Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

[Mrzohs]

not saying it is fair but we keep hearing "clubs arent happy about North getting free access to Sanders" Imagine the AFL saying okay our formula didnt give them enough here is pick 1 or multiple firsts

would of been outcry league wide that the team that won the flag got all that.

The reality is that Hawthorn didnt do what teams have done since, matched and forced a trade. If they had the time over they probably would of

When the dust settles North could end up with pick 2,3,5 thats crazy!

• North will get pick 3 for Mckay.
• North will receive a pick from the AFL mid first round compensation 11.

If they make a play for pick 4 (5) with 11,14. Rediciolous handicap.

 

[LunchboxLegend]

No Chol needed. CJ can be our new marking forward we need for free. He reads the flight so well, great hands and can get up high. Give him a preseason as a forward as he’s not going to get many games down back.

Forward craft is a thing. Takes years.
Cant just plug in a good marker.

 

[CaptainWorpedo]

not saying it is fair but we keep hearing "clubs arent happy about North getting free access to Sanders" Imagine the AFL saying okay our formula didnt give them enough here is pick 1 or multiple firsts

would of been outcry league wide that the team that won the flag got all that.

The reality is that Hawthorn didnt do what teams have done since, matched and forced a trade. If they had the time over they probably would of

Every time you reply on the topic, you give it more life lol

 

[butlers hawks]

Every time you reply on the topic, you give it more life lol

 

[Howe Amazing]

Provided Frost doesn’t go with Frostball he is a good defender. If he is our KD again next year there has to be players getting handballs from him

 

[SSSSSS]

Have it on good authority that we’re talking to Spargo. He wants opportunities and has sounded out both Hawks and Roos.

Was actually one of the Demons better players on the weekend. One of the only ones who hit a target.

Think he'd be a good get. Can play the Wingard role.

 

[Platten44]

Geelong to get younger with Goldstein

 

[SSSSSS]

All this Chol posting is giving me a Chol.

 

[SSSSSS]

Textbook ball drop that.

 

[GinniAndTonic]

Go have a look at afl exclusive’s Instagram. every trade rumour they have put up hasn’t happened. Don’t believe it

 

[AlwaysHawks15]

Geelong to get younger with Goldstein

What's the point now. Bloke is 36. He missed his chance 2-3 years ago when he was still one of the best rucks in the game. He's still decent but how desperate can you be to think he is going to solve all their problems. They need young rucks not close to retirement ones.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

The irritation comes due to the afl having a clause in the rules saying “this compensation can be adjusted for anomalous results” the argument is that buddy contract was an anomaly that should have a better pick and that McKay is probably anomaly deserving a lesser pick.

Except Frawley got Melbourne a similar pick so, no, McKay getting Norf pick 3 wouldn’t be an anomaly.

 

[Bugs1977]

Mood

 

[GinniAndTonic]

Does any ITK on here actually some new info regarding McKay? Only thing I’ve heard from someone fairly close to the Duursma family is he will almost certainly request a trade.

 

[spudmaster]

What's the point now. Bloke is 36. He missed his chance 2-3 years ago when he was still one of the best rucks in the game. He's still decent but how desperate can you be to think he is going to solve all their problems. They need young rucks not close to retirement ones.

A stop-gap with Ceglar retiring, giving Conway another year or two to develop, and providing coverage for Stanley or allowing him to rotate and not having to use Blicavs.

 

[CaptainWorpedo]

Except Frawley got Melbourne a similar pick so, no, McKay getting Norf pick 3 wouldn’t be an anomaly.

Proving its just the Hawks that get screwed over by the afl with f/a

 

[Ned Ryerson]

The reality is that Hawthorn didnt do what teams have done since, matched and forced a trade. If they had the time over they probably would of

Didn’t we confirm that there wasn’t any feasible way we could match it? That (and because they were furious he didn’t go to GWS) was why they copped draft penalties because they took the piss out of the system.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

Proving its just the Hawks that get screwed over by the afl with f/a

Not really, no. If you want to feel persecuted by literally everything today though, have fun.

 

[GinniAndTonic]

The great man is active.
Hopefully he is type us an update as we speak. I think we all need it

 

[Ned Ryerson]

The great man is active.
Hopefully he is type us an update as we speak. I think we all need it

 

[Hawktalk111]

Was actually one of the Demons better players on the weekend. One of the only ones who hit a target.

Think he'd be a good get. Can play the Wingard role.

Unless all his past issues are fixed his goal accuracy might be deceptive.

Great this year
2023 - 61.1%
played 14 games

But shocking last year
2022 - 38.5% played 24 games

I feel like Melbourne can keep him
2021 - 42.9% played 25 games

Wait 88% in 2020!
…oh he only played 1 game

 

[butlers hawks]

The great man is active.
Hopefully he is type us an update as we speak. I think we all need it

What type of plants does he have for you to hide in outside of his house?

 

[chopflop]

The great man is active.
Hopefully he is type us an update as we speak. I think we all need it

11 to 1 like to post ratio. Truly elite

 

[CaptainWorpedo]

Not really, no. If you want to feel persecuted by literally everything today though, have fun.

Since when has “F/A” become everything? May help if you actually read first!

 

[Brant]

Unless all his past issues are fixed his goal accuracy might be deceptive.

Great this year
2023 - 61.1%
played 14 games

But shocking last year
2022 - 38.5% played 24 games

I feel like Melbourne can keep him
2021 - 42.9% played 25 games

Wait 88% in 2020!
…oh he only played 1 game

Spargo's stats are pretty bad.

At 10 possessions & less than a goal per week, he'll be the one paying us Match Payments every time he plays!




*yup, I'm aware of his comparative stats to Brockman.