Trades 2023 Round 3 Trades - Moo Time !

[freddy mercury]

Y'all gonna break English and **** him over for the coaches who backed him before rd 1. You're all a bunch of kents who need to be Alfed.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Y'all gonna break English and * him over for the coaches who backed him before rd 1. You're all a bunch of kents who need to be Alfed.

How do you think us Setterfield owners feel

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

How do you think us Setterfield owners feel

Less lonely than last week

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Have done this....
2 keepers and a rookie-price for 3 mid-pricers

View attachment 1643517

I must be insane. But I like it!

Which leaves me with this....

View attachment 1643521 in le puswah (it's an Obese Arachnid ism) and...

View attachment 1643519


So, my dear SC experts and fellow kents.

Are these the wrong trades?
There is a more sensible option. But I can barely pronounce the word, let alone live it.

Which would you choose? Each reply gets free noodz in their PM's (may or may not be me).

A) Cameron, Setterfield, Ziebell + $424k bank
or
B) English, Oliver, Chandler + $190k bank

View attachment 1643530

Second one, English will be worth bulk cash when he goes down.

Then you boost & spend, opposite to coke.

 

[Rayzorwire]

How do you think us Setterfield owners feel

Safely onboard and not prone in the slightest to wild bouts of FOMO?

 

[CanadianKanga]

Is Chandler a must? I've got an opportunity to get all 3 of Zeibell, Setterfield, and D Cameron if I skip on Chandler or Hollands. Or is this a greedy short sighted strategy that is compromising cash generation on bench?

 

[Raveneyes]

38k overall, team is cooked

Yes the Pies did well to win the 2023 March premiership Well done

View attachment 1643538View attachment 1643541
View attachment 1643542

End of March you'll be ninth.... kent!

 

[Quazza]

Y'all gonna break English and * him over for the coaches who backed him before rd 1. You're all a bunch of kents who need to be Alfed.

I feel that way about Naicos.

Starting with him about the only thing I got right

 

[Quazza]

i dunno, i pretty well already hate my team. Have toyed with trading Doc to free up $$ but there's no one in particular I would trade him to

Darcy>Cameron like everyone else? I guess

OPen to all ideas (no matter how crazy)

 

[Raveneyes]

Are you sure you can handle a more MPM team?

I think you are more comfortable with GnRs.

So option B for you.

Setterfield, Ziebell and DCameron is 2023 SC.

I've got no doubt about it.

Gawn's injury makes it an absolute no brainer for you

Second one, English will be worth bulk cash when he goes down.

Then you boost & spend, opposite to coke.

Admit it. You're just replying for the noooodz.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Less lonely than last week

 

[Northernsoul74]

Ridley has St Kilda this week, who have a forward line of spuds and dwarfs and gave up 500 points to 3 Freo players.

Spare a thought for us Bulldogs fans. Reading this will likely send us over the edge.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Admit it. You're just replying for the noooodz.

 

[gutsroy]

All these kents talking about how they've got to burn trades and how you've got to be aggressive this year etc etc...

I thought the higher ranked you are the more aggressive you're supposed to be?

I understand there's more trades this year and everything, but it goes against my fibres to just randomly stark nuking trades.

View attachment 1643254

I'm avoiding all the "hot" options this week like LDU, Setterpenis, Ziebull.

Only trade i'm actually considering is Chesser to Chandler (can't pass up that cash flow). Am i wrong?


View attachment 1643255

Darko, Sharkasaurus (can I call you Sharkasaurus?), Darkasaurus Rex,
No offence mate but you're entering Gina Rinehart areas there...
It's not the lads and lasses whose only concern is a nosebleed due to their current altitude who are contemplating big moves, it's the poor bastards down at 80k trying to extricate themselves from the morass that are weighing up business of the risky persuasion.
(Sensational work btw, go hard!)

 

[Tulendeena]

Is Chandler a must? I've got an opportunity to get all 3 of Zeibell, Setterfield, and D Cameron if I skip on Chandler or Hollands. Or is this a greedy short sighted strategy that is compromising cash generation on bench?

I don't think so, maintaining an 82 avg as a small fwd seems unsustainable. Still a fantastic rookie but i don't think he'll break you if you miss him

 

[Carlos Herrrnandez]

Hi All

Can you activate your boost trade after tomorrows lockout? Assuming a yes, but wanted to confirm with the experts

 

[Northernsoul74]

Y'all gonna break English and * him over for the coaches who backed him before rd 1. You're all a bunch of kents who need to be Alfed.

More going Cameron I think.

 

[gutsroy]

Hi All

Can you activate your boost trade after tomorrows lockout? Assuming a yes, but wanted to confirm with the experts

Yeah, anytime in the round up to final game lockout.
¡Qué rico!
Edit: And if you activate one but only end up actually doing two trades in the end, it gets refunded, i.e. only counts as a boost used if you exceed the standard number of trades for the round (2 normally, 3 for some bye rds)

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Macrae > Daicos via DPP
Callaghan > Setterfidies
Esava > Ziebell

Holding Cumming whilst most are flicking him to Daicos. If he finds some form he will now be a genuine POD. Trading Macrae will probably back fire but we’ll see.

 

[Phoenix_9]

Flanders to Chandler. Better scores, more cash gen, and more cash in the bank. No brainer.

Chesser to Setterfield. Massive ticks all around.

The last trade is the only one I’m questioning.
I want/need Daicos.
I can trade Ridley, Docherty or Macrae.

I’m leaning towards Docherty because that gives me the cash to trade someone to Bowes next week, as he looked great.

Thoughts lads?

 

[gutsroy]

Y'all gonna break English and * him over for the coaches who backed him before rd 1. You're all a bunch of kents who need to be Alfed.

Don't make me raise my voice, Frederick.
Everybody gets to pick whoever they like.

Did you Frederick?

 

[Scythe94]

Flanders to Chandler. Better scores, more cash gen, and more cash in the bank. No brainer.

Chesser to Setterfield. Massive ticks all around.

The last trade is the only one I’m questioning.
I want/need Daicos.
I can trade Ridley, Docherty or Macrae.

I’m leaning towards Docherty because that gives me the cash to trade someone to Bowes next week, as he looked great.

Thoughts lads?

In terms of prioritising those three premos:
1. Doc (guaranteed top five DEF)
2. Macrae (SC gun but Bevo factor, plus he seems on the decline)
----
3. Ridley (Crab)

 

[Quazza]

 

[Blackhawk42]

Okay, all set now.

Dale (now due for 120), Chesser and Esava
For
Setterfield, Gulden and McKenna

Essentially an underperforming premium and two useless rookie priced players for a good rookie priced player, a mid-priced gun and a forward premo. I'd say it's a win.

Hopper sits on the pine. Will mean Mackenzie becomes a bench player next week which isn't ideal, but can address that later on.

 

[Bjchan13]

Macrae > Daicos via DPP
Callaghan > Setterfidies
Esava > Ziebell

Holding Cumming whilst most are flicking him to Daicos. If he finds some form he will now be a genuine POD. Trading Macrae will probably back fire but we’ll see.

Ive also gone Macrae to Daicos via DPP. Also holding Cumming, Ridley and Doch who all could've gone for Daicos. Cumming looked ok to the eye last week and i think he can bounce back.