Get_The_Gaff
Norm Smith Medallist
- Apr 4, 2021
- 5,572
- 13,001
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Jones is best 22 for sure.
Jones is really quick and tackles hard . He just needs to temper his aggression as he gives away too many frees inside defensive 50 .
-
LIVE: Sydney v Port Adelaide - 7:40 / 7:10 Fri
Squiggle tips Swans at 57% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
-
LIVE: Geelong v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Cats at 54% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Prelim Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round SF Winner: And_ROOS
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
2024 best 22
- Thread starter GoEaglesGoSGIO
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Jones is really quick and tackles hard . He just needs to temper his aggression as he gives away too many frees inside defensive 50 .
I think he should be, but its very hard to fit him in with all the other tall forwards who will get preference.
OA, Darling, BWilliams and Flynn will all be ahead of him
- Dec 11, 2008
- 993
- 288
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Notre Dame
At risk of adding to the "but what about xxxx!"
Young Hough could be about to step right up this year.
It's a common trait with good players to show a bit early on, and then in the 3rd year if you are crossing the 50 games played threshold really go up a level. Houghy's in that zone.
Young Hough could be about to step right up this year.
It's a common trait with good players to show a bit early on, and then in the 3rd year if you are crossing the 50 games played threshold really go up a level. Houghy's in that zone.
- Aug 23, 2022
- 3,139
- 8,421
- AFL Club
- West Coast
I’m not the biggest fan of Jones feel he butchers the ball too much. That role that he’s played off half back, you need élite decision making and foot skills and I personally think Jones is average at both.
Happy if others disagree I know some really like him.
Think Burgiel if he can continue to develop and stay on the park could fill that role.
I think part of the problem is that we seem to be throwing him around a bit in pre-season and then shifting him back.I’m not the biggest fan of Jones feel he butchers the ball too much. That role that he’s played off half back, you need élite decision making and foot skills and I personally think Jones is average at both.
Happy if others disagree I know some really like him.
Think Burgiel if he can continue to develop and stay on the park could fill that role.
I'm hopeful that with some more clarity he can adjust to at least taking his time on the final disposal. He and Duggan are high meters gained, low precision big kicks and that's too many in the backline (if Duggan stays there).
I could see Jones as a territory taking winger like Ed Langdon. A run and carry, get it from the back half to the forward 50 quickly not pretty, chaos making type.
Shared mine in the Media thread - but now on topic I guess.
Here’s Round 1:
B: Liam Duggan, Tom Barrass, Tom Cole
HB: Jayden Hunt, Jeremy McGovern, Elliot Yeo
C: Brady Hough, Reuben Ginbey, Andrew Gaff
HF: Elijah Hewett, Jack Darling, Jamie Cripps
F: Liam Ryan, Oscar Allen, Noah Long
Foll: Matt Flynn, Tom Kelly, Dom Sheed
I/C: Bailey Williams, Tyler Brockman, Alex Witherden, Harley Reid
Sub: Jack Petrucelle
Next cabs off the rank - Jamaine Jones, Jake Waterman, Campbell Chesser
There will be injuries obviously - the back 6 + Witherden is pretty solid, a lot depends of how much footy Gov and Yeo miss. Hough and Ginbey will also spend time back, potentially Jones too.
The midfield is a balance I think - Kelly is easily our best mid now but it’s not really clear who our next best is - probably Yeo if he plays midfield.
As frustrated with Gaff and Sheed as a lot of people are, if we roll into the season with Tim Kelly with half an Elliot Yeo and 4 rookies, it’s going to get very ugly, very quickly. While we transition over to Hewitt/Ginbey/Reid/Chesser the older guys will play AFL footy - we just need to to find their touch again and work out the best position to get the most out of them. Not willing to put a line through Sheed just yet - he’s had no luck with his body in the last 2 seasons.
Up forward….if Ryan can stay on the park and find his spark alongside Brockman…and Darling can bounce back…it’s a decent line up. Cripps has continued to produce - also needs to stay fit but will be a good mentor for Hewett and Reid across HF. Oscar will continue to grow - god knows we need him to be an AA quality forward as soon as possible. Bailey Williams could be the wildcard up forward - no idea how successful he will be but more than likely he will push up onto a wing so hopefully he can clunk a few decent marks. Will be interesting to see how many of Williams, Darling, Maric, Waterman and J.Williams can play in the same side (with Flynn in the ruck). I’d say it’s 2 of them at most.
Here’s Round 1:
B: Liam Duggan, Tom Barrass, Tom Cole
HB: Jayden Hunt, Jeremy McGovern, Elliot Yeo
C: Brady Hough, Reuben Ginbey, Andrew Gaff
HF: Elijah Hewett, Jack Darling, Jamie Cripps
F: Liam Ryan, Oscar Allen, Noah Long
Foll: Matt Flynn, Tom Kelly, Dom Sheed
I/C: Bailey Williams, Tyler Brockman, Alex Witherden, Harley Reid
Sub: Jack Petrucelle
Next cabs off the rank - Jamaine Jones, Jake Waterman, Campbell Chesser
There will be injuries obviously - the back 6 + Witherden is pretty solid, a lot depends of how much footy Gov and Yeo miss. Hough and Ginbey will also spend time back, potentially Jones too.
