List Mgmt. 2024 GWS Giants List Management - Academy, Free Agent, Trade & Draft

[Andre the Giant]

Been thinking about the Peatling situation and thinking could get ugly.

They have 4 which is a premium pick even in an even draft so doubtful it moves. They have 28 which has long been slated for Alex Neal-Bullen

30

Alex Neal-bullen

Age

28

Ht

182cm

Wt

80kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

15.3

4star

K

8.7

3star

HB

6.6

4star

M

2.8

3star

T

4.1

5star

G

0.8

4star

D

10.5

3star

K

6.0

2star

HB

4.5

3star

M

2.0

2star

T

1.5

2star

G

1.5

5star

D

10.0

3star

K

5.0

2star

HB

5.0

4star

M

1.4

2star

T

2.0

4star

G

1.0

4star

, a player they have worked on for more than a year. Their next pick this year is 45 which is not good enough.

Yesterday talk was they would offer a Future 2nd for Peatling but frankly that is not good enough as Adelaide whilst dreadful this year have recruited well and have the basis of a good side, they are a dangerous side to trade future picks with.

I think this one is going to require a multiple club deal for a satisfactory outcome.

 

[Maximus 2011]

Been thinking about the Peatling situation and thinking could get ugly.

They have 4 which is a premium pick even in an even draft so doubtful it moves. They have 28 which has long been slated for Alex Neal-Bullen, a player they have worked on for more than a year. Their next pick this year is 45 which is not good enough.

Yesterday talk was they would offer a Future 2nd for Peatling but frankly that is not good enough as Adelaide whilst dreadful this year have recruited well and have the basis of a good side, they are a dangerous side to trade future picks with.

I think this one is going to require a multiple club deal for a satisfactory outcome.

Which is why I don't like dealing with the Crows. I think they absolutely fleece us again and we end up with either a 3rd round pick, a future 2nd round pick or they take him to the draft

 

[PaythePerryman]

Which is why I don't like dealing with the Crows. I think they absolutely fleece us again and we end up with either a 3rd round pick, a future 2nd round pick or they take him to the draft

Problem is he won't make it through....he'll get picked ahead of Adelaide.

I don't think they currently have a pick to satisfy the trade. Future 2nd ain't cutting the mustard.

Someone floated sending them a pick(21) and Peatling for their F1.

Otherwise I'm not sure how it gets done

 

[Callums_Guns]

Someone floated sending them a pick(21) and Peatling for their F1.

Should be (37) and Peatling for their F1

Would be crazy to give them the pick we get for Cumming and Cumming/Peatling for F1




Start it at 52/Peatling for F1 then end up at 37/Peatling

 

[PaythePerryman]

Should be (37) and Peatling for their F1

Would be crazy to give them the pick we get for Cumming and Cumming/Peatling for F1




Start it at 52/Peatling for F1 then end up at 37/Peatling

Yeah I'd be stoked with that. Peatling is worth it ...they know.
..they are paying him a lot

 

[captainMyCaptain]

Hopefully we get a good deal for Peatling. But there is also the possibility that the reason the crows upped their offer from 4 years to 6 and added more $$$ for cumming was to get us first rd compo and in return we wouldn't get as much for Peatling.

 

[PaythePerryman]

Hopefully we get a good deal for Peatling. But there is also the possibility that the reason the crows upped their offer from 4 years to 6 and added more $$$ for cumming was to get us first rd compo and in return we wouldn't get as much for Peatling.

I think that hat might be tin foil

 

[Mors]

Hopefully we get a good deal for Peatling. But there is also the possibility that the reason the crows upped their offer from 4 years to 6 and added more $$$ for cumming was to get us first rd compo and in return we wouldn't get as much for Peatling.

More than likely they upped the offer because we upped the offer.

 

[captainMyCaptain]

NORTH Melbourne's No.2 pick and West Coast's No.3 selection are on the table as trade chips as clubs contemplate moves up the draft board.

The Giants will also consider shifting up the order given their hand now – picks 15, 16 and 21

Crows expected to use a future second-round pick to attain Peatling

Top picks on table, Crows moves keep coming, Combine watch - https://www.afl.com.au/news/1238227

 

[Danny88]

GWS doing GWS things…..

Flagging we will combine picks to move up the draft order

 

[sydney_gws]

GWS doing GWS things…..

Flagging we will combine picks to move up the draft order

Is thst good or bad? I think our best work is in accepting future 1sts.
I generally don't like the cost of trading up , however a higher pick is more likely to play and stay than picks 11 to 18 which have been problematic in the past, namely Hately and Bruhn.
Hopefully if we trade up it is as part of a 3 way trade where we don't lose too much value.

