld19]

 

[Blvckboard]

Trade Out, understanding I would be trading them out early before their byes.

Option 1
Sheezel this week, Day next week

Option 2
Day this week, Sheezel next week

Trade In

Option 1
Neale this week, Sinclair next week

Option 2
Sinclair this week, Neale next week

 

[Makeshift Park]

Circa 6k ranking.

From one extreme (trading in SP Trac and Clarry) to the other (trading in budget price DCam, Lloyd and Brayshaw), all in the space of 48 hours.




Then, bring in either Petracca or Oliver after their bye (move Rozee fwd), concede that Imma have to classify Sheezel, Day and Humphrey as "premos" for the sake of completion, and await the inevitable carnage.

 

[croweater 41]

Trade Out, understanding I would be trading them out early before their byes.

Option 1
Sheezel this week, Day next week

Option 2
Day this week, Sheezel next week

Trade In

Option 1
Neale this week, Sinclair next week

Option 2
Sinclair this week, Neale next week

You are probably better to cash Sheez if you are set on these two options.

 

[croweater 41]

Smoking back line ..

Shame my midfield can't be the same...

I just don't like the options of Neale and Brayshaw off byes this week and then even more limited next week with Gee/GC options.

I am just going to try and hold firm for a little bit longer and pray for no injuries.

 

[Lord De Goey]

I understand your trades.
Get the best guys you can before some lose value while upgrading where possible.

Problem I see is almost zero bench coverage for ‘break glass in case of emergency’.

Also your shorting your stock in selling your rookies early, maybe too early before their BE’s are higher than say last 3 round average (in Weddle).
I’m guessing its because of FOMO as others are all talking about the race to get to full premo onfield.

Who is gonna generate cash for you going forward or is the only aim is to get to full premo, put the cue in the rack, and just say, ‘yep I won’, before taking the last shot to pot the black ball.

Mind you this is not aimed at you alone personally but it is how we were taught to play the game by successful cases of historical pasts.
Get to full premo during byes for the run home.

If you are taking a risk at getting Lloyd who isn’t a bad choice, why not take a look at Himmelberg and keep Weddle for a little saving and hope H’berg keeps playing down back in a switch like he did last year where he performed better. Also keeps a F/D swing open.
Keys pick I like, right amount of risk reward at price point. Also JZ is looking cooked.
Day for Brawshaw is a bit of a zero sum trade as the points gained for a trade is a very small increase on averages.

Sorry for the over analysis.
Had a few spare minutes.

Thanks for the response! I’ll be honest the trades I’m most likely leaning towards are Ziebell and Cincotta to Neale and Keays. Leaving me with Ridley and Day at D5/6, Sheezel and Keays at F5/6 and 7 trades to turn Wardlaw, Ford, Weddle, Johnson into my last midfielder. I could even do a third trade this week and go Weddle to Fyfe, bank 80k for my last upgrade and loop Fyfe/Sheezel/Keays every week.

Would have made more sense to include the quote lol

 

[stevebbb]

Hey lads, what would you do?




option 1:
-Weddle to Brayshaw

-Briggs to Cameron (rd15)

7 trades left and probably $75k-ish in the bank for luxury upgrades post bye



option 2:
-Weddle to Brayshaw
-Ziebell to Neale

-Briggs to Cameron (rd15)

6 trades left and no cash in the bank for luxury upgrades post bye



option 3:
-???



Trades vs points

 

[Scythe94]

Hey lads, what would you do?

View attachment 1706519


option 1:
-Weddle to Brayshaw

-Briggs to Cameron (rd15)

7 trades left and probably $75k-ish in the bank for luxury upgrades post bye



option 2:
-Weddle to Brayshaw
-Ziebell to Neale

-Briggs to Cameron (rd15)

6 trades left and no cash in the bank for luxury upgrades post bye



option 3:
-???



Trades vs points

I like option 2. Better bye coverage, and six trades with a completed side is more than a lot of teams will have at this rate.

