List Mgmt. 2024 List Management Part 2 📃

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Shiel has lost his explosiveness these days anyway due to injury. A slightly above average speed plodder now
He has been no where near the player he was once he left the Giants, was a very damaging player amongst the extremely skilled & talented depth of midfielders and flankers that came through together, who could carve up sides on any particular day once they starteded to mature and emerged into a serious team…

Hindsight shows as talented as he was with some wonderful traits, clever positioning as well as speed and burst through congestion, he was capable of bursting out and setting up forward runs or chains, his kicking though wasn’t his strongest ability…
Injuries along the way as his career progressed seem to have impacted his strengths as a speed runner, decision making also has also seemed to deteriorate over time also…
 
Feels like a case of Stockholm syndrome, we've been abused by injured players so we need Shiel to keep the abuse now we've dumped Cunningham, Martin and Marchbank.
Sam Day as a DFA?

I refuse not to have a consistently injured key defender on the long term injury list, rushed back for a game only to get injured by half time and miss 8 weeks when the initial prognosis was 2 weeks...
 
Shiel has lost his explosiveness these days anyway due to injury. A slightly above average speed plodder now

His disposal is rubbish these days too
both incorrect. His kicking was safe as it should be for an inside mid. His pace was the Dylan of old.

A few Essendon supporters even suggesting they'd start him in the 22
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

both incorrect. His kicking was safe as it should be for an inside mid. His pace was the Dylan of old.

A few Essendon supporters even suggesting they'd start him in the if you

both incorrect. His kicking was safe as it should be for an inside mid. His pace was the Dylan of old.

A few Essendon supporters even suggesting they'd start him in the 22
You can keep him then
 
Thinking Curtis Taylor might fit in nicely.

We could do (and have done) worse
 
10th Anniversary of last flag = Wooden Spoon

20th Anniversary of last flag = Wooden Spoon

30th Anniversary of last flag = ...

Don't even think about it Carlton. Time to get serious this off-season 😠
If we want to make it more likely to happen we should trade away our future 1st
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top