List Mgmt. 2024 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

[Ticky009]

 

[Cadsky]

We are the window, heeney , paps etc are 29

We need some harden bodies

Kids won’t do until 3 to 4 years

Gotta have money though. Who are we trading out? Parker, sure. But then who? Chad the only obvious answer. Maybe go left field and trade florent even though he just signed, it's happened before.

 

[Punts]

Cats are leading the race for Oliver

 

[TasSixer]

Cats are leading the race for Oliver

Of course they are, probably got a beach house ready for him.

 

[tombomb]

Cats are leading the race for Oliver

1000-1 Melbourne trade Oliver to Geelong.

 

[Andyy1]

Gotta have money though. Who are we trading out? Parker, sure. But then who? Chad the only obvious answer. Maybe go left field and trade florent even though he just signed, it's happened before.

Should have everyone on the market imo, see what comes in, what can be manoeuvred around

 

[Dan87]

I think Perryman would be a step in the right direction

Still hasn't nominated

 

[ashep]

I'm as disappointed as anyone, but the team that put a 3 game gap on the competition @ 160% and won 2 finals wasn't a complete mirage.

Sure, we had some gaps in our list and our strategy badly exposed, but any suggestion of a rebuild because this list can't get back there is a significant overreaction.

We reload and go again.

 

[Benmacca33]

Trading in hamling to sure us up Down back played forward most of yr in ressies
Untried at senior level
Traded in adams for contested bull work
We know how that ended
Traded in Grundy played the yr but tailed off dramatically
Jordan was a win but never improved us that much
Don’t think there is enough out there to turn this around think we have enough cattle with talent
Need new direction with mongrel and a hard edge the focus teams get on top and we pack up simple as that happens to often
Coach coaches game plan that’s the change needed now it’s gone way to far

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Kick the tyres on Peter wright

No better than Amartey and no to trading with Essendon unless we have to

 

[Dan87]

No better than Amartey and no to trading with Essendon unless we have to

Amartey played his first full season and was our leading goal kicker

Put McLean in your crosshairs imo

 

[crankygeese]

The AFL just ruled the pick we got from North will come after any Band 2 compo picks

AFL informed teams that 'Band 2' compensation picks will fall before North Melbourne's pair of end-of-first round selections.

Sydney now face the prospect of falling further down the draft order should any of this year's free agency departures be deemed worthy of 'Band 2' or end-of-first round compensation.

This is the same thing that happened last year with the compo picks, it's not a conspiracy to **** us over, for once the AFL is consistently applying a rule that they used before. It's still frustrating, but they are being consistent. No need for pitchforks at the moment.

Clubs had lobbied to the AFL for the compensation picks to be placed before North Melbourne's pair of selections, given a similar situation occurred last year.


Adelaide and St Kilda both picked before Carlton, who held the Kangaroos' pick in 2023, having received end-of-first round compensation picks for Tom Doedee's free agency move to Brisbane and Jade Gresham's to Essendon respectively.


North Melbourne earned three end-of-first round compensation picks from the AFL last year due to poor performance, one in 2023 and two in 2024, but traded all three to rival clubs.


Last year's pick was shifted to the Blues in exchange for Zac Fisher, while their two picks this season went to the Swans for Dylan Stephens and to the Suns as a result of a pick-swap undertaken last season.

 

[Adnico26Parker]

I think Perryman would be a step in the right direction

Still hasn't nominated

Collingwood leading

6 x $850-900k

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Amartey played his first full season and was our leading goal kicker

Put McLean in your crosshairs imo

Either one not fussed who goes out. McLean covers ruck more. Need to take one of talls out

 

[Cadsky]

Either one not fussed who goes out. McLean covers ruck more. Need to take one of talls out

Like I said yesterday, put all 3 of them up against each other all summer. Specific drills for ruck work, jump, marking, goal accuracy, pack marking, etc. Tell them there's only two spots. Make them earn it.

 

[Bandit55]

He also was probably our best player in the 2022 Grand Final and had an amazing year all round.

Judging him on one game where he was no where near the worst player we had that day is hardly fair.

He came into the game in the 2022 Grand Final when it was all over. Fox was our best by the length of the Flemington straight.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Adnico26Parker]

RMC Sept Power Rankings:

AFL Draft Power Rankings: September 2024

With boys pathway seasons coming to a close around the nation, it's time for another instalment of our monthly AFL Draft Power Rankings.

central.rookieme.com

 

[SwansLifer]

Swans need to also keep an eye out for the next D'Ambrossio. The Hawks got him for peanuts.

 

[The King!]

We signed all 3 tall forwards, they aren't trading any.

Doesn't mean they all have to just play seniors every week though.

 

[Wheresbuddy]

Either one not fussed who goes out. McLean covers ruck more. Need to take one of talls out

Amartey cops alot of flak. However there is alot of talent to work with there. Another full preseason to back up from a relatively injury free year will hopefully build his tank and durability, allowing him to be an option as a backup ruck. If this eventuates, I think he is the preferred option over Mclean if we go for a two tall setup.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

I'm as disappointed as anyone, but the team that put a 3 game gap on the competition @ 160% and won 2 finals wasn't a complete mirage.

Sure, we had some gaps in our list and our strategy badly exposed, but any suggestion of a rebuild because this list can't get back there is a significant overreaction.

We reload and go again.

Oh no doubt we will back in 12 or 24 months dissecting another GF capitulation.

Hoping for Cleary and Sheldrick to cement a place in the side in 2025, exit meetings were today i assume Parker is staying?

 

[The King!]

Oh no doubt we will back in 12 or 24 months dissecting another GF capitulation.

Hoping for Cleary and Sheldrick to cement a place in the side in 2025, exit meetings were today i assume Parker is staying?

Mad monday

 

[KingV23]

Amartey cops alot of flak. However there is alot of talent to work with there. Another full preseason to back up from a relatively injury free year will hopefully build his tank and durability, allowing him to be an option as a backup ruck. If this eventuates, I think he is the preferred option over Mclean if we go for a two tall setup.

Agreed. Amartey's most recent preseason was his first uninterrupted, and he is our leading goal kicker. I think there is still a lot of upside with Amartey. McLean the most vulnerable in my opinion.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Amartey cops alot of flak. However there is alot of talent to work with there. Another full preseason to back up from a relatively injury free year will hopefully build his tank and durability, allowing him to be an option as a backup ruck. If this eventuates, I think he is the preferred option over Mclean if we go for a two tall setup.

Amartey is more than fine imo has provided great value for a late rookie pick.

Logan however is a problem showed little for a top 5 prospect so far even when we were dominating.

 

[wilsonmatic]

I think we should go after a key back, don't really rate McCartin. Also a ruckman to challenge Grundy. He's a bit of a lumbering dinosaur and way past his best.

 

[anotherletdown]

We are the window, heeney , paps etc are 29

We need some harden bodies

Kids won’t do until 3 to 4 years

I'd like to think we're in the window but there's a lot of heavy lifting being done by some relatively old players. Plus, are we real contenders? We've shat the bed last 2 times around.