-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2024 Draft Thread
- Thread starter goodcop badcop
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Bonti 5416
Debutant
- Nov 9, 2022
- 123
- 252
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
My ideal at the moment:
17 (20/21 on the night)
Hannaford/Hotton/Lindsay/Reid (pretty unlikely those last two) Berry my ultimate but he is not getting to our pick.
25 (29)
Harry Oliver - dont want us to take a speculative player hoping hes a star. Just take a high quality role player who is a list need. Oliver fits the bill as a Duryea replacement and even upgrade. Anyone know hes combine results? Can seem to find them.
Hamish Davis - huge enginge and or pacy mid/small connecting forwards
Is a huge need. Davis has the engine and looks a proper footballer with genuine craft.
Angus Clarke - would love to know his combine testing also. Seems good as a Bailey Dale understudy.
35 - (prob comes in a to 34/33)
Dattoli - yeah he might not have pace but you know he’ll be in the thick of it. Plus we can afford to have one forward without pace just crumbing the front of packs and pressuring opposition. Got some tricks when he gets the footy.
Mraz - Still need a gorilla full back as a jones replacement. Seems to me that Croft if he becomes a backman would more likely be a Lobb replacement.
Busslinger more of a Jake Lever.
Like his competitiveness and tested great for his position. Agility in particular.
Who are others hoping for at each pick at this stage?
17 (20/21 on the night)
Hannaford/Hotton/Lindsay/Reid (pretty unlikely those last two) Berry my ultimate but he is not getting to our pick.
25 (29)
Harry Oliver - dont want us to take a speculative player hoping hes a star. Just take a high quality role player who is a list need. Oliver fits the bill as a Duryea replacement and even upgrade. Anyone know hes combine results? Can seem to find them.
Hamish Davis - huge enginge and or pacy mid/small connecting forwards
Is a huge need. Davis has the engine and looks a proper footballer with genuine craft.
Angus Clarke - would love to know his combine testing also. Seems good as a Bailey Dale understudy.
35 - (prob comes in a to 34/33)
Dattoli - yeah he might not have pace but you know he’ll be in the thick of it. Plus we can afford to have one forward without pace just crumbing the front of packs and pressuring opposition. Got some tricks when he gets the footy.
Mraz - Still need a gorilla full back as a jones replacement. Seems to me that Croft if he becomes a backman would more likely be a Lobb replacement.
Busslinger more of a Jake Lever.
Like his competitiveness and tested great for his position. Agility in particular.
Who are others hoping for at each pick at this stage?
CaptainMurphy
Norm Smith Medallist
Veteran
Western Bulldogs - Ed Richards Player Sponsor 2018
Western Bulldogs - Bailey Dale Player Sponsor 2018
Western Bulldogs - Mitch Honeychurch Player Sponsor 2018
Western Bulldogs - Nathan Mullenger-McHugh Player Sponsor 2018
Western Bulldogs - Nathan Mullenger-McHugh Player Sponsor 2017
Western Bulldogs - Bailey Dale Player Sponsor 2017
Western Bulldogs - Mitch Honeychurch Player Sponsor 2017
- Jun 4, 2015
- 5,668
- 7,602
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Good list, but Dattoli won't be there at 35. I reckon you could swap him and Clarke.
Just been trying to get my head around what players could be available at our picks and figured I’d make a post to see if our more informed draft watchers think it’s on the money and perhaps help out others get an idea of what the draft might look like.
I’ve taken the profiles from the Fox rankings and split them into groups based on who might be around at each pick. I just used the fox ones because they were the easiest to use, not because I think they are particularly good. I’ve left the Fox ranking numbers next to each prospect but then shuffled them around a bit to reflect what seems to be the consensus on where players fit.
The first 12 players in the Fox rankings will be gone by our pick so I think Travaglia is the first, albeit highly unlikely, player that could be on the board. Also, while Allen and Travaglia are almost certainly gone before our pick, it feel like they are a tier below the top prospects. below the top prospects. below the top prospects.
Fox did a top 50 so there will be players in the frame at 35 and possibly even 25 who aren’t in this list and really trying to get an idea of where players go beyond the first round is probably pretty futile.
Pick 17 will end up 20 or 21 so there would need a few surprise bolters for any of the first group to be available but it’s not impossible.
Unlikely at 17
13. TOBIE TRAVAGLIA
Position: Medium defender
Size: 187cm
Clubs: Bendigo Pioneers/Sandhurst
AFL player comparison: Will Day
Clubs knew he was gun prospect pre-champs, Travaglia shot up draft boards after an awesome carnival campaign for Vic Country. Travaglia was named in the Under 18 All-Australian side after averaging 21.8 disposals and 6.2 marks — of which 3.5 were intercept marks – while going at an impressive 82.5 per cent efficiency by foot. Travaglia then finished off his 2024 campaign with a flurry of eye-catching displays at Coates Talent League level, kicking 8.2 and averaging 21.8 disposals and 4.4 inside 50s from his final five matches playing primarily as a midfielder with spurts in the forward arc. Travaglia got a small taste of what professional footballer life could look like earlier this year when he played two games for Carlton’s VFL side. His second match against Richmond was particularly eye-catching, finishing with 22 disposals, nine intercepts, seven score involvements and four marks. To cap it off, he finished second in the 2km time trial at the national draft combine with a time of 6:13. Travaglia is everything you need in a mid-sized intercept defender: Athletic and competitive in the air, pinpoint with his disposal from defence and smart with his offensive-defensive balance. But Travaglia – and AFL club recruiters – can see him following a similar trajectory to Hawthorn star Will Day, who was drafted as a defender before turning into a gun midfielder at the top level. He’s now a top 10 to 15 prospect, with Richmond (Picks 10 and 11) recently linked to the Pioneer.
14. JOE BERRY
Position: Medium forward
Size: 181cm
Clubs: Murray Bushrangers/Wangaratta
AFL player comparison: Dylan Moore
A crafty and hard-working half-forward that should thrive in the modern AFL era. Berry produced a brilliant, eye-catching carnival for Vic Country where he was a threat across all four games, finishing with nine goals and averaging 13.2 disposals and 5.5 score involvements. With sharp top-end speed that allows him to get up the ground, as well as excellent creativity close to goal, Berry is your typical high forward. He’s a natural crumber, getting to the right spots where he can show off his cleanliness at ground level and innate goal sense. He kicked 27 goals for the Bushrangers this season — the most of any active Coates Talent League player — while also averaging 14.4 disposals and 3.9 inside 50s to be a joint winner of the club’s best and fairest award and earn selection in the competition’s team of the year. Berry looms as a mid first-round pick, with Richmond, Fremantle, Port Adelaide and the Giants in the mix.
15. XAVIER LINDSAY
Position: Midfielder/medium defender
Size: 183cm
Clubs: Gippsland Power/Leongatha
AFL player comparison: Scott Pendlebury
Perhaps the classiest of the class. Recruiters coming into the year liked Lindsay as a half-back, but he showed throughout the year he has an improved inside game and is reliable across any third of the ground. But it’s decision-making, pinpoint ball use, agility and speed that really catch the eye. Lindsay’s ‘Pick Me’ game for Vic Country against Vic Metro, finishing with 30 disposals, 11 marks, 10 contested possessions, eight score involvements, eight tackles, six inside 50s, six intercepts, four clearances and 585m gained. Overall, he averaged 22.7 disposals, 4.3 clearances and 5.0 tackles in three matches for Country, having missed the Allies match due to injury. Lindsay then became the first Gippsland Power player in a decade to claim the Morrish Medal as the best and fairest player in the Coates Talent League, averaging 23.4 disposals, 5.4 clearances and 5.2 inside 50s across his 12 appearances this season. Lindsay is in the top-10 mix, with Melbourne (Pick 5) perhaps the club with the earliest pick that could take him. Yet there’s a world in which Lindsay slips to teams like the Dockers and Power in the teens, such is the nature of this year’s even draft class.
