List Mgmt. 2024 List Management discussion

[Grasshopper17]

We probably are indebted to Day.I think his worst injury occurred preseason when he broke his hip.I remembe it was described like a car accident.

Did he run into Jonathan Brown?

 

[Crusha]

Must admit, after MFC trade with Bombers today leaving them with only pick 49 (we aren't getting 5 and 9), I thought that the Sharp trade with MFC would've happened fairly quickly subsequently after their Bombers trade.

They need to keep it available until they have exhausted all possibilities to trade up in this years draft.
(Beware ...... It's possible that their 2024 pick offer for Sharp could be further out still !!)

 

[Perrip]

Inside Trading

Dees make Sharp bid
Melbourne has put forward its No.49 selection in trade talks with Brisbane over contracted winger Harry Sharp, with the Demons now short on trade options following a mega pick swap completed on Monday.
The club gave its future first-round pick, as well as picks No.28, 40, 46, 54 and 65, to move back into the early parts of this year's draft and nab Essendon's No.9 selection to kickstart the Trade Period's final week.
The Lions had initially indicated that they wanted an earlier pick than No.49 in talks over Sharp, who requested a trade to the Demons on Friday last week despite being contracted through until 2025.
Brisbane is confident its current draft hand – which includes picks No.32, 34, 42, 43, 45, 60 and 66 – will be enough to match bids on Levi Ashcroft and Sam Marshall and therefore isn't holding out for more later picks.

 

[Happy_Neale]

Am I crazy, or is Dizzy not obviously going back forward when he's back?

You could not have worded this more confusingly if you tried

The issue with Dizz IMO is he is undersized and not a natural forward. He also had lost a yard of pace pre-ACL so who knows if he'll even get back to where he was physically. Having said that I didn't mind him forward but I don't think there's room for him and Morris tbh.

 

[M Malice]

Inside Trading

We might prefer a future 2nd round pick for Harry Sharp, Demons would back themselves in to move up the ladder and that pick to be in the late 30s.... we could then start a death ride thread and hope it will be pick 19.

 

[Lace Out]

Inside

Dees can piss off with that 49.Terrible offering.

 

[braddsey]

We might prefer a future 2nd round pick for Harry Sharp, Demons would back themselves in to move up the ladder and that pick to be in the late 30s.... we could then start a death ride thread and hope it will be pick 19.

I loves me a good deathride!
Anything we can give Port for one of their future picks?

 

[braddsey]

Have we done this one yet this trade period?

 

[buttermuffs]

Can’t see us getting Day. Those days of trading in spuds is well and truly past us.

Well this isn’t a trade. Also I feel reading for Fort is the exact same type of move we are doing here for Day. It’s a solid experienced depth choice in a position where only Oscar/Hipwood respectively is experienced.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Big Sauce 21]

Lukosius gets what he wants, tanked his performances hard the last 2 years to get this to happen.

 

[McIvor]

Inside Trading

Relates to my post this morning that I thought we were pushing for 40 or 46 so the club must have been disappointed that MFC went ahead and traded those picks out nonetheless. Wonder if we are now after something more than 49 and something next year?

 

[Johnny Bananas]

We might prefer a future 2nd round pick for Harry Sharp, Demons would back themselves in to move up the ladder and that pick to be in the late 30s.... we could then start a death ride thread and hope it will be pick 19.

Since Melbourne have traded their future first, doesn't that mean they can't trade out any other future picks unless they have two in that round?

 

[Sproj]

We're only taking it a day at a time for starters...

We would love to entertain players of that calibre but (insert name here) is contracted.

 

[Dom PC]

I know we've had some absolute snore fests in other trade periods but this one has to be right up there... they need to shorten it to 6 business days so there is a weekend and the Monday to wrap it up.

 

[McIvor]

I know we've had some absolute snore fests in other trade periods but this one has to be right up there... they need to shorten it to 6 business days so there is a weekend and the Monday to wrap it up.

I don’t get why it needs to be entertaining or how some player moving clubs is even that interesting but that’s me I guess.

 

[M Malice]

3 days would be plenty for the official trade period, clubs would be talking behind closed doors out of the spotlight well before anyway.

 

[Big Sauce 21]

I know we've had some absolute snore fests in other trade periods but this one has to be right up there... they need to shorten it to 6 business days so there is a weekend and the Monday to wrap it up.

Monday to Friday. No weekend break.

 

[blueiris]

Ryan, Gunston, Fort, Cockatoo?

We've traded for quite a few recently who haven't ended up in our best team but still provided value to the club

Fort is a premiership player thank you very kindly and don’t you forget it

 

[blueiris]

I know we've had some absolute snore fests in other trade periods but this one has to be right up there... they need to shorten it to 6 business days so there is a weekend and the Monday to wrap it up.

Agree the AFL really should have brought in 2years in advance trading immediately imagine the Trades most trades would be done quite easily and imagine the Names Chad Warner to Fremantle McKay to Us and such and such

 

[Morbidly_Obese]

Lukosius gets what he wants, tanked his performances hard the last 2 years to get this to happen.

Nah he's just shit.

 

[Morbidly_Obese]

Dees making things hard for themselves with that trade with Essendon. Only have 3 more draft picks this year and have to get deals done for Sharp + Derkson potentially.

Maybe we can hijack the derkson trade.

 

[Section 5]

Dees can piss off with that 49.Terrible offering.

How dare they offer 49 when we got him for 43. Hold out i say.

 

[Leuy LongerCombo]

Since Melbourne have traded their future first, doesn't that mean they can't trade out any other future picks unless they have two in that round?

Throwing in a swap of Future 3rds could end up being quite beneficial to us, the Dees are clearly backing themselves in to bounce back.

In saying that pick 49 doesn’t seem too bad for Sharp. It may make pick 66 surplus to our list space though, and doubt we get anything meaningful if we’re required to trade it into next years draft.

 

[Tom14]

Since Melbourne have traded their future first, doesn't that mean they can't trade out any other future picks unless they have two in that round?

Correct.

If we can squeeze more out of the dees then great, but I actually think pick 49 is about what Sharp is worth. If we would prefer to keep him for depth, then that's totally fine too.

Frankly the greatest benefit for us of trading him is probably going to be freeing up a list spot so we can take more picks/keep other players if we want to. I haven't bothered to go through and work out our list spots/picks situation so don't know if we really need to though.

 

[martinson]

Correct.

If we can squeeze more out of the dees then great, but I actually think pick 49 is about what Sharp is worth. If we would prefer to keep him for depth, then that's totally fine too.

Frankly the greatest benefit for us of trading him is probably going to be freeing up a list spot so we can take more picks/keep other players if we want to. I haven't bothered to go through and work out our list spots/picks situation so don't know if we really need to though.

49 for Sharp is fine. I can't see him getting a game here unless we have massive injury issues.