The midfield is a balance I think - Kelly is easily our best mid now but it’s not really clear who our next best is - probably Yeo if he plays midfield.
As frustrated with Gaff and Sheed as a lot of people are, if we roll into the season with Tim Kelly with half an Elliot Yeo and 4 rookies, it’s going to get very ugly, very quickly. While we transition over to Hewitt/Ginbey/Reid/Chesser the older guys will play AFL footy - we just need to to find their touch again and work out the best position to get the most out of them. Not willing to put a line through Sheed just yet - he’s had no luck with his body in the last 2 seasons.
Up forward….if Ryan can stay on the park and find his spark alongside Brockman…and Darling can bounce back…it’s a decent line up. Cripps has continued to produce - also needs to stay fit but will be a good mentor for Hewett and Reid across HF. Oscar will continue to grow - god knows we need him to be an AA quality forward as soon as possible. Bailey Williams could be the wildcard up forward - no idea how successful he will be but more than likely he will push up onto a wing so hopefully he can clunk a few decent marks. Will be interesting to see how many of Williams, Darling, Maric, Waterman and J.Williams can play in the same side (with Flynn in the ruck). I’d say it’s 2 of them at most.
- Oct 9, 2009
- 11,951
- 13,066
- AFL Club
- West Coast
What I'd like to see for the majority of the year...
AFL
B: Jones Barrass Cole
HB: Duggan McGovern Hough
C: Hunt Kelly Burgiel
HF: Long Allen Cripps
F: Ryan Darling H Reid
R: Flynn Ginbey Hewett
I: B Williams Yeo Maric Petruccelle
S: Brockman
E: Hall Culley Witherden
WAFL
B: Witherden H Edwards Bazzo
HB: Rotham Jamieson Baker
C: Chesser Hall Gaff
HF: Culley A Reid Johnstone
F: Dewar J Williams Waterman
R: Livingstone L Edwards Sheed
I: Barnett Trew Rawlinson
After years of drafting too many defenders, we seem to be short of them next season lol.
AFL
B: Jones Barrass Cole
HB: Duggan McGovern Hough
C: Hunt Kelly Burgiel
HF: Long Allen Cripps
F: Ryan Darling H Reid
R: Flynn Ginbey Hewett
I: B Williams Yeo Maric Petruccelle
S: Brockman
E: Hall Culley Witherden
WAFL
B: Witherden H Edwards Bazzo
HB: Rotham Jamieson Baker
C: Chesser Hall Gaff
HF: Culley A Reid Johnstone
F: Dewar J Williams Waterman
R: Livingstone L Edwards Sheed
I: Barnett Trew Rawlinson
After years of drafting too many defenders, we seem to be short of them next season lol.
- Mar 19, 2020
- 15,231
- 44,195
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Thread starter
- #59
Plus Zane Sumich as one of our better players in the Bs too. I think Livingstone wont be in the best 22 but obviously is in frst cab off the rank otherwise.
- Mar 11, 2015
- 1,801
- 3,809
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Hewett is an impact clearance midfielder, not an endurance wingman, you’ve got that wrong.
- Mar 19, 2020
- 15,231
- 44,195
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Thread starter
- #61
I think people are wayyyyy too generous for Livingstone. Barnett well ahead and I also dont think Livingstone is in that best 22. For the WAFL some players who will definetly play are Nelson, Gilbee, Ruscoe and Sumich. Players like Livingstone/Dewar will be on the outer somewhat. My WAFL team would be
B: Witherden H Edwards Bazzo
HB: Rotham Jamieson Nelson
C: Chesser Hall Petch
HF: Culley A Reid, Ruscoe
F: Petch, Maric, Waterman
R: Barnett Edwards Trew
I: Johnston, Sumich, Baker, Gilbee
EMG : Dewar, Rawlinson, Livingstone
Something like that. Waterman to backup ruck as a difference
- Oct 9, 2009
- 11,951
- 13,066
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Clearly I'm only including the AFL-listed players lol.
Injuries will happen so not all of them will be in the WAFL side each week.
Don't worry there will be plenty of room for the non-AFL listed players.
Last edited:
- Sep 21, 2004
- 39,178
- 29,068
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Norwood & Liverpool.
Best balance of development and existing best 22 round 1
B Hunt Barrass Burgiel
HB Duggan♡ McGovern Yeo
C Chesser♡ Kelly# Hough
HF Cripps Allen Ryan
F Long# Darling☆ H Ried*
Foll: Flynn☆, Ginbey♡, Hewett*
Bench: B Williams☆, Sheed, Brockman, Waterman.
Emerg: Maric, Petrucelle, Jones, Cole, Gaff
People wont like Waterman in for Maric but one is a kid in his 2nd season and Waterman from reports has come back fit and is busting a gut (pun intended). Sounds like he realises its now or never. Losing some weight may be a blessing as I thought he looked a little heavy around his hips.