16. LUKE TRAINOR
Position: Tall defender
Size: 194cm
Clubs: Sandringham Dragons/Old Brighton Grammarians
AFL player comparison: Jordan Ridley
Slid a bit in the back-half of the year, but Trainor remains one of the best key-position prospects in the draft class. From his four games for Metro, Trainor averaged 19.8 disposals (76% kicking efficiency), 5.8 marks (1.8 intercept) and 4.8 rebound 50s as he showed off his strong offensive traits, including strong overhead marking and a penetrating right-foot kick. But what AFL clubs were more impressed by was competitiveness in the air and willingness to defend. This was particularly evident against South Australia, with Trainor taking the points against Tyler Welsh in an intriguing battle, while he also had big moments against Jonty Faull and Jack Whitlock in the Metro-Country game. His performances for the AFL Academy against VFL opposition were also impressive, named best on ground against Coburg (20 disposals, 4 marks) before another strong outing against Footscray (21 disposals, 1 goal). Trainor is the grandson of 1000-goalkicker Doug Wade and nephew of AFL Commissioner Gabrielle Trainor. The earliest he might be taken, at this stage, is Pick 7 (St Kilda), but clubs wouldn’t be surprised if he slipped towards the 20s. His landing spot could be determined by how early other key-position prospects go on the night.
18. BO ALLAN
Position: Medium defender/midfielder
Size: 191cm
Clubs: Peel Thunder/Halls Head
AFL player comparison: Elliot Yeo
Allan would be higher on others’ draft boards following a strong back-end to the season. After earning All-Australian honours — he averaged 20.0 disposals, 7.3 contested possessions, 6.3 score involvements, 6.0 tackles and 3.7 clearances for WA — Allan added another nine WAFL league games to take his season tally to 11 for Peel Thunder, averaging 11.5 disposals and 3.3 tackles on his way to becoming a premiership player. Allan is a great athlete — he recorded three top-four finishes at the national draft combine, in both vertical jumps and the agility test — and has strong footy nous. He has the range that allows him to play midfield minutes and win the ball around stoppages, yet is just as comfortable playing as a rebounding defender. Some clubs believe he can be a midfielder at AFL level due to his competitiveness, while others reckon he’d be more suited to a backline role. Either way, he looms as hot property on draft night. Both West Coast (Pick 12) and Fremantle (Pick 14) have been heavily linked to Allan, but he also has interest from Richmond with its mid-first round picks (Picks 10 and 11). Considering that Richmond interest and the fact the Dockers are now behind the Eagles in the draft order, scouts would be surprised if Allan was still on the board after West Coast’s pick.
Possibly available at 17
17. TAJ HOTTON
Position: Midfielder/medium forward
Size: 180cm
Clubs: Sandringham Dragons/Hampton Rovers
AFL player comparison: Shai Bolton
Clubs haven’t forgotten about the dangerous and creative Hotton, who was arguably the hottest player of the draft pool at the start of the season before rupturing his ACL at training in May. He had some monster Talent League games for the Dragons, most notably against the Chargers where he kicked 4.1 from 32 disposals, 10 marks, five inside 50s and five tackles. He also played a game for the AFL academy, booting two goals from 18 disposals against Coburg. Hotton had significantly improved his endurance, allowing him to spend more time on the ball. Hotton, the son of ex-Collingwood and Carlton player Trent Hotton and brother of 2022 Saints draftee Olli Hotton, is still expected to be a mid first-round pick with Richmond, in particular, said to have put some work into him. The fact so many clubs have multiple early picks this year — the Tigers, Giants, Swans and Bulldogs — probably plays into Hotton’s favour.
30. OLLIE HANNAFORD
Position: Utility
Size: 180cm
Clubs: GWV Rebels/Sandhurst
AFL player comparison: Tom Atkins
A late bolter who could go much earlier than this spot come draft night. Hannaford is a tough, speedy, exciting, versatile and well-rounded prospect who’s impressed across every line at different stages this year. He started the year in defence for the Rebels and impressed with his rebounding. As a forward, he kicked five goals against the Oakleigh Chargers in Round 18 then a bag of six in the qualifying final against the Geelong Falcons on his way to 21.8 for the season and selection in the Coates Talent League Team of the Year. He then finished as the Rebels’ best player in their grand final loss to the Dragons, picking up 24 disposals, nine tackles, seven inside 50s and a goal in a prominent performance. Could sneak into the teens in the first round.
24. JESSE DATTOLI
Position: Medium forward/wing
Size: 178cm
Clubs: Northern Knights/Heidelberg
AFL player comparison: Josh Rachele
There’s been ample intrigue around this Northern Knights product all year, for he’s uber-talented and has match-winner traits written all over him. After an injury-interrupted 2023 campaign, Dattoli impressed both at Coates Talent League level and against the best in the national carnival. He kicked 12 goals and averaged 23.1 disposals, 6.1 score involvements and 3.9 clearances for the Knights, while he also had a promising carnival campaign for Vic Metro, booting three goals and averaging 15.2 disposals, 7.2 marks and 6.0 score involvements. Dattoli works hard between the arcs and is creative with his ball use. He’s the kind of midfielder-forward with AFL traits that could easily sneak into the teens on draft night.
19. JOBE SHANAHAN
Position: Tall forward
Size: 194cm
Clubs: Bendigo Pioneers/Moama
AFL player comparison: Nick Riewoldt
A riser across the back-half of the season after starring on the national Under 18 stage then thriving against state league opposition. Shanahan was named at centre half-forward in the All-Australian team after an excellent carnival for the Allies, which saw him take a comp-high eight contested marks. His standout game came against Vic Country, booting three goals from with 16 disposals and nine marks (four contested) and three goals. But it was his three-game stint for Essendon’s VFL side that boosted the external attention on him, kicking 4.0 against the Northern Bullants, 2.3 against Gold Coast then 5.0 against Coburg. Shanahan finished the season with a six-goal, 17-disposal display for the Pioneers before being named in the Coates Talent League Team of the Year. Shanahan plays with grand presence in the air and has a superb pair of hands, but his mobility and ability to constantly present make him a threat around the ground as well. There’s a slight chance he sneaks in to the top 10 — should one of the Saints, Demons or Tigers want a key forward at that stage of the draft — otherwise he should be in that mid first-round mix featuring the Power, Dockers and Giants.
20. JACK WHITLOCK
Position: Tall forward/ruck
Size: 200cm
Clubs: Murray Bushrangers/Shepparton
AFL player comparison: Ben King
After a rollercoaster start to his 2024 season, Whitlock finished strong. He had a massive second half for Vic Country against Vic Metro in the final champs game to finish with 2.1 from 13 disposals and seven marks (three contested). Whitlock also thrived with more ruck time against Western Australia during the champs, finishing with 18 disposals, 11 contested possessions, eight score involvements, seven hit-outs and five clearances. That set him up for an imposing final six-game stretch with the Bushrangers at Coates League level, which saw him 15.11 and average 18.9 disposals and 5.0 marks. At 200cm and with great athleticism, Whitlock has all the traits to be an exciting key-position player at AFL level. His early draft prospects were enhanced by an increase in size and strength, which has helped him become a more ominous presence close to goal. Could be an outside chance to be taken by one of the Saints, Demons or Tigers in the top 10, but looms more likely as a later selection on night one. Could Sydney pounce?
Likely Available at 17 Possible at 25
25. COOPER HYNES
Position: Medium forward/midfielder
Size: 190cm
Clubs: Dandenong Stingrays/Bonbeach
AFL player comparison: Jack Ziebell
Power, power, power. Hynes, the son of John Hynes who played four games for Carlton in the late ‘90s, was a standout for the Dandenong Stingrays this season, kicking 23.12 and averaging 23.7 disposals, 7.4 score involvements and 4.7 clearances to finish runner-up in the Morrish Medal count. Hynes has brilliant inside ball-winning ability, but has kicked big bags of goals this year — including five against Gold Coast academy — while showing off his strong hands close to goal. Hynes boosted his first-round chances during the carnival, booting four goals and averaging 16.8 disposals and 5.2 score involvements playing mainly across half-forward for Vic Country. While there’s improvement left, Hynes has worked hard on his conditioning across the past 12 months to compliment his brilliant natural football ability. He has a wide draft range, with some suggesting he could taken with a late-teens pick or midway through the second round.
36. HAMISH DAVIS
Position: Medium forward
Size: 190cm
Clubs: Claremont/Subiaco
AFL player comparison: Will Hayward
Arguably WA’s second-best prospect after Bo Allan, Davis has many tricks he can bring to an AFL club. He’s athletic and powerful in the air, but his strong aerobic capacity — highlighted by the fact he ran the 2km time trial at the national combine in 6:18 (ranked fifth) — makes him a threat around the ground. Davis starred at every level he played at this year. After dominating for Claremont at Colts level — he kicked 14 goals and average 23 disposals from nine games — Davis thrived at the national carnival, kicking 7.7 and averaging 14.5 disposals and 6.0 score involvements across four matches. He then finished the year in Claremont’s WAFL league team, with standout performances against Subiaco (3.1 from 16 disposals) and East Fremantle (4.0 from 21 disposals) before producing a 30-disposal display in the colts grand final to win the Mel Whinnen medal as the best player on the ground. More likely to be a second-round selection at this stage.
