2024 Phantom draft all invited

[blueiris]

round 1 Picks

1.Richmond Sam Lalor
2. North Melbourne Alix Tauru
3.Brisbane Lions _ Levi Ashcroft
4.Carlton_ Jagga Smith
5.Adelaide_ Sid Draper
6.Melbourne_ FOS
7.Richmond_ Harvey Langford
8. Essendon _ Isacc Kako
9. GoldCoast_ Leonardo Lombardo
10.St Kilda_ Murphy Reid
11. St Kilda_ Tobie Travaglia
12.Melbourne_ Harvey Armstrong
13. Richmond_ Luke Trainor
14. Richmond_ Josh Smillie
15. Western Bulldogs_ Bo Allen
16. Port Adelaide_ Joe Berry
17.Fremantle_ Cooper Hynes
18 GWS_ Xavier Lindsay
19. GWS_ Harrison Oliver
20.West Coast_ Tom Gross
21.Richmond
22.Sydney
23.Richmond
24. GWS
25.Sydney
26.Richmond


Round 2
27 Richmond
28 West coast
29.West Coast
30 Port Adelaide
31 Fremantle
32.St Kilda
33 Hawthorn
34, Western Bulldogs
35. Port Adelaide
36.GWS
37 Carlton
38. Essendon
39 Sydney
40 Geelong
41 Essendon
43 St Kilda
44 Western Bulldogs
45 Brisbane Lions
46 Port Adelaide


Round 3
47 Gold Coast
48 Collingwood
49 Essendon
50. Brisbane Lions
51 Essendon
52 Collingwood
53 GWS
54 Geelong
55 Collingwood
56 Sydney
57 Brisbane Lions
58 Gold Coast
59 North Melbourne
60 Carlton
61 Adelaide
62 Essendon
63 Brisbane Lions
64 Fremantle

Round 4
65 Carlton
66 Essendon
67 Carlton
68 Gold Coast
69 Hawthorn
70 Gold Coast
71 Carlton
72. West Coast
73. GWS
74. Geelong
75 Gold Coast
77 Hawthorn
78 Gold Coast

 

[year of the cat]

Pacey

I’d describe him as “powerful” but certainly not pacy.

 

[Futbolista]

Pacey

Compared to me, yes!

 

[Haggas]

1 Richmond - Sam Lalor
2 North Melbourne - Alix Tauru
3 Brisbane Lions - Levi Ashcroft
4 Carlton - Jagga Smith
5 Adelaide - Sid Draper
6 Melbourne - Finn O'Sullivan
7 Richmond - Harvey Langford
8 Essendon - Isacc Kako
9 GoldCoast - Leonardo Lombardo
10 St Kilda - Murphy Reid
11 St Kilda - Tobie Travaglia
12 Melbourne - Harvey Armstrong
13. Richmond - Luke Trainor
14 Richmond - Josh Smillie
15 Western Bulldogs - Bo Allen
16 Port Adelaide - Joe Berry
17 Fremantle - Cooper Hynes
18 GWS - Xavier Lindsay
19 GWS - Harrison Oliver
20 West Coast - Tom Gross
21 Richmond - Jobe Shanahan
23 Sydney - Taj Hotton
24 Richmond - Jesse Dattoli
25 GWS - Oliver Hannaford
26 Sydney - Thomas Sims
27 Richmond - Jack Whitlock


Round 2
28 Richmond - Christian Moreas
29 West Coast - Matt Whitlock
30 West Coast - Hamish Davis
31 Port Adelaide - Jonty Faull
32 Fremantle
33 St Kilda
34 Hawthorn
35, Western Bulldogs
36 Port Adelaide
37 GWS
38 Carlton
39 Essendon
40 Sydney
41 Geelong
42 Essendon
43 St Kilda
44 Western Bulldogs
45 Brisbane Lions
46 Port Adelaide

 

[ArdentEagle]

I could have sworn Jack Whitlock was taken ages ago...No stress, still very happy with Sims.

 

[blueiris]

I could have sworn Jack Whitlock was taken ages ago...No stress, still very happy with Sims.

hawthorn trade was Vetoed

 

[bone2468]

Pick 32 Fremantle select: Kayle Gerreyn

 

[weltschmerz]

SnusCG Saints up

 

[SnusCG]

Pick 33. St Kilda selects Alex Dodson

 

[Hawker399]

Pick 34 - James Barrat
Perfect choice for the Hawks. 3rd tall forward or back. Surprised others were chosen in front of him.

