![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/carlton.png)
- Mar 25, 2019
- 11,161
- 22,169
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Switkowski rumour still has legs on the Flagmantle board, been discussed all yearIgnore, posted the same on our Board.
Obvious attention seeking troll is obvious![]()
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Semi Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Switkowski rumour still has legs on the Flagmantle board, been discussed all yearIgnore, posted the same on our Board.
Obvious attention seeking troll is obvious![]()
Switkowski rumour still has legs on the Flagmantle board, been discussed all year
Re: the poster spouting the Trac to Carlton rumours
![]()
Except Fanta was an injury riddled guy who had played little football at the highest level for a long time!The Houston chase smells like a Vossy favorite tbh - bit like Fantasia on a 2 year contract.
I'd say (hope) we're just asking the question rather than heavily pursuing it.
Nice player but have other more pressing needs and draft picks to use on actual 18yo's.
Been mentioned by many different posters of there's since about May, not just that one.That particular poster hasn’t posted any Switkowski rumours.
Check their posting history.
Been mentioned by many different posters of there's since about May, not just that one.
Waterman did bugger all after Q1.That is just wrong.
Kemp was playing on bigger opponents and was outsized. Had little hope.
Young is our second best 1v1 and rarely loses his contests. Nice story.
McGovern - you bet. waterman was their only hope and guess who was minding him?
1 out of 3 ain’t bad I suppose.
We have two top 5 kpf's. We have a top 3 kpd. What team can claim that? At what point do we begin to think our issues may be between the arcs?Hopefully Austin doesnt get distracted by Houston and miss a second key stoppage based defender.
It would be seriously frustrating if he misses it again.
Opposition teams strategy...drag Weitering away from the ball; kick it to either Kemp/Mcgovern/Young's opponent. Score goals.
Talk on the Freo board that Switkowski still heading back to Vic this off season.
Houston
Switkowski
Haynes
2024 First round draft pick
Ben + Lucas Campo
Wouldn't be a bad haul if we could pull it off. Feel like a name would have to go to fit everyone.
Some guy in the Trac thread saying Trac is 100% in play for the Blues too, Cerra and TDK names that have been thrown up.
Arcs being ears?We have two top 5 kpf's. We have a top 3 kpd. What team can claim that? At what point do we begin to think our issues may be between the arcs?
That works too.Arcs being ears?![]()
If we lose Owies to bring in Switkowski, we’ve lost the plot
We'd get a draft pick for Owies as he is not a free agent. Switkowski + pick 30ish for Owies is a deal worth doing if you ask me.
Owies manager has popped his name out to see his value.
This ain’t rocket surgery.
Who is your second top KPDer? Give me a name or names?We have two top 5 kpf's. We have a top 3 kpd. What team can claim that? At what point do we begin to think our issues may be between the arcs?
I disagree, Jsos can be a defender. When have we seen it? was it just a game or a season? No he is not his Dad.Sos is NOT a defender (we’ve seen it, even if our heart longs for him to be just like his dad)
I believe that he is refering to Harris & Sam being the top 2 KPD and Weitering being the 3rd.Who is your second top KPDer? Give me a name or names?
We only have Weitering then it is the abyss in terms of defending.
I think you are referring to intercept defenders. We don't have strong lock down defenders except Weitering who we want to free up.
Depending entirely on how much $ he's asking for.Owies bleeds blue. Would be a stupid LM decision to let him go.
Did Jon Ralph just report that Jack Martin is about to be offered another contract?
As an aside, really irks me when people refer to Martin as a small forward.
Carlton F.C. website says 192 cm's.he's 194cm.
Club website has him at 194cmSecond and third efforts sure, but that isn't applicable to defensive third only. So not sure why this is relevant to JSOS being in defence. Defensive pressure inside forward 50 is huge in the modern game.
He isn't the perfect size, he is 1.91m which would mean he would be the third tall at best and often find himself undersized. He would have to play intercept so would he take McGovern's spot? McGovern is probably a better user of the football and is quicker so not sure how this makes us better.
We have a best 22 medium forward spot availible due to Martin never being fit. If we can fit Mckay, Curnow and two rucks we can fit McKay, Curnow and JSOS.
Gov has very different attributes to JSOS, the main one being pace. McGovern is really quick off the mark.
If JSOS was closer to 200cm I would agree, fact is he isn't and we really don't have a burning need for medium defenders. We do have a need for a third tall forward who is consistent.
I don't think JSOS is a KPD defensive option, he isn't strong a big body that can wrestle and isn't tall.
I think we need to persist with L Young rather than throwing an undersized defender to the wolves as we have with Kemp this year.