22. JONTY FAULL
Position: Tall forward
Size: 195cm
Clubs: GWV Rebels/Redan
AFL player comparison: Charlie Curnow
There’s something special about this tall Rebel, who bounced back after a long lay-off to start the season with a back injury. Faull, who’s both strong overhead yet agile and clean below his knees for a player of his size, kicked five goals from three games for Vic Country at national champs level. He was then a dominant force at Coates Talent League level, finishing the season with an impressive 27.16 — including nine goals across two finals for the Rebels — while averaging 13.0 disposals, 4.5 marks and 102 ranking points from 11 matches. Like Jack Whitlock, Faull looms as a mid to first-round prospect.
23. ALEX DODSON
Position: Ruck
Size: 203cm
Clubs: Sturt/Payneham
AFL player comparison: Luke Jackson
The best ruck in this year’s draft class is a freak 203cm prospect who, up until a few months ago, wasn’t sure if he wanted to fully pursue an AFL or basketball career. He didn’t play footy at all in 2023, leading to him representing Australia in basketball at both Under 17 and Under 18 level. He was also a train-on player with the Adelaide 36ers – the NBL club he’s supported his whole life – as part of their development roster. But now that he’s all-in on footy, Dodson looms as a first-round prospect. After missing SA’s first champs this year game due to basketball commitments, Dodson averaged 17.3 disposals, 9.7 contested possessions, 3.7 clearances, 19.7 hit-outs and 114.1 ranking points in his three outings to earn All-Australian honours. Against Vic Metro, he snuck forward to take a strong contested mark and kick a goal in an encouraging sign. Dodson is everything you want in a modern-day athletic ruck. He’s competitive at ruck contests then follows up at ground level to help win clearances. He then works hard around the field to get to as many contests as possible and find the footy, both in the air and at ground level. Dodson is a good chance to be taken on the first round of the draft.
26. MATT WHITLOCK
Position: Tall utility
Size: 198cm
Clubs: Murray Bushrangers/Shepparton
AFL player comparison: Sam Taylor
While twin brother Jack is slightly taller and slightly higher rated overall, don’t sleep on the younger — and versatile — Whitlock. When Jack was sidelined earlier in the year due to a finger injury, Whitlock was swung from defence into the forward line – and had a day out against the Giants Academy team, booting 5.3 from 14 disposals and seven marks. He ended up kicking 27.20 for the year playing mainly as a forward, but was named at full-back in the Coates Talent League team of the year. Recruiters were pleased he had the opportunity to show his wares at the other end of the field – and just as stoked he was able to deliver, consistently presenting up at the ball all game and competing well in the air. But he was just as impressive in defence for Vic Country. While Whitlock is still lightly built and developing his frame, he’s very athletic — his running vertical jump of 90cm at the draft combine ranked sixth overall — and has shown greater ball-winning ability this year. A chance to be taken in the first round, considering the array of bids that’ll take place.
27. TOM GROSS
Position: Midfielder/medium forward
Size: 182cm
Clubs: Oakleigh Chargers/Old Trinity Grammarians
AFL player comparison: Rory Sloane
A slider, but Gross still has fans. The Chargers product made the All-Australian team, booting two goals and averaging 20.0 disposals, 7.0 score involvements, 5.2 marks, 3.5 tackles and 3.0 clearances for Vic Metro. Gross was especially impressive against South Australia, picking up 27 disposals – 11 during a defining third quarter – nine score involvements and nine marks — as he showed off his powerful aerobic capacity. His power, ferocity at the footy and strong overhead marking ability means he can impact games both close to goal and at stoppages. An outside chance to be taken in the first round — could the Giants pounce with their third first-round pick?
28. HARRISON OLIVER
Position: Medium defender
Size: 181cm
Clubs: Sandringham Dragons/St Bedes-Mentone
AFL player comparison: Luke Hodge
There’s a lot to like about this composed defender, who could be in the first-round mix due to competitiveness, decision-making and pinpoint distribution by foot. Oliver made the All-Australian team after averaging 16.2 disposals and going at 82 per cent efficiency by foot for Vic Metro. He can break the lines with his run, carry and kicking, while he also goes hard at the ball. Probably slid a touch during the back-half of the year, so is more likely a night two chance at the draft.
29. CHRISTIAN MORAES
Position: Utility
Size: 182cm
Clubs: Eastern Ranges/Knox
AFL player comparison: Luke Parker
Some clubs might have him higher on their boards, due to his elite workrate and running power. Moraes emerged as a top prospect for the 2024 draft last year, starring for the Eastern Ranges as a bottom-ager to average 26 disposals from 16 games — including one goal from 24 touches in the grand final. Due to Vic Metro’s strong on-ball brigade, Moraes didn’t get a lot of centre square time during the national carnival, starting as a half-back before playing more forward of centre. He still averaged impressive numbers — three goals and an equal carnival-high 8.0 score involvements to go with 20.8 disposals, 5.8 marks and 4.5 inside 50s — but missed out on All-Australian selection. Recruiters know how dynamic he can be though, personified by his first three games of the 2024 Coates Talent League season where he booted 9.3 and averaged 23.7 disposals, 6.7 marks and 4.0 tackles, before a five-goal, 27-disposal display against the Western Jets in Round 17. Could be a player that slips to the second round yet ultimately turns into a bargain selection. Hawthorn (Pick 33) got a glimpse of Moraes via the Box Hill program late in the season
Likely available at 25, possible at 35
32. NOAH MRAZ
Position: Tall defender
Size: 198cm
Clubs: Dandenong Stingrays/Noble Park
AFL player comparison: Darcy Moore
Probably would’ve been much higher on this board — and been taken earlier in the draft — if it wasn’t for navicular foot issue this season. Mraz managed two Talent League games for the Stingrays and played in both AFL Academy hit-outs against VFL opposition before his diagnosis. But the 198cm Stingray is still considered one of the best key defenders in the draft pool. He’s strong both in the air and at ground level for a player of his size, while his defensive positioning and closing speed are also standout traits. Scouts, too, love his competitive mindset and workrate. Looms as a second-round pick.
33. CHARLIE NICHOLLS
Position: Tall utility
Size: 197cm
Clubs: Central District/Min-Man
AFL player comparison: Harry Petty
This South Australian with vice-like hands has fans at AFL club level, mainly around his incredible pack marking ability, as well as his size and athleticism. Nicholls burst onto the scene at the start of the season, booting 13 goals from his first six SANFL Under 18s games. He then put on a breathtaking marking display against Vic Country, but was inaccurate in front of goal, finishing with 1.3 from 11 disposals and nine marks (four contested). But one of the best things for Nicholls was SA’s decision to play him behind the ball — a role he quickly adapted to, finishing with 10 disposals and six marks (four intercept) against Vic Metro. Post-champs, Nicholls had exposure at SANFL reserves level then had a strong Under 18s finals campaign with Central District. More likely to be taken on night two of the draft, possibly lower than this position.
34. JASPER ALGER
Position: Medium forward
Size: 182cm
Clubs: Oakleigh Chargers/Warragul
AFL player comparison: Toby Greene
A goalkicker with a lot of AFL traits. Alger is a strong overhead mark for a player of his size, while he’s also quick on the burst — personified by him ranking fourth in the 20m sprint (2.95 seconds) and 10th in the agility test (8.14 seconds) at the national draft combine. But Alger is crafty forward who knows where the goals are. He kicked five goals from four games for Vic Country — including three against South Australia — while his four-goal effort against the Calder Cannons in the Wildcard Round final was eye-catching. No. 34 might be a bit high for some clubs, but Alger has big upside.
35. TOM SIMS
Position: Tall forward
Size: 199cm
Clubs: Northern Knights/Montmorency
AFL player comparison: Charlie Dixon
The powerful and versatile Sims, who’s also a strong ruck option, plays with great presence on the field, marks the ball well and covers the ground well for a player of his size. He had a big start to the year with 15 goals from his five Talent League games for the Knights — including 7.4 from 15 disposals and 10 marks against the Oakleigh Chargers — before hitting a lean patch in the middle of the year. Sims kicked 4.5 from four champs games for Vic Metro, but it could’ve been a more fruitful haul if more opportunities were taken. Still, his ability in the ruck late in the Coates season was pivotal for the Knights and added another string to his bow. Considering the array of top-end key forwards in this year’s crop, Sims will likely have to wait until night two to get picked up at the draft.