You'd want to hope that Steele at least resembles a keeper though. Who knows, maybe the break did him good.

 

[Kedford]

Alot of potential trade in's are hitting high prices that I don't want to trade in like Butters, Sicily, Macrae and Petracca.

Who is everyone eyeing off in the next 3 rounds?

Only two that could be potential value that I like are Sam Walsh

18

Sam Walsh

Age

24

Ht

184cm

Wt

84kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

25.1

5star

K

13.5

5star

HB

11.6

5star

M

5.1

5star

T

3.2

5star

CL

3.4

5star

No current season stats available

D

26.2

5star

K

15.4

5star

HB

10.8

5star

M

6.0

5star

T

3.2

5star

CL

4.8

5star

and Jake Lloyd

44

Jake Lloyd

Age

31

Ht

182cm

Wt

81kg

Pos.

D/M

Career

Season

Last 5

D

23.4

5star

K

14.4

5star

HB

9.0

5star

M

4.3

4star

T

1.9

4star

MG

403.9

5star

D

23.4

5star

K

14.4

5star

HB

9.0

4star

M

4.3

4star

T

1.9

3star

MG

403.9

5star

D

23.2

5star

K

13.4

5star

HB

9.8

5star

M

4.2

4star

T

2.2

4star

MG

357.4

5star

.

 

[TheArchitect]

Alot of potential trade in's are hitting high prices that I don't want to trade in like Butters, Sicily, Macrae and Petracca.

Who is everyone eyeing off in the next 3 rounds?

Only two that could be potential value that I like are Sam Walsh and Jake Lloyd.

Steele, Mills, and Dangerfield are all on my radar currently.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Alot of potential trade in's are hitting high prices that I don't want to trade in like Butters, Sicily, Macrae and Petracca.

Who is everyone eyeing off in the next 3 rounds?

Only two that could be potential value that I like are Sam Walsh and Jake Lloyd.

Neale, Brayshaw, D Cameron and... dare I say it... Tarryn Thomas

 

[YeoGabbaGabba]

Sheezel to Cameron
De Goey to Anderson



Or De Goey to Walsh, Titch…

If you’re thinking De Goey to Anderson surely it can wait until after the bye? Just in case there’s somehow a training injury or something before Gold Coast’s game after the bye (edit: Just seen it was a response to a trade suggestion, but still would suggest waiting a week if Anderson was the play as neither’s value would change)

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hey lads, what would you do?

View attachment 1706519


option 1:
-Weddle to Brayshaw

-Briggs to Cameron (rd15)

7 trades left and probably $75k-ish in the bank for luxury upgrades post bye



option 2:
-Weddle to Brayshaw
-Ziebell to Neale

-Briggs to Cameron (rd15)

6 trades left and no cash in the bank for luxury upgrades post bye



option 3:
-???



Trades vs points

Option 2 is smoking ..

 

[AFDogs]

Just Simpson > Mullin bank some cash for a Sheezel upgrade next week.

 

[Sketi]

To trade JZ or not to trade JZ, that is the question... 13 trades left, 4 rookies left to upgrade including Ashcroft and Humpa, one of who I might have to end up keeping at M8/F6.

 

[Test Tickle]

Not many rookies around and I have Davey and Drury as E loophole options and 13 trades left.

Thinking Baker > Fyfe this week, then Mitchell > Windhager (if selected) next week and banking 200k.
Also gives me 2 more playing in Rd 15.

discuss.

 

[evo]

Not many rookies around and I have Davey and Drury as E loophole options and 13 trades left.

Thinking Baker > Fyfe this week, then Mitchell > Windhager (if selected) next week and banking 200k.
Also gives me 2 more playing in Rd 15.

discuss.

Windbag seems to be about as bad at Supercoach as Davey is.

 

[Test Tickle]

Windbag seems to be about as bad at Supercoach as Davey is.