What do people think about 15,16 for pick 8 with St kilda?

 

[Giant Pete]

How many players do we need to bring in so far?
Haynes
Preuss
Hamilton
Peatling
Pez
Isaac

So 6… is that right?

 

[PaythePerryman]

How many players do we need to bring in so far?
Haynes
Preuss
Hamilton
Peatling
Pez
Isaac

So 6… is that right?

Kennedy

So 7

 

[PaythePerryman]

I don't think any draftee is gonna help us next year.
Leake, Gothard and Rowston might though.
I'd probably keep our picks and just take best available unless Caruso is obsessed with someone again....like Gothard

 

[sydney_gws]

Is thst good or bad? I think our best work is in accepting future 1sts.
I generally don't like the cost of trading up , however a higher pick is more likely to play and stay than picks 11 to 18 which have been problematic in the past, namely Hately and Bruhn.
Hopefully if we trade up it is as part of a 3 way trade where we don't lose too much value.

What do people think about 15,16 for pick 8 with St kilda?

What part do you disagree with?
Do you think 15,16 is too much for 8. I am not advocating it, just guessing what we might do.

 

[sydney_gws]

I don't think any draftee is gonna help us next year.
Leake, Gothard and Rowston might though.
I'd probably keep our picks and just take best available unless Caruso is obsessed with someone again....like Gothard

What do you think we should have done last year?

 

[PaythePerryman]

What do you think we should have done last year?

I was pretty certain we should take Caddy to pair with Cadman down the line.
But he didn't want to leave Vic apparently. After seeing Phoenix I'm pretty happy with it but Wilson looks like an oppo missed...it's too early to say though

 

[Orange crush]

What part do you disagree with?
Do you think 15,16 is too much for 8. I am not advocating it, just guessing what we might do.

I disagree with the suggestion of 15 and 16 for 8 …. Asked and I responded

 

[PaythePerryman]

It's such an even draft. Having 15/16/21 gives us a pretty good look at getting it right.
If you were giving up 15/16 you'd wanna get pretty high up the order

 

[MelbourneGWS]

Kennedy

So 7

And we are still waiting on Stone’s decision on our contract offer. Also Wade and XO have expressed interest in leaving, but their contracts only expire next year- unlike Stone’s contract which ended in 2024. However, our list manager in a radio interview stated that Wade and XO would not be going and was confident of Stone re-signing with us.

So best case the list vacancies are the 7 who have left us so far, and worst case 10 (assuming that we change our minds due to enticing trades offered for Wade and XO). Also supposedly Aleer whose contract expires next year was made an offer by St Kilda and turned it down.

 

[PaythePerryman]

And we are still waiting on Stone’s decision on our contract offer. Also Wade and XO have expressed interest in leaving, but their contracts only expire next year- unlike Stone’s contract which ended in 2024. However, our list manager in a radio interview stated that Wade and XO would not be going and was confident of Stone re-signing with us.

So best case the list vacancies are the 7 who have left us so far, and worst case 10 (assuming that we change our minds due to enticing trades offered for Wade and XO). Also supposedly Aleer whose contract expires next year was made an offer by St Kilda and turned it down.

Yeah I think we hold XO and Derk to their contracts and I'm praying Stone doesn't request a trade. He's the perfect replacement for Perryman in the back line in my opinion.
Fast and desperate in defence.
Finally a spot has opened up for him.

 

[Orange crush]

Yeah I think we hold XO and Derk to their contracts and I'm praying Stone doesn't request a trade. He's the perfect replacement for Perryman in the back line in my opinion.
Fast and desperate in defence.
Finally a spot has opened up for him.

You’d think Stone will see that spot open for him and stay

 

[Callums_Guns]

Yeah I think we hold XO and Derk to their contracts and I'm praying Stone doesn't request a trade. He's the perfect replacement for Perryman in the back line in my opinion.
Fast and desperate in defence.
Finally a spot has opened up for him.

If he stays the same could be said for Aleer who is also waiting for a spot and I think Aleer adds more (has hops aswell so could be used both forward or pinch hit in ruck)

 

[Bjo187]

Aleer might see an opportunity for that third tall defender role after watching himmelberg's finals series, the issue is, Harry is on massive money, so clubs are reluctant to have that value sitting in the two's.

I've always wondered if they could try him as a back up ruck, he did win the vertical leap award and the draft combine and has had a few years in the gym now. He could be a Keefe replacement.

 

[PMBangers]

I don't think any draftee is gonna help us next year.

Most of this years cohort is closer to 'ready to go' than last years, unless we're picking 100% talls or Tauru I'd say we'll see quite a few come in and have a decent level of impact