37. JAMES BARRAT
Position: Tall utility
Size: 194cm
Clubs: Bendigo Pioneers/Leitchville Gunbower
AFL player comparison: Tom Barrass
A popular member of the Vic Country set-up, Barrat showed impressive versatility this year. He booted 16.18 from his first six Coates Talent League games then kicked two goals against South Australia in Vic Country’s opening championships clash. But an AFL club-led push saw Barrat swung into defence for the final two games of Country’s carnival — and he thrived on the big stage by averaging 11 touches and six intercepts. He then carried that form as a defender back to the Pioneers, averaging 18.8 disposals, 9.2 marks and 8.0 rebound 50s from his final six home and away games, before producing a two-goal, 25-disposal display in Bendigo’s wildcard clash against the Stingrays. Barrat won the Neville Strauch best and fairest award for the Pioneers’ boys team for season 2024. An aggressive and competitive player with a strong pair of hands, Barrat looms as a second-round draft pick.
38. ANGUS CLARKE
Position: Medium defender
Size: 189cm
Clubs: Glenelg/East Gambier
AFL player comparison: Mason Redman
A tall intercept defender with a high footy IQ and elite skills, Clarke has caught the eye of many clubs this year. He played a starring role for South Australia at the national carnival, averaging 17 disposals and two intercept marks per match. Clarke also played 10 games at Under 18 level for Glenelg where he averaged 16.7 disposals and ran his 2km time trial at the national draft combine in 6:16 — ranked third overall.
39. JACK OUGH
Position: Wing/midfielder
Size: 194cm
Clubs: GWV Rebels/Wentworth
AFL player comparison: Joel Freijah
Put himself on the radar with a strong finish to his 2024 campaign. After averaging 13.5 touches from four matches for Vic Country in the carnival where he impressed with his workrate, Ough starred across an eight-game stretch for the Rebels, averaging 25.1 disposals, 5.0 tackles and 4.3 marks where he spent more time on the ball. Against the Geelong Falcons, he amassed 33 disposals, 20 contested possessions and nine clearances as he showed off an improving inside game. Considering his height and versatility, clubs are optimistic he could be an inside midfielder at AFL level — to the point where some believe he’d be worth of being taken inside the top 30.
41. KAYLE GERREYN
Position: Tall forward/ruck
Size: 199cm
Clubs: West Perth/Joondalup Kinross
AFL player comparison: Rowan Marshall/Riley Thilthorpe
Another emerging bolter from WA, Gerreyn has got some real AFL attributes. He kicked five goals and averaged 6.5 score involvements from four games for WA at the carnival, before kicking 15.10 from his final eight games with West Perth across both colts and league. One aspect that was particularly noticeable during the champs was that he’s a beautiful, natural kick of the footy for a player of his size. Then at the same time, he’s not afraid to throw his weight around, both inside 50 and at stoppage. He’s a genuine forward-ruck that has clubs excited. Should be taken in the second round.
42. SAM DAVIDSON
Position: Medium forward
Size: 191cm
Clubs: Richmond (VFL)/St Kevin’s Old Boys
AFL player comparison: Ollie Dempsey
The best mature-age prospect in the class — and he could continue one of footy’s great recruiting streaks. Davidson this year was recognised for a breakout VFL season by claiming the Fothergill-Round-Mitchell Medal, which is awarded to the most promising player aged 24 or under. In a good omen for Davidson, the past 17 consecutive Fothergill-Round-Mitchell Medal winners — including Michael Barlow, Michael Hibberd, Kane Lambert, Nic Newman, Luke Ryan and Bayley Fritsch — have been drafted onto an AFL list. Davidson, 22, did most of his damage inside 50 for the Tigers’ VFL side this year, kicking 26.13 and averaging 14.4 disposals, but he also showed off his versatility by playing on the wing and, at times, in the ruck. He has terrific aerobic capacity — he ran his 2km time trial at the state draft combine in 6:12 — but is so competitive in the air too. Richmond has taken several players from its VFL list in recent years. Could Davidson be the next?
43. HARRY O’FARRELL
Position: Tall defender
Size: 197cm
Clubs: Calder Cannons/Maribyrnong Park
AFL player comparison: Harry Himmelberg
Had an injury-riddled draft year, but O’Farrell is a key defensive prospect expected to be on an AFL list next year. He played the first two Talent League games for the Cannons then impressed for the AFL Academy against Coburg with his strength, defensive nous and rebounding ability. O’Farrell then injured his ankle in his second champs game for Vic Metro, resulting in a two-month stint on the sidelines. When he returned for the Cannons, he was swung forward and kicked 2.4 from 10 touches before suffering a concussion in the next game. He has the mobility to play on either tall or small forwards due to his aerial presence and good judgement.
44. LACHIE JAQUES
Position: Medium defender
Size: 185cm
Clubs: Geelong Falcons/St Mary’s
AFL player comparison: Tom Stewart
The Falcons co-captain has come from the clouds this year. Jaques caught the attention of recruiters with a promising start to the season, averaging 26 disposals and 7.7 intercepts from his first three matches. He was then named at half-back in the All-Australian team from the national championships, averaging 16.2 disposals at 78.5 per cent efficiency for Vic Country. Jaques has a great ability to read the play and use the footy precisely coming out of half-back. Geelong always leans towards its local Geelong Falcons talent — and Jaques could be in their mix later in the draft.
46. ADRIAN COLE
Position: Tall defender
Size: 194cm
Clubs: Sandringham Dragons/St Bedes-Mentone
AFL player comparison: Dougal Howard
One for Saints fans to get excited about, as Cole is part of the club’s NGA. An athletic key-position backman who’s incredibly gifted one-on-one and has a great natural leap, Cole boosted his prospects playing for Vic Metro at the national carnival this year, locking down the opposition’s most dangerous tall forwards like Jonty Faull. He then rank the 2km time trial in 6:24 — ranked equal-seventh. The Saints will match a bid on Cole, but it could come a lot earlier than Pick 46.
47. JOSH DOLAN
Position: Small forward/midfielder
Size: 177cm
Clubs: Sandringham Dragons/Beaumaris
AFL player comparison: Dylan Moore
A high half-forward who could thrive in the modern AFL landscape. Dolan was a star for the Dragons this year, kicking 8.4 and averaging 19.8 disposals, 8.6 score involvements and 5.0 marks per game. He’s a strong runner and damaging by foot.
48. HUGH BOXSHALL
Position: Midfielder
Size: 187cm
Clubs: Claremont/Swanbourne
A ball magnet who was unlucky to not get an invite to the national combine, Boxshall now looms as a national draft selection. Boxshall, who averaged 25 disposals for Claremont’s colts side this season, always seems to have extra time in congestion and is clean via hand. He was also one of WA’s most prolific performers at the national carnival, averaging 18.7 disposals, 8.0 contested possessions and 5.0 marks.
49. XAVIER IVISIC
Position: Midfielder
Size: 180cm
Clubs: Geelong Falcons/Bell Park
Found the footy at will this year, primarily due to his excellent workrate contest to contest, but also for his footy IQ. Was overlooked for a national combine invite, despite averaging 22 disposals and six score involvements for Vic Country and 25 disposals and six clearances for the Falcons. Ivisic is lightly framed, but his strong running capacity and improving inside game has him on the radar.
50. OLLIE WARBURTON
Position: Medium defender/midfielder
Size: 185cm
Clubs: Murray Bushrangers/Shepparton Swans
A classy, versatile player who showed this season he can be deployed as either a defender or midfielder. Was excellent for Vic Country at the national champs, averaging 18.5 disposals and going at 77.1 per cent efficiency by foot. Warburton was also prolific for the Murray Bushrangers, averaging 25.9 disposals.
I’ve taken the profiles from the Fox rankings and split them into groups based on who might be around at each pick. I just used the fox ones because they were the easiest to use, not because I think they are particularly good. I’ve left the Fox ranking numbers next to each prospect but then shuffled them around a bit to reflect what seems to be the consensus on where players fit.
The first 12 players in the Fox rankings will be gone by our pick so I think Travaglia is the first, albeit highly unlikely, player that could be on the board. Also, while Allen and Travaglia are almost certainly gone before our pick, it feel like they are a tier below the top prospects. below the top prospects. below the top prospects.
Fox did a top 50 so there will be players in the frame at 35 and possibly even 25 who aren’t in this list and really trying to get an idea of where players go beyond the first round is probably pretty futile.