The emergency list looks decent when we are fully fit.
Some real pace in those back pockets and wings.
Wouldnt be surprised if Petro gets a start ahead of Brockman either. Both forward mids but Petro showed a bit late last year playing inside mid, if he could get his possesions up to 20-25 and stick 3 -4 tackles a game he's then best 22.
The H Ried Hewett rotation combo will become one of our main weapons going forward. And Tim Kelly will love the attention shifting elsewhere.
B Hunt Barrass Burgiel
HB Duggan♡ McGovern Yeo
C Chesser♡ Kelly# Hough
HF Cripps Allen Ryan
F Long# Darling☆ H Ried*
Foll: Flynn☆, Ginbey♡, Hewett*
Bench: B Williams☆, Sheed, Brockman, Waterman.
Emerg: Maric, Petrucelle, Jones, Cole, Gaff
People wont like Waterman in for Maric but one is a kid in his 2nd season and Waterman from reports has come back fit and is busting a gut (pun intended). Sounds like he realises its now or never. Losing some weight may be a blessing as I thought he looked a little heavy around his hips.
The emergency list looks decent when we are fully fit.
Some real pace in those back pockets and wings.
Wouldnt be surprised if Petro gets a start ahead of Brockman either. Both forward mids but Petro showed a bit late last year playing inside mid, if he could get his possesions up to 20-25 and stick 3 -4 tackles a game he's then best 22.
The H Ried Hewett rotation combo will become one of our main weapons going forward. And Tim Kelly will love the attention shifting elsewhere.
Last edited:
WCEConnor23
Senior List
- Nov 9, 2022
- 218
- 677
- AFL Club
- West Coast
I prefer Jones as a half forward also running through the midfield a bit. He's played some good games in that role, notably 2 seasons ago our season opener vs gold coast and last year vs North in round 1. I think he can be a 15+ possession 1/2 goal a game half forward with elite defensive pressure.I’m not the biggest fan of Jones feel he butchers the ball too much. That role that he’s played off half back, you need élite decision making and foot skills and I personally think Jones is average at both.
Happy if others disagree I know some really like him.
Think Burgiel if he can continue to develop and stay on the park could fill that role.
Keys
Looking for a cloud to yell at
- Moderator
- #68
Permanent Backs:
McGovern, Barrass, Cole, Jones, Witherden or Bazzo
HEdwards, Rotham, Burgiel
Rotating Back/Mid:
Yeo, Ginbey, Duggan, Hough, Hunt
Permanent Mids:
Kelly, Gaff or Sheed
Chesser, LEdwards, Trew, Hall
Rotating Forward/Mid:
Cripps, Hewett, Reid, Long
Petruccelle, Culley
Permanent Forwards:
Allen, Darling, Ryan, Brockman, Waterman or Maric
JWilliams
Rucks:
Flynn, Williams
Jamieson
Players in italics should be putting pressure on those in front of them for a spot and/or be ready to step up as injury cover
WAFL/Developing:
A Reid, Johnston, Barnett, Rawlinson, Baker, Livingstone, Dewar
This group should concentrate on developing their skills in the WAFL as they’re probably short of being ready for seniors. Obviously if they perform above expectations then give them a game if there’s a spot but reality is they only play if we get struck down with injury again
McGovern, Barrass, Cole, Jones, Witherden or Bazzo
HEdwards, Rotham, Burgiel
Rotating Back/Mid:
Yeo, Ginbey, Duggan, Hough, Hunt
Permanent Mids:
Kelly, Gaff or Sheed
Chesser, LEdwards, Trew, Hall
Rotating Forward/Mid:
Cripps, Hewett, Reid, Long
Petruccelle, Culley
Permanent Forwards:
Allen, Darling, Ryan, Brockman, Waterman or Maric
JWilliams
Rucks:
Flynn, Williams
Jamieson
Players in italics should be putting pressure on those in front of them for a spot and/or be ready to step up as injury cover
WAFL/Developing:
A Reid, Johnston, Barnett, Rawlinson, Baker, Livingstone, Dewar
This group should concentrate on developing their skills in the WAFL as they’re probably short of being ready for seniors. Obviously if they perform above expectations then give them a game if there’s a spot but reality is they only play if we get struck down with injury again
Carbine Chaos
See My Chess
- Apr 1, 2009
- 65,060
- 98,364
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth FC, Everton, Delhi
People talking about Waterman over Maric.
Why not Waterman over Darling?
Jack's fitness and form in 2023 doesn't warrant automatic selection.
Why not Waterman over Darling?
Jack's fitness and form in 2023 doesn't warrant automatic selection.
Credits
PepperTom32
Debutant
- Mar 2, 2021
- 122
- 321
- AFL Club
- West Coast
The Deagles?
- Jan 13, 2013
- 23,757
- 47,712
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Don't forget Gov was a forward who got sent away for being too fat before a couple of pre-season knee injuries forced us to play him as a key back
Similar threads