Many Saints fans believe he's been training with the midfield and that he'll be selected now that HC is out to play on the ball. Been racking them up in the twos.

 

[jdwood]

Not many rookies around and I have Davey and Drury as E loophole options and 13 trades left.

Thinking Baker > Fyfe this week, then Mitchell > Windhager (if selected) next week and banking 200k.
Also gives me 2 more playing in Rd 15.

discuss.

Don’t mind it (though not sold on Fyfe personally).

I think for trades pre round 15, we are going to have to be creative in how we fund upgrades - which is what you are doing.

I’m personally not going to touch any non playing DPP while the byes are still on foot because I’m determined to ensure I’ve got 18+ for both 14 and 15. That means that anyone I bring in needs to have solid JS over that period.

Post round 15, I think there is a role for one or two non playing DPP because they depth of your bench becomes less important.

 

[rocker_oz33]

To trade JZ or not to trade JZ, that is the question... 13 trades left, 4 rookies left to upgrade including Ashcroft and Humpa, one of who I might have to end up keeping at M8/F6.

I think JZ prob scores ok in Tassie.

Unsure on he's record there...just a gut feel.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Windbag seems to be about as bad at Supercoach as Davey is.

Surprised Windy tagger hasn't played much this year .
I thought Ross would like him..

188 with dpp be 77 odd ...get a free look this round.

Cin,Angwin, dorks wookies to him next week...might be an option ..

 

[rocker_oz33]

Just Simpson > Mullin bank some cash for a Sheezel upgrade next week.

Doubt Mullins makes the cats rd 14 team.

But pretty light on wookies atm .

 

[Sketi]

I think JZ prob scores ok in Tassie.

Unsure on he's record there...just a gut feel.

Dude needs the bye like nothing else, looked absolutely cooked on the weekend.

 

[Falchoon]

Many Saints fans believe he's been training with the midfield and that he'll be selected now that HC is out to play on the ball. Been racking them up in the twos.

probs ahead of Seb Ross too.

(& Gresham)

 

[BrutThough]

Putting out a call for Scoopsnet intel on whether any of the following bye-all-done smokey-dokey's are worth a shot if you're on a tight budget, feeling creative(ly confined), or just very deliberately aiming unique to make up ground:


Wilkie (very invested in club success, big game player? What's with the 20 and the 50?)

B Crouch ($100K+ down, would be a decent cheap M8 at his best, how's he traveling? Steele a factor if he keeps playing hurt?)

N Wanganeen-Milera (is he building to tons? wait next year or two?)

-----------------------------------------------

Blakey (big new contract, talls returning, can go massive and will put in 100% every week)

Rampe (where did those early big scores come from? Could they return?)

----------------------------------------------

Rich (played most of last year, Lions have struggled to replace him, have they now got him right for a big push to finals? Tons awaiting? Sub/rest risk?)

Daniher (not cheap, but he's as mercurial as they get. Could easily be a top forward at season's end)

McCluggage (bit similar M8 possibility profile to Crouch - can he turn it around? If you have Neale, does he cover him going AWOL to some degree?)

Andrews (might bottom out much lower than usual at this rate and can go massive in big games)

-----------------------------------------------

Young
Cox
O'Meara
Fyfe

-----------------------------------------------

Didn't comment for the Freo blokes because they're all kinda obvious risk/reward.

Did I miss anyone?

Can we make a case that one of these less common alternatives could bring a rogue side home with a wet sail?

NWM might be a good value pick if Sinclair continues to get played in the midfield.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Hey lads, what would you do?

View attachment 1706519


option 1:
-Weddle to Brayshaw

-Briggs to Cameron (rd15)

7 trades left and probably $75k-ish in the bank for luxury upgrades post bye



option 2:
-Weddle to Brayshaw
-Ziebell to Neale

-Briggs to Cameron (rd15)

6 trades left and no cash in the bank for luxury upgrades post bye



option 3:
-???



Trades vs points

Option 2 easily

DC you can get after his bye via Briggs