Pick 17 will end up 20 or 21 so there would need a few surprise bolters for any of the first group to be available but it’s not impossible.
Unlikely at 17
13. TOBIE TRAVAGLIA
Position: Medium defender
Size: 187cm
Clubs: Bendigo Pioneers/Sandhurst
AFL player comparison: Will Day
Clubs knew he was gun prospect pre-champs, Travaglia shot up draft boards after an awesome carnival campaign for Vic Country. Travaglia was named in the Under 18 All-Australian side after averaging 21.8 disposals and 6.2 marks — of which 3.5 were intercept marks – while going at an impressive 82.5 per cent efficiency by foot. Travaglia then finished off his 2024 campaign with a flurry of eye-catching displays at Coates Talent League level, kicking 8.2 and averaging 21.8 disposals and 4.4 inside 50s from his final five matches playing primarily as a midfielder with spurts in the forward arc. Travaglia got a small taste of what professional footballer life could look like earlier this year when he played two games for Carlton’s VFL side. His second match against Richmond was particularly eye-catching, finishing with 22 disposals, nine intercepts, seven score involvements and four marks. To cap it off, he finished second in the 2km time trial at the national draft combine with a time of 6:13. Travaglia is everything you need in a mid-sized intercept defender: Athletic and competitive in the air, pinpoint with his disposal from defence and smart with his offensive-defensive balance. But Travaglia – and AFL club recruiters – can see him following a similar trajectory to Hawthorn star Will Day, who was drafted as a defender before turning into a gun midfielder at the top level. He’s now a top 10 to 15 prospect, with Richmond (Picks 10 and 11) recently linked to the Pioneer.
14. JOE BERRY
Position: Medium forward
Size: 181cm
Clubs: Murray Bushrangers/Wangaratta
AFL player comparison: Dylan Moore
A crafty and hard-working half-forward that should thrive in the modern AFL era. Berry produced a brilliant, eye-catching carnival for Vic Country where he was a threat across all four games, finishing with nine goals and averaging 13.2 disposals and 5.5 score involvements. With sharp top-end speed that allows him to get up the ground, as well as excellent creativity close to goal, Berry is your typical high forward. He’s a natural crumber, getting to the right spots where he can show off his cleanliness at ground level and innate goal sense. He kicked 27 goals for the Bushrangers this season — the most of any active Coates Talent League player — while also averaging 14.4 disposals and 3.9 inside 50s to be a joint winner of the club’s best and fairest award and earn selection in the competition’s team of the year. Berry looms as a mid first-round pick, with Richmond, Fremantle, Port Adelaide and the Giants in the mix.
15. XAVIER LINDSAY
Position: Midfielder/medium defender
Size: 183cm
Clubs: Gippsland Power/Leongatha
AFL player comparison: Scott Pendlebury
Perhaps the classiest of the class. Recruiters coming into the year liked Lindsay as a half-back, but he showed throughout the year he has an improved inside game and is reliable across any third of the ground. But it’s decision-making, pinpoint ball use, agility and speed that really catch the eye. Lindsay’s ‘Pick Me’ game for Vic Country against Vic Metro, finishing with 30 disposals, 11 marks, 10 contested possessions, eight score involvements, eight tackles, six inside 50s, six intercepts, four clearances and 585m gained. Overall, he averaged 22.7 disposals, 4.3 clearances and 5.0 tackles in three matches for Country, having missed the Allies match due to injury. Lindsay then became the first Gippsland Power player in a decade to claim the Morrish Medal as the best and fairest player in the Coates Talent League, averaging 23.4 disposals, 5.4 clearances and 5.2 inside 50s across his 12 appearances this season. Lindsay is in the top-10 mix, with Melbourne (Pick 5) perhaps the club with the earliest pick that could take him. Yet there’s a world in which Lindsay slips to teams like the Dockers and Power in the teens, such is the nature of this year’s even draft class.
16. LUKE TRAINOR
Position: Tall defender
Size: 194cm
Clubs: Sandringham Dragons/Old Brighton Grammarians
AFL player comparison: Jordan Ridley
Slid a bit in the back-half of the year, but Trainor remains one of the best key-position prospects in the draft class. From his four games for Metro, Trainor averaged 19.8 disposals (76% kicking efficiency), 5.8 marks (1.8 intercept) and 4.8 rebound 50s as he showed off his strong offensive traits, including strong overhead marking and a penetrating right-foot kick. But what AFL clubs were more impressed by was competitiveness in the air and willingness to defend. This was particularly evident against South Australia, with Trainor taking the points against Tyler Welsh in an intriguing battle, while he also had big moments against Jonty Faull and Jack Whitlock in the Metro-Country game. His performances for the AFL Academy against VFL opposition were also impressive, named best on ground against Coburg (20 disposals, 4 marks) before another strong outing against Footscray (21 disposals, 1 goal). Trainor is the grandson of 1000-goalkicker Doug Wade and nephew of AFL Commissioner Gabrielle Trainor. The earliest he might be taken, at this stage, is Pick 7 (St Kilda), but clubs wouldn’t be surprised if he slipped towards the 20s. His landing spot could be determined by how early other key-position prospects go on the night.
18. BO ALLAN
Position: Medium defender/midfielder
Size: 191cm
Clubs: Peel Thunder/Halls Head
AFL player comparison: Elliot Yeo
Allan would be higher on others’ draft boards following a strong back-end to the season. After earning All-Australian honours — he averaged 20.0 disposals, 7.3 contested possessions, 6.3 score involvements, 6.0 tackles and 3.7 clearances for WA — Allan added another nine WAFL league games to take his season tally to 11 for Peel Thunder, averaging 11.5 disposals and 3.3 tackles on his way to becoming a premiership player. Allan is a great athlete — he recorded three top-four finishes at the national draft combine, in both vertical jumps and the agility test — and has strong footy nous. He has the range that allows him to play midfield minutes and win the ball around stoppages, yet is just as comfortable playing as a rebounding defender. Some clubs believe he can be a midfielder at AFL level due to his competitiveness, while others reckon he’d be more suited to a backline role. Either way, he looms as hot property on draft night. Both West Coast (Pick 12) and Fremantle (Pick 14) have been heavily linked to Allan, but he also has interest from Richmond with its mid-first round picks (Picks 10 and 11). Considering that Richmond interest and the fact the Dockers are now behind the Eagles in the draft order, scouts would be surprised if Allan was still on the board after West Coast’s pick.
Possibly available at 17
17. TAJ HOTTON
Position: Midfielder/medium forward
Size: 180cm
Clubs: Sandringham Dragons/Hampton Rovers
AFL player comparison: Shai Bolton
Clubs haven’t forgotten about the dangerous and creative Hotton, who was arguably the hottest player of the draft pool at the start of the season before rupturing his ACL at training in May. He had some monster Talent League games for the Dragons, most notably against the Chargers where he kicked 4.1 from 32 disposals, 10 marks, five inside 50s and five tackles. He also played a game for the AFL academy, booting two goals from 18 disposals against Coburg. Hotton had significantly improved his endurance, allowing him to spend more time on the ball. Hotton, the son of ex-Collingwood and Carlton player Trent Hotton and brother of 2022 Saints draftee Olli Hotton, is still expected to be a mid first-round pick with Richmond, in particular, said to have put some work into him. The fact so many clubs have multiple early picks this year — the Tigers, Giants, Swans and Bulldogs — probably plays into Hotton’s favour.
30. OLLIE HANNAFORD
Position: Utility
Size: 180cm
Clubs: GWV Rebels/Sandhurst
AFL player comparison: Tom Atkins
A late bolter who could go much earlier than this spot come draft night. Hannaford is a tough, speedy, exciting, versatile and well-rounded prospect who’s impressed across every line at different stages this year. He started the year in defence for the Rebels and impressed with his rebounding. As a forward, he kicked five goals against the Oakleigh Chargers in Round 18 then a bag of six in the qualifying final against the Geelong Falcons on his way to 21.8 for the season and selection in the Coates Talent League Team of the Year. He then finished as the Rebels’ best player in their grand final loss to the Dragons, picking up 24 disposals, nine tackles, seven inside 50s and a goal in a prominent performance. Could sneak into the teens in the first round.
