JJBagger
Club Legend
- Sep 6, 2022
- 1,310
- 3,729
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Name me a player in the comp that has never had a horrible kick? I think we judge him harshly because we put the microscope on every single disposal these guys take
List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃
- Thread starter Aphrodite
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Highly unlikely Hudson Okeefe would be cut, looks to have definite potential, unlucky with a long term hamstring.
Agree that Mirkov will go, l think a good chance Marchbank will go to the rookie list, still too many injury prone players on the list.
- Sep 25, 2013
- 16,122
- 31,139
I think they’ll delist rookie Carroll.
- Moderator
- #7,304
not worth his salary or draft picks for us (800+ and a good first round pick).
Busslingers numbers at VFL look very solid for a youngster. Top end draft talent so there must be something there to work with. Bevo pretty handy at getting kids off side if they don't fit his 'mould'.
KPD size and strong intercept mark. They maybe just gently simmering him in the 2s and all's well but he would be an ideal target if not getting a run at the dogs. Impossible to know what situation is but would be ideal
KPD size and strong intercept mark. They maybe just gently simmering him in the 2s and all's well but he would be an ideal target if not getting a run at the dogs. Impossible to know what situation is but would be ideal
TENACIOUS
Premiership Player
- Aug 16, 2008
- 3,949
- 14,906
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Smith?
His type is exactly what our midfield needs, aggression and speed…
A midfield of Cripps, Walsh, TDK, Cerra, Smith and Elijah would be insane…
$800k is a good deal, with the upcoming cap increases…
If our cap is that bad, that we can’t afford a decent player… It’s up to the players to make sacrifices like Geelong, Richmond, Hawthorn and Collingwood did…
Last edited:
Could be traded back to WA. Has been quite disappointing for mine. Hasn't come as his trajectory looked. His disposal is quite poor and doesn't get enough of it to be damaging. Shows some traits but we have seen a few of these types. They rarely really kick on. Think Dow, Setters, SPS, LOB. I would pit him in that category.
AndyNicka
Senior List
- Oct 14, 2008
- 194
- 621
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I think they're referring to Matthew Carroll not Jack Carroll.
Would prefer LDU if we could get him next year. Probably similar money and closer to what we need. Explodes out of stoppage more and a better user then Smith. Plus, a free agent.
Forgot about him. I was referring to Jack Carroll. You're probably right. Would be tough on him but if we are short on list spots, it'd be the obvious choice. Could keep him as part of the VFL program and see how he goes.
Jacks Seething Rage
All Australian
- Apr 13, 2024
- 722
- 2,084
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Both are correct.
He is one of our best kicks. He'd be no better than average by AFL midfielder standards.
Slight correction Zeke Uwland will be a gun, but he is next year’s draft, not this year. Their academy is getting scary.
- Moderator
- #7,313
you missed the bit i also mentioned an early draft pick, which we don't have
FWIW though i don't think he's a particularly good kick, or fast.
Forgot about that Carroll! His injuries could not have come at a worse time for him. Will be lucky to be rerookied
Apparently good in offence but weak with defence.
Not surprised we passed him up, based on that... doesn't fit the Vossy mould.
Do we have enough accountability with that mix? Not saying Smith wouldn't be a great get, but we also don't want to be one-way runners like Port.
- Sep 28, 2018
- 5,034
- 9,321
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Agree to disagree that’s fine but Marchbank at the very least should be on a rookies contract.
Can’t keep players who are constantly injured that’s just my opinion.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
- Sep 25, 2013
- 16,122
- 31,139
I’m all but certain they’ll retain only one of them. Plenty of chance both are gone. It’s time to move on from these players.
- Apr 7, 2006
- 1,714
- 5,268
- AFL Club
- Carlton
GC have a lot of AFL listed players playing VFL. There must be some more Elijah Hollandses in there.
Can't believe he wasn't getting a regular game in that rabble of a GC team last year. Rosas looks like a good player. Haven't seen much of Jeffery.
Will Moyle wait patiently for Witts to drop off if he gets offers elsewhere? I doubt it.
Agree - a lot to play out in the Pitto situation.
- Mar 25, 2019
- 14,391
- 29,441
- AFL Club
- Carlton
HS reporting Stengle available at 850k apparently... Would be out of our range with TDK and Weitering signings in the future.
Still hoping for a miracle though
Still hoping for a miracle though
- Aug 22, 2014
- 14,017
- 51,135
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Depending on how other clubs rate this draft, Martin could be floated for a pick upgrade. Freo will likely have three picks in the teens (theirs, Port's and Collingwood's) - would expect they'd probably try to move up the board with some of those, but could they be tempted to downgrade one to our first if they also get Martin in the deal?
Say they turn 14, 15 and 16 into 8, 20 and Martin, that's probably not a bad outcome for a side that genuinely fancy themselves a premiership chance in the next few years, but also want to keep bringing in talented kids. Opportunity looks like it could be there too, Brissy and GC both with picks around the 7-9 mark the way things are tracking, and both have highly rated Father-Son/ Academy picks this year.
If Martin gets us from 20 to 15 (hopefully ensuring the pick can be used before a Campo bid), and frees up some cap space to target a free agent this year or next (by front ending a contract or two), that's probably the best we can hope for from an oft-injured, almost 30yo player. Not overly enamoured by this year's free agents, but we could set ourselves up with cap space to chase a Ballard or Collins via free agency next year. Values him around a late third, which I think is the most we could get for him, but the actual benefit we get outweighs the arbitrary draft pick value.
Say they turn 14, 15 and 16 into 8, 20 and Martin, that's probably not a bad outcome for a side that genuinely fancy themselves a premiership chance in the next few years, but also want to keep bringing in talented kids. Opportunity looks like it could be there too, Brissy and GC both with picks around the 7-9 mark the way things are tracking, and both have highly rated Father-Son/ Academy picks this year.
If Martin gets us from 20 to 15 (hopefully ensuring the pick can be used before a Campo bid), and frees up some cap space to target a free agent this year or next (by front ending a contract or two), that's probably the best we can hope for from an oft-injured, almost 30yo player. Not overly enamoured by this year's free agents, but we could set ourselves up with cap space to chase a Ballard or Collins via free agency next year. Values him around a late third, which I think is the most we could get for him, but the actual benefit we get outweighs the arbitrary draft pick value.
- Mar 20, 2017
- 10,971
- 37,072
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Mid week tackle reporting that many clubs are confident that Tyson Stengle is gettable at $800k per season. Stkilda and * at the head of the queue but others watching.
I wouldn't get rid of all our injury-prone players.
Would delist Marchy and Cunners as their roles can be covered... bur more inclined to keep Martin.
Martin adds an important component to our F50 that no other player on the list can. Good in the air, on the ground and hard at it.
Plus we need that extra aerial threat up forward whenever Harry relieves in the ruck. I'd like to keep him, at least till Moir is ready.
Would delist Marchy and Cunners as their roles can be covered... bur more inclined to keep Martin.
Martin adds an important component to our F50 that no other player on the list can. Good in the air, on the ground and hard at it.
Plus we need that extra aerial threat up forward whenever Harry relieves in the ruck. I'd like to keep him, at least till Moir is ready.
- Status
