Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Judd_Magic]

Keep one: McKay Vs Sexton

Sexton

 

[Jiska]

Trade:

Oliver or Green

I would have said both, but Piggy worth another look with Trac out for a while now.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Trade Oliver or miller

 

[Jiska]

Trade Oliver or miller

I would have said both, but Piggy worth another look with Trac out for a while now.

 

[Jiska]

I would have said both, but Piggy worth another look with Trac out for a while now.

Trade Oliver or miller

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Have to cull Petracca but no mids or fwds appeal to me at his price range, might just bring in a defender.

Whitfield v The Lizard?

 

[NSLK]

Hold J McCrae and hope he comes good / upgrade him / hold as F7/M9 cover

Hold Reid and wear the extra "bye" (don't need him for 18), F6

 

[stevebbb]

Trade Oliver or miller

Trade Oliver. A short rest isn't going to help him, he needs a full preseason to get back to his old self. He looks unfit, lacking effort, and his decision making is horrible. I actually think without Trac things will get worse for him and the Dees. I'm sure he'll have a few big scores, but if he averages over 100 I'll be very surprised.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Have to cull Petracca but no mids or fwds appeal to me at his price range, might just bring in a defender.

Whitfield v The Lizard?

The lizard for mine

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Trade Oliver. A short rest isn't going to help him, he needs a full preseason to get back to his old self. He looks unfit, lacking effort, and his decision making is horrible. I actually think without Trac things will get worse for him and the Dees. I'm sure he'll have a few big scores, but if he averages over 100 I'll be very surprised.

It's interesting, as I thought he played quite well in a beaten team the other day. Was getting to stoppages better than early in the season and to my eye was actually trying hard.

 

[jdwood]

Gulden and J Clarke

Vs

Neale and H Young

Leaning the former

 

[SC fish]

It's interesting, as I thought he played quite well in a beaten team the other day. Was getting to stoppages better than early in the season and to my eye was actually trying hard.

I thought he improved once Petracca went off too. Still way off his best though

 

[stevebbb]

It's interesting, as I thought he played quite well in a beaten team the other day. Was getting to stoppages better than early in the season and to my eye was actually trying hard.

Can't remember who, but one of the pundits put it perfectly. He said he looks like the old Oliver, before he learnt to lower his eyes and kick better. Early career Oliver. Still a content and ball winning pig, but just rushing. His kicking the other day was atrocious.

 

[No eye deer]

Can't remember who, but one of the pundits put it perfectly. He said he looks like the old Oliver, before he learnt to lower his eyes and kick better. Early career Oliver. Still a content and ball winning pig, but just rushing. His kicking the other day was atrocious.

That he becomes a Premo again?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

It's interesting, as I thought he played quite well in a beaten team the other day. Was getting to stoppages better than early in the season and to my eye was actually trying hard.

I thought there was a stark difference between 1st half Oliver & 2nd half Oliver ......pity he can't seem to put 4 Qtrs together

 

[dicey7]

Just going for league,
Butters and curnow vs Moore and zerrett

 

[Judd_Magic]

Just going for league,
Butters and curnow vs Moore and zerrett

Moore and Zerrett.

 

[toxic]

Just going for league,
Butters and curnow vs Moore and zerrett

B and C

 

[Lord De Goey]

Sinclair and Gulden

V

Clark and Day

 

[vic_LION]

Sinclair and Gulden

V

Clark and Day

Sinc and Gulden for me

 

[keithrichards]

Sinclair and Gulden

V

Clark and Day

Sinc and Gulden



Gulden vs LDU vs Zerrett for final midfield spot

 

[lids2richo]

Sinc and Gulden



Gulden vs LDU vs Zerrett for final midfield spot

Zerrett

Trade Stewart or McKercher to L. Ryan?

 

[JuddgementDay]

For my last spot -

Serong vs Zorko?

 

[Judd_Magic]

For my last spot -

Serong vs Zorko?

Serong purely based on Zorko being a total flog of the highest order right uncle Jiska ?

 

[Jiska]

Serong purely based on Zorko being a total flog of the highest order right uncle Jiska ?