24. JESSE DATTOLI
Position: Medium forward/wing
Size: 178cm
Clubs: Northern Knights/Heidelberg
AFL player comparison: Josh Rachele
There’s been ample intrigue around this Northern Knights product all year, for he’s uber-talented and has match-winner traits written all over him. After an injury-interrupted 2023 campaign, Dattoli impressed both at Coates Talent League level and against the best in the national carnival. He kicked 12 goals and averaged 23.1 disposals, 6.1 score involvements and 3.9 clearances for the Knights, while he also had a promising carnival campaign for Vic Metro, booting three goals and averaging 15.2 disposals, 7.2 marks and 6.0 score involvements. Dattoli works hard between the arcs and is creative with his ball use. He’s the kind of midfielder-forward with AFL traits that could easily sneak into the teens on draft night.
19. JOBE SHANAHAN
Position: Tall forward
Size: 194cm
Clubs: Bendigo Pioneers/Moama
AFL player comparison: Nick Riewoldt
A riser across the back-half of the season after starring on the national Under 18 stage then thriving against state league opposition. Shanahan was named at centre half-forward in the All-Australian team after an excellent carnival for the Allies, which saw him take a comp-high eight contested marks. His standout game came against Vic Country, booting three goals from with 16 disposals and nine marks (four contested) and three goals. But it was his three-game stint for Essendon’s VFL side that boosted the external attention on him, kicking 4.0 against the Northern Bullants, 2.3 against Gold Coast then 5.0 against Coburg. Shanahan finished the season with a six-goal, 17-disposal display for the Pioneers before being named in the Coates Talent League Team of the Year. Shanahan plays with grand presence in the air and has a superb pair of hands, but his mobility and ability to constantly present make him a threat around the ground as well. There’s a slight chance he sneaks in to the top 10 — should one of the Saints, Demons or Tigers want a key forward at that stage of the draft — otherwise he should be in that mid first-round mix featuring the Power, Dockers and Giants.
20. JACK WHITLOCK
Position: Tall forward/ruck
Size: 200cm
Clubs: Murray Bushrangers/Shepparton
AFL player comparison: Ben King
After a rollercoaster start to his 2024 season, Whitlock finished strong. He had a massive second half for Vic Country against Vic Metro in the final champs game to finish with 2.1 from 13 disposals and seven marks (three contested). Whitlock also thrived with more ruck time against Western Australia during the champs, finishing with 18 disposals, 11 contested possessions, eight score involvements, seven hit-outs and five clearances. That set him up for an imposing final six-game stretch with the Bushrangers at Coates League level, which saw him 15.11 and average 18.9 disposals and 5.0 marks. At 200cm and with great athleticism, Whitlock has all the traits to be an exciting key-position player at AFL level. His early draft prospects were enhanced by an increase in size and strength, which has helped him become a more ominous presence close to goal. Could be an outside chance to be taken by one of the Saints, Demons or Tigers in the top 10, but looms more likely as a later selection on night one. Could Sydney pounce?
Likely Available at 17 Possible at 25
25. COOPER HYNES
Position: Medium forward/midfielder
Size: 190cm
Clubs: Dandenong Stingrays/Bonbeach
AFL player comparison: Jack Ziebell
Power, power, power. Hynes, the son of John Hynes who played four games for Carlton in the late ‘90s, was a standout for the Dandenong Stingrays this season, kicking 23.12 and averaging 23.7 disposals, 7.4 score involvements and 4.7 clearances to finish runner-up in the Morrish Medal count. Hynes has brilliant inside ball-winning ability, but has kicked big bags of goals this year — including five against Gold Coast academy — while showing off his strong hands close to goal. Hynes boosted his first-round chances during the carnival, booting four goals and averaging 16.8 disposals and 5.2 score involvements playing mainly across half-forward for Vic Country. While there’s improvement left, Hynes has worked hard on his conditioning across the past 12 months to compliment his brilliant natural football ability. He has a wide draft range, with some suggesting he could taken with a late-teens pick or midway through the second round.
36. HAMISH DAVIS
Position: Medium forward
Size: 190cm
Clubs: Claremont/Subiaco
AFL player comparison: Will Hayward
Arguably WA’s second-best prospect after Bo Allan, Davis has many tricks he can bring to an AFL club. He’s athletic and powerful in the air, but his strong aerobic capacity — highlighted by the fact he ran the 2km time trial at the national combine in 6:18 (ranked fifth) — makes him a threat around the ground. Davis starred at every level he played at this year. After dominating for Claremont at Colts level — he kicked 14 goals and average 23 disposals from nine games — Davis thrived at the national carnival, kicking 7.7 and averaging 14.5 disposals and 6.0 score involvements across four matches. He then finished the year in Claremont’s WAFL league team, with standout performances against Subiaco (3.1 from 16 disposals) and East Fremantle (4.0 from 21 disposals) before producing a 30-disposal display in the colts grand final to win the Mel Whinnen medal as the best player on the ground. More likely to be a second-round selection at this stage.
22. JONTY FAULL
Position: Tall forward
Size: 195cm
Clubs: GWV Rebels/Redan
AFL player comparison: Charlie Curnow
There’s something special about this tall Rebel, who bounced back after a long lay-off to start the season with a back injury. Faull, who’s both strong overhead yet agile and clean below his knees for a player of his size, kicked five goals from three games for Vic Country at national champs level. He was then a dominant force at Coates Talent League level, finishing the season with an impressive 27.16 — including nine goals across two finals for the Rebels — while averaging 13.0 disposals, 4.5 marks and 102 ranking points from 11 matches. Like Jack Whitlock, Faull looms as a mid to first-round prospect.
23. ALEX DODSON
Position: Ruck
Size: 203cm
Clubs: Sturt/Payneham
AFL player comparison: Luke Jackson
The best ruck in this year’s draft class is a freak 203cm prospect who, up until a few months ago, wasn’t sure if he wanted to fully pursue an AFL or basketball career. He didn’t play footy at all in 2023, leading to him representing Australia in basketball at both Under 17 and Under 18 level. He was also a train-on player with the Adelaide 36ers – the NBL club he’s supported his whole life – as part of their development roster. But now that he’s all-in on footy, Dodson looms as a first-round prospect. After missing SA’s first champs this year game due to basketball commitments, Dodson averaged 17.3 disposals, 9.7 contested possessions, 3.7 clearances, 19.7 hit-outs and 114.1 ranking points in his three outings to earn All-Australian honours. Against Vic Metro, he snuck forward to take a strong contested mark and kick a goal in an encouraging sign. Dodson is everything you want in a modern-day athletic ruck. He’s competitive at ruck contests then follows up at ground level to help win clearances. He then works hard around the field to get to as many contests as possible and find the footy, both in the air and at ground level. Dodson is a good chance to be taken on the first round of the draft.
26. MATT WHITLOCK
Position: Tall utility
Size: 198cm
Clubs: Murray Bushrangers/Shepparton
AFL player comparison: Sam Taylor
While twin brother Jack is slightly taller and slightly higher rated overall, don’t sleep on the younger — and versatile — Whitlock. When Jack was sidelined earlier in the year due to a finger injury, Whitlock was swung from defence into the forward line – and had a day out against the Giants Academy team, booting 5.3 from 14 disposals and seven marks. He ended up kicking 27.20 for the year playing mainly as a forward, but was named at full-back in the Coates Talent League team of the year. Recruiters were pleased he had the opportunity to show his wares at the other end of the field – and just as stoked he was able to deliver, consistently presenting up at the ball all game and competing well in the air. But he was just as impressive in defence for Vic Country. While Whitlock is still lightly built and developing his frame, he’s very athletic — his running vertical jump of 90cm at the draft combine ranked sixth overall — and has shown greater ball-winning ability this year. A chance to be taken in the first round, considering the array of bids that’ll take place.
27. TOM GROSS
Position: Midfielder/medium forward
Size: 182cm
Clubs: Oakleigh Chargers/Old Trinity Grammarians
AFL player comparison: Rory Sloane
A slider, but Gross still has fans. The Chargers product made the All-Australian team, booting two goals and averaging 20.0 disposals, 7.0 score involvements, 5.2 marks, 3.5 tackles and 3.0 clearances for Vic Metro. Gross was especially impressive against South Australia, picking up 27 disposals – 11 during a defining third quarter – nine score involvements and nine marks — as he showed off his powerful aerobic capacity. His power, ferocity at the footy and strong overhead marking ability means he can impact games both close to goal and at stoppages. An outside chance to be taken in the first round — could the Giants pounce with their third first-round pick?