 

[weltschmerz]

Pick 35, the guy I've been hoping would make it past the last half dozen picks, Dogs select Angus Clarke.

 

[ArdentEagle]

hawthorn trade was Vetoed

Cheers mate. Hard to keep up while I was at work. All G anyway.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Sydney - Thomas Sims
199cm KPF

I think he'll be the best forward and a very good 2nd ruck

Had a very respected board veteran suggest I take a closer look and I like what I saw.

Write up to follow

*I considered the other twin but I have other plans

Don’t hate it just question whether you could have traded back and done the same thing but those are the two key needs whatever tall forward is fine

 

[guruisatiger]

Looking at What I picked for Richmond so far

They have the speed in Lalor and Dattoli
The inside bulls in Smillie and Langford

The Key defender in Trainor

And Key Forward in Shanahan

I missed on the pace of Marshall
And Hotton

Take out Langford and trainor
Replace with hotton and Lindsay

 

[Haggas]

Pick 36. Port Adelaide - Jack Ough

 

[ArdentEagle]

Don’t hate it just question whether you could have traded back and done the same thing but those are the two key needs whatever tall forward is fine

Possibly mate. A small risk I could have missed both.

I really wanted to make sure I got my KPF after landing Hotton.

So far it fallen the way I was hoping. I still have plans/primary and secondary targets and will end up taking 4 picks I think.

I wanted to get the perfect balance for you guys.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Possibly mate. A small risk I could have missed both.

I really wanted to make sure I got my KPF after landing Hotton.

So far it fallen the way I was hoping. I still have plans/primary and secondary targets and will end up taking 4 picks I think.

I wanted to get the perfect balance for you guys.

More the second pick Hotton is perfect he was there you sort of had to take him. Just get bad vibes reaching for talls that said you have addressed two of our needs a small forward or a medium forward next pick

 

[year of the cat]

Trade offer to GWS - F2 for pick 37

Giant Strides

 

[blueiris]

Take out Langford and trainor
Replace with hotton and Lindsay

Sorry I'm confused are you saying Richmond perfect draft would be this scenario

 

[WilloTree]

Pick 32 Fremantle select: Kayle Gerreyn

Brad Oldfield loves this pick.

 

[Giant Strides]

Trade offer to GWS - F2 for pick 37

Giant Strides

Accepted. Pick #37 is all yours.

blueiris , please note change of owner of pick #37 from GWS to Geelong.

 

[year of the cat]

Pick 37 - Geelong select Lachie Jaques

Write up to follow

You’re up Vindicater

 

[eth-dog]

Vindicater 47 and 58 for 38?

 

[Cobblers]

Accepted. Pick #37 is all yours.

blueiris , please note change of owner of pick #37 from GWS to Geelong.

I would like to know the logic behind Giants agreeing to that trade. Seems as if you are trading for very similar pick in a weaker draft. My understanding is that the Giants have the list spots to take 5 picks in this years National Draft.

 

[Giant Strides]

I would like to know the logic behind Giants agreeing to that trade. Seems as if you are trading for very similar pick in a weaker draft. My understanding is that the Giants have the list spots to take 5 picks in this years National Draft.

No, actually we only have 4 spots for ND, then 2 in the rookie draft. So, in reality, a trade of this nature would have needed to be made before the ND spots are finalised. I am effectively replicating that outcome.

I would think that in the next week or so, GWS will either:

• bundle up 2 (or even more) picks to grab an earlier round 1 pick, OR
• trade a single pick (#16, 21, or 37) into 2025.

Otherwise we will simply lose pick #53, which seems a waste.

I think #37 is a big chance to be moved because of the risk that Logan Smith will be bid before then; but we might take the risk and simply have a trade out ready to go on the night. #37 for a F2 from a team likely to be at the pointy end of next year's ladder is a good result, and GWS will hope that they actually do poorly and it becomes more valuable.

I could have just taken a selection here and not worried about the reality of list spots (I had someone in mind until the trade offer popped up), but this mock draft has given me some thoughts so happy to make the trade.

I'd also note that with the revised points system to match academy and father/son bids, I suspect second round picks will become more valuable in future (vice currently third round picks). This trade would add a third second-round pick in 2025 for Giants - I see this would be creating value in possible trades for round 1 picks next year (Lions and Suns, for example, will likely do their usual trade back to increase points for guys like Annable & Uwland).

Does that make sense?

 

[Vindicater]

Vindicater 47 and 58 for 38?

I would have been tempted but I have a player I like the look of.

But first am I right in saying nobody has bid on Sam Marshall yet? If so will put a bid on him.