28. HARRISON OLIVER
Position: Medium defender
Size: 181cm
Clubs: Sandringham Dragons/St Bedes-Mentone
AFL player comparison: Luke Hodge
There’s a lot to like about this composed defender, who could be in the first-round mix due to competitiveness, decision-making and pinpoint distribution by foot. Oliver made the All-Australian team after averaging 16.2 disposals and going at 82 per cent efficiency by foot for Vic Metro. He can break the lines with his run, carry and kicking, while he also goes hard at the ball. Probably slid a touch during the back-half of the year, so is more likely a night two chance at the draft.
29. CHRISTIAN MORAES
Position: Utility
Size: 182cm
Clubs: Eastern Ranges/Knox
AFL player comparison: Luke Parker
Some clubs might have him higher on their boards, due to his elite workrate and running power. Moraes emerged as a top prospect for the 2024 draft last year, starring for the Eastern Ranges as a bottom-ager to average 26 disposals from 16 games — including one goal from 24 touches in the grand final. Due to Vic Metro’s strong on-ball brigade, Moraes didn’t get a lot of centre square time during the national carnival, starting as a half-back before playing more forward of centre. He still averaged impressive numbers — three goals and an equal carnival-high 8.0 score involvements to go with 20.8 disposals, 5.8 marks and 4.5 inside 50s — but missed out on All-Australian selection. Recruiters know how dynamic he can be though, personified by his first three games of the 2024 Coates Talent League season where he booted 9.3 and averaged 23.7 disposals, 6.7 marks and 4.0 tackles, before a five-goal, 27-disposal display against the Western Jets in Round 17. Could be a player that slips to the second round yet ultimately turns into a bargain selection. Hawthorn (Pick 33) got a glimpse of Moraes via the Box Hill program late in the season
Likely available at 25, possible at 35
32. NOAH MRAZ
Position: Tall defender
Size: 198cm
Clubs: Dandenong Stingrays/Noble Park
AFL player comparison: Darcy Moore
Probably would’ve been much higher on this board — and been taken earlier in the draft — if it wasn’t for navicular foot issue this season. Mraz managed two Talent League games for the Stingrays and played in both AFL Academy hit-outs against VFL opposition before his diagnosis. But the 198cm Stingray is still considered one of the best key defenders in the draft pool. He’s strong both in the air and at ground level for a player of his size, while his defensive positioning and closing speed are also standout traits. Scouts, too, love his competitive mindset and workrate. Looms as a second-round pick.
33. CHARLIE NICHOLLS
Position: Tall utility
Size: 197cm
Clubs: Central District/Min-Man
AFL player comparison: Harry Petty
This South Australian with vice-like hands has fans at AFL club level, mainly around his incredible pack marking ability, as well as his size and athleticism. Nicholls burst onto the scene at the start of the season, booting 13 goals from his first six SANFL Under 18s games. He then put on a breathtaking marking display against Vic Country, but was inaccurate in front of goal, finishing with 1.3 from 11 disposals and nine marks (four contested). But one of the best things for Nicholls was SA’s decision to play him behind the ball — a role he quickly adapted to, finishing with 10 disposals and six marks (four intercept) against Vic Metro. Post-champs, Nicholls had exposure at SANFL reserves level then had a strong Under 18s finals campaign with Central District. More likely to be taken on night two of the draft, possibly lower than this position.
34. JASPER ALGER
Position: Medium forward
Size: 182cm
Clubs: Oakleigh Chargers/Warragul
AFL player comparison: Toby Greene
A goalkicker with a lot of AFL traits. Alger is a strong overhead mark for a player of his size, while he’s also quick on the burst — personified by him ranking fourth in the 20m sprint (2.95 seconds) and 10th in the agility test (8.14 seconds) at the national draft combine. But Alger is crafty forward who knows where the goals are. He kicked five goals from four games for Vic Country — including three against South Australia — while his four-goal effort against the Calder Cannons in the Wildcard Round final was eye-catching. No. 34 might be a bit high for some clubs, but Alger has big upside.
35. TOM SIMS
Position: Tall forward
Size: 199cm
Clubs: Northern Knights/Montmorency
AFL player comparison: Charlie Dixon
The powerful and versatile Sims, who’s also a strong ruck option, plays with great presence on the field, marks the ball well and covers the ground well for a player of his size. He had a big start to the year with 15 goals from his five Talent League games for the Knights — including 7.4 from 15 disposals and 10 marks against the Oakleigh Chargers — before hitting a lean patch in the middle of the year. Sims kicked 4.5 from four champs games for Vic Metro, but it could’ve been a more fruitful haul if more opportunities were taken. Still, his ability in the ruck late in the Coates season was pivotal for the Knights and added another string to his bow. Considering the array of top-end key forwards in this year’s crop, Sims will likely have to wait until night two to get picked up at the draft.
37. JAMES BARRAT
Position: Tall utility
Size: 194cm
Clubs: Bendigo Pioneers/Leitchville Gunbower
AFL player comparison: Tom Barrass
A popular member of the Vic Country set-up, Barrat showed impressive versatility this year. He booted 16.18 from his first six Coates Talent League games then kicked two goals against South Australia in Vic Country’s opening championships clash. But an AFL club-led push saw Barrat swung into defence for the final two games of Country’s carnival — and he thrived on the big stage by averaging 11 touches and six intercepts. He then carried that form as a defender back to the Pioneers, averaging 18.8 disposals, 9.2 marks and 8.0 rebound 50s from his final six home and away games, before producing a two-goal, 25-disposal display in Bendigo’s wildcard clash against the Stingrays. Barrat won the Neville Strauch best and fairest award for the Pioneers’ boys team for season 2024. An aggressive and competitive player with a strong pair of hands, Barrat looms as a second-round draft pick.
38. ANGUS CLARKE
Position: Medium defender
Size: 189cm
Clubs: Glenelg/East Gambier
AFL player comparison: Mason Redman
A tall intercept defender with a high footy IQ and elite skills, Clarke has caught the eye of many clubs this year. He played a starring role for South Australia at the national carnival, averaging 17 disposals and two intercept marks per match. Clarke also played 10 games at Under 18 level for Glenelg where he averaged 16.7 disposals and ran his 2km time trial at the national draft combine in 6:16 — ranked third overall.
39. JACK OUGH
Position: Wing/midfielder
Size: 194cm
Clubs: GWV Rebels/Wentworth
AFL player comparison: Joel Freijah
Put himself on the radar with a strong finish to his 2024 campaign. After averaging 13.5 touches from four matches for Vic Country in the carnival where he impressed with his workrate, Ough starred across an eight-game stretch for the Rebels, averaging 25.1 disposals, 5.0 tackles and 4.3 marks where he spent more time on the ball. Against the Geelong Falcons, he amassed 33 disposals, 20 contested possessions and nine clearances as he showed off an improving inside game. Considering his height and versatility, clubs are optimistic he could be an inside midfielder at AFL level — to the point where some believe he’d be worth of being taken inside the top 30.
41. KAYLE GERREYN
Position: Tall forward/ruck
Size: 199cm
Clubs: West Perth/Joondalup Kinross
AFL player comparison: Rowan Marshall/Riley Thilthorpe
Another emerging bolter from WA, Gerreyn has got some real AFL attributes. He kicked five goals and averaged 6.5 score involvements from four games for WA at the carnival, before kicking 15.10 from his final eight games with West Perth across both colts and league. One aspect that was particularly noticeable during the champs was that he’s a beautiful, natural kick of the footy for a player of his size. Then at the same time, he’s not afraid to throw his weight around, both inside 50 and at stoppage. He’s a genuine forward-ruck that has clubs excited. Should be taken in the second round.
42. SAM DAVIDSON
Position: Medium forward
Size: 191cm
Clubs: Richmond (VFL)/St Kevin’s Old Boys
AFL player comparison: Ollie Dempsey
The best mature-age prospect in the class — and he could continue one of footy’s great recruiting streaks. Davidson this year was recognised for a breakout VFL season by claiming the Fothergill-Round-Mitchell Medal, which is awarded to the most promising player aged 24 or under. In a good omen for Davidson, the past 17 consecutive Fothergill-Round-Mitchell Medal winners — including Michael Barlow, Michael Hibberd, Kane Lambert, Nic Newman, Luke Ryan and Bayley Fritsch — have been drafted onto an AFL list. Davidson, 22, did most of his damage inside 50 for the Tigers’ VFL side this year, kicking 26.13 and averaging 14.4 disposals, but he also showed off his versatility by playing on the wing and, at times, in the ruck. He has terrific aerobic capacity — he ran his 2km time trial at the state draft combine in 6:12 — but is so competitive in the air too. Richmond has taken several players from its VFL list in recent years. Could Davidson be the next?
43. HARRY O’FARRELL
Position: Tall defender
Size: 197cm
Clubs: Calder Cannons/Maribyrnong Park
AFL player comparison: Harry Himmelberg
Had an injury-riddled draft year, but O’Farrell is a key defensive prospect expected to be on an AFL list next year. He played the first two Talent League games for the Cannons then impressed for the AFL Academy against Coburg with his strength, defensive nous and rebounding ability. O’Farrell then injured his ankle in his second champs game for Vic Metro, resulting in a two-month stint on the sidelines. When he returned for the Cannons, he was swung forward and kicked 2.4 from 10 touches before suffering a concussion in the next game. He has the mobility to play on either tall or small forwards due to his aerial presence and good judgement.
44. LACHIE JAQUES
Position: Medium defender
Size: 185cm
Clubs: Geelong Falcons/St Mary’s
AFL player comparison: Tom Stewart
The Falcons co-captain has come from the clouds this year. Jaques caught the attention of recruiters with a promising start to the season, averaging 26 disposals and 7.7 intercepts from his first three matches. He was then named at half-back in the All-Australian team from the national championships, averaging 16.2 disposals at 78.5 per cent efficiency for Vic Country. Jaques has a great ability to read the play and use the footy precisely coming out of half-back. Geelong always leans towards its local Geelong Falcons talent — and Jaques could be in their mix later in the draft.
46. ADRIAN COLE
Position: Tall defender
Size: 194cm
Clubs: Sandringham Dragons/St Bedes-Mentone
AFL player comparison: Dougal Howard
One for Saints fans to get excited about, as Cole is part of the club’s NGA. An athletic key-position backman who’s incredibly gifted one-on-one and has a great natural leap, Cole boosted his prospects playing for Vic Metro at the national carnival this year, locking down the opposition’s most dangerous tall forwards like Jonty Faull. He then rank the 2km time trial in 6:24 — ranked equal-seventh. The Saints will match a bid on Cole, but it could come a lot earlier than Pick 46.
47. JOSH DOLAN
Position: Small forward/midfielder
Size: 177cm
Clubs: Sandringham Dragons/Beaumaris
AFL player comparison: Dylan Moore
A high half-forward who could thrive in the modern AFL landscape. Dolan was a star for the Dragons this year, kicking 8.4 and averaging 19.8 disposals, 8.6 score involvements and 5.0 marks per game. He’s a strong runner and damaging by foot.
48. HUGH BOXSHALL
Position: Midfielder
Size: 187cm
Clubs: Claremont/Swanbourne
A ball magnet who was unlucky to not get an invite to the national combine, Boxshall now looms as a national draft selection. Boxshall, who averaged 25 disposals for Claremont’s colts side this season, always seems to have extra time in congestion and is clean via hand. He was also one of WA’s most prolific performers at the national carnival, averaging 18.7 disposals, 8.0 contested possessions and 5.0 marks.
49. XAVIER IVISIC
Position: Midfielder
Size: 180cm
Clubs: Geelong Falcons/Bell Park
Found the footy at will this year, primarily due to his excellent workrate contest to contest, but also for his footy IQ. Was overlooked for a national combine invite, despite averaging 22 disposals and six score involvements for Vic Country and 25 disposals and six clearances for the Falcons. Ivisic is lightly framed, but his strong running capacity and improving inside game has him on the radar.
50. OLLIE WARBURTON
Position: Medium defender/midfielder
Size: 185cm
Clubs: Murray Bushrangers/Shepparton Swans
A classy, versatile player who showed this season he can be deployed as either a defender or midfielder. Was excellent for Vic Country at the national champs, averaging 18.5 disposals and going at 77.1 per cent efficiency by foot. Warburton was also prolific for the Murray Bushrangers, averaging 25.9 disposals.
My wish list, in order of priority at each pick:
17 - Lindsay/Hotton/Berry/Hannaford. Really hope one of those guys is available - having to settle for a guy like Dattoli or Hynes here would hurt
25 - Oliver/Davis/Hynes
35 - Mraz/Clarke/Ough/Moraes/Jacques
48 - Davidson or maybe Jasper Alger
A few phantoms I've seen have us missing a few of these guys by a few places. Hopefully this is just a case of internet groupthink and recruiters will see it differently, allowing the guys I want due to internet groupthink to be available at our picks.
A draft hand of something like Hannaford/Oliver/Mraz/Davidson OR Hannaford/Davis/Jacques/Alger would be an amazing balance. weltschmerz picked Dattoli, Hynes, Moraes and Davidson and although I'm meh on some of the individuals he selected, the balance across those four picks is really really nice and plugs a lot of holes moving forward.
17 - Lindsay/Hotton/Berry/Hannaford. Really hope one of those guys is available - having to settle for a guy like Dattoli or Hynes here would hurt
25 - Oliver/Davis/Hynes
35 - Mraz/Clarke/Ough/Moraes/Jacques
48 - Davidson or maybe Jasper Alger
A few phantoms I've seen have us missing a few of these guys by a few places. Hopefully this is just a case of internet groupthink and recruiters will see it differently, allowing the guys I want due to internet groupthink to be available at our picks.
A draft hand of something like Hannaford/Oliver/Mraz/Davidson OR Hannaford/Davis/Jacques/Alger would be an amazing balance. weltschmerz picked Dattoli, Hynes, Moraes and Davidson and although I'm meh on some of the individuals he selected, the balance across those four picks is really really nice and plugs a lot of holes moving forward.
Mofra
Moderator
- Dec 6, 2005
- 69,264
- 204,493
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Footscray, Coney Island Warriors
- Moderator
- #1,107
I'd happily take Davis at pick 17. He's played (and performed) against men in the WAFL.
I'm far less enthused about this draft than many. There is a lot of value in later picks - guys like Barrat and Alger seem like they could make the grade. Davidson is ready to go and Richmond should jump on him with one of their second rounders.
I'm far less enthused about this draft than many. There is a lot of value in later picks - guys like Barrat and Alger seem like they could make the grade. Davidson is ready to go and Richmond should jump on him with one of their second rounders.
- Apr 23, 2013
- 7,336
- 10,931
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Cleveland Indians
Funny , I haven’t seen one bit of vision Hotton where I have thought wow another Shia Bolton .
Maybe size and build ?
But others will have seen way more of him, interested in their opinions ?
Maybe size and build ?
But others will have seen way more of him, interested in their opinions ?
I never really liked player comparisons
But what I see from every bit of vision of Hotton I’ve got my eyeballs onto is someone that is super creative in the forward line who brings other team mates into the game. I’m not as convinced with him been a permanent midfielder at this stage but just someone that gets thrown there to shake up the dynamic a bit every so often
Dattoli is basically Charlie Clarke with less flair. If we wouldn’t play Clarke then I don’t see the point in drafting Dattoli.
- Sep 2, 2013
- 11,236
- 10,465
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Honestly think that given the way our midfield depth is going to be tested over the next few years we really need to hit guys with midfield scope here, Hannaford and Hotton are the two obvious ones if they drop through to us at 17. I honestly wouldn't be surprised if we are one of the clubs that view Ough in the top 30, that is where I have him anyways ahead of Gross and Moraes could surprise and go a little earlier than our second in my opinion though. Clarke I have around our third pick and would be a good pick up there.
Guys like Boxshall/Angove/Warburton/Unwin etc might appeal in the 40's to try and fill in our wings and the rookie spot might be wise to pick up another developing no1 ruck as feel only having two on the list is a bit light on, Zac Harding and Jacob Molier being too I think could fit into the way we play.
Guys like Boxshall/Angove/Warburton/Unwin etc might appeal in the 40's to try and fill in our wings and the rookie spot might be wise to pick up another developing no1 ruck as feel only having two on the list is a bit light on, Zac Harding and Jacob Molier being too I think could fit into the way we play.
- Sep 14, 2015
- 5,369
- 16,034
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
There is talk that Richmond are open to offers, spreading their obscene riches into next year.
Next years draft apparently gets thin pretty quickly.
I'd happy if we offered something like 25+F1 for 11.
Getting a shot at somebody like a Xavier Lindsay holds a lot of appeal.
Next years draft apparently gets thin pretty quickly.
I'd happy if we offered something like 25+F1 for 11.
Getting a shot at somebody like a Xavier Lindsay holds a lot of appeal.
I'd rather see if we could trade 17 and F2 instead. The players I'd like are either gone by 17 or likely their at 25.
Similar threads
- Sticky
