Trades 2024 Round 3 Trades

[JuddgementDay]

Would appreciate the brains trust opinions on this, one trade done this week will be Terry for Powell but not sure about any others being required and only 3.8 k in the bank. Any thoughts kind kentlemen? Leave it alone now or what? Coffield will probably wait until next week.

View attachment 1941174

Nice team.

Not a pressing need, but Grundy to Xerri for $$$ ITB and same scores

Grundy has to go soon anyway

 

[54Dogs]

Will J Lyons get played again? I don't know, I have too many other problems to deal with. I kinda don't want to get rid of him. Why was he dropped???

Need to offload:
Lazz to... I dunno? Mannah? ......... who is the best forward rookie bubble boy?
SBerry to McKerch or Sharp (who will make most money?)
Gibbcus to Pink or Hore... leaning toward pink ATM. Someone reckoned Hore was best option.
Help please people!!!!

If he does it will most likely be as sub, which he was 7 times last yr

 

[54Dogs]

Lyons dropped to accommodate Neale I reckon

They played together Rd 0

 

[Double the Fist]

Yeah I know. At least he’s not bleeding cash. And is only a late change or injury to a mid from return.

Newcombe and Young are s**t

I don't have enough trades, need a 6 x boost to clear all my trash.. fmd

If he does it will most likely be as sub, which he was 7 times last yr

Oh. Actually sub 7 times. I didn't read that properly earlier. FMD

 

[Double the Fist]

Why do you need to offload Lazz?

He was doing well with high DE (apparently) and got subbed. He has also lost CBAs. Might be worth swapping to Kerch. What are your thougts? I havn't seen any north games.

 

[54Dogs]

Is Carroll a trap

will he play the next 4-6 games out of 10

Will be fine until Walsh returns in 2-3 weeks, then will lose CBAs and become a sub risk again. But has a high ceiling esp this week against Nth

 

[Dougy85]

I'm interested to get some different opinions on what to do next with this side.

Injured rookies in the backline a concern, albeit not this week. The rest all look to have a few weeks worth of cash gen.
Not sold on swapping Coffield to Pink. I have considered Coffield to Carroll via Dawson to NWM but think a big Dawson score is just around the corner.

185k in the bank.

 

[rocker_oz33]

He was doing well with high DE (apparently) and got subbed. He has also lost CBAs. Might be worth swapping to Kerch. What are your thougts? I havn't seen any north games.

Give Las zero another week and see what happens

 

[Double the Fist]

Yeah I know. At least he’s not bleeding cash. And is only a late change or injury to a mid from return.

Newcombe and Young are s**t

Young has had a huge amount of clangers last game. Is he jsut bad at midfield or is he being hurried and not coping with his new mid role?
Or is he just bad. I don't watch a lot of footy and havn't seen him or Freo play yet either.
If Lyons isn't playing and Lazz is named on field, I might have to chop Young.
What do others think? I want to keep him as he is a primo point player back, but if he is really bad, it might be worth culling him to Mass?

This game hurts my brain.

 

[JRyan23]

Ok guys help me. With the Lyons news my plans have been turned upside down. Here are the options

Option 1
OUT:
SBerry
TBerry
Gibcus

IN:
Mass
Sharp
Powell

this was my original plan, would mean I would hold Lyons for a week
22 players for week

or

OUT:
HYoung
Lyons
SBerry

IN:
Mass
Serong
Powell

Means I still have Gibcus Reid at D7/8 and TBerry in forward. This option also gives me 20 this week





Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[54Dogs]

I'm interested to get some different opinions on what to do next with this side.

Injured rookies in the backline a concern, albeit not this week. The rest all look to have a few weeks worth of cash gen.
Not sold on swapping Coffield to Pink. I have considered Coffield to Carroll via Dawson to NWM but think a big Dawson score is just around the corner.

185k in the bank.

View attachment 1941346

Windsor / Laz / Berry > Carrol / Dempsey / Powell

 

[MacStradbroke]

I'm interested to get some different opinions on what to do next with this side.

Injured rookies in the backline a concern, albeit not this week. The rest all look to have a few weeks worth of cash gen.
Not sold on swapping Coffield to Pink. I have considered Coffield to Carroll via Dawson to NWM but think a big Dawson score is just around the corner.

185k in the bank.

View attachment 1941346

Don’t trade a Dawson to NW.
Maybe Lazzaro to Powell.
TBerry to Dempsey (cash gen and fill forwards this week)

 

[JuddgementDay]

Ok guys help me. With the Lyons news my plans have been turned upside down. Here are the options

Option 1
OUT:
SBerry
TBerry
Gibcus

IN:
Mass
Sharp
Powell

this was my original plan, would mean I would hold Lyons for a week
22 players for week

or

OUT:
HYoung
Lyons
SBerry

IN:
Mass
Serong
Powell

Means I still have Gibcus Reid at D7/8 and TBerry in forward. This option also gives me 20 this week





Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

How about

OUT:
Lyons
TBerry
Gibcus

IN:
Mass
Sharp
Powell

 

[rocker_oz33]

I'm interested to get some different opinions on what to do next with this side.

Injured rookies in the backline a concern, albeit not this week. The rest all look to have a few weeks worth of cash gen.
Not sold on swapping Coffield to Pink. I have considered Coffield to Carroll via Dawson to NWM but think a big Dawson score is just around the corner.

185k in the bank.

View attachment 1941346

Coff to Bramble might be a option should score ok make cash ...prob not a keeper ...who knows

 

[JRyan23]

How about

OUT:
Lyons
TBerry
Gibcus

IN:
Mass
Sharp
Powell

If Berry is dropped tho


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[54Dogs]

Hand forced with Lyons, shame about the 60K price bump he would have had, but known risk so fair play.

Green and Darcy next week

 

[rocker_oz33]

If Berry is dropped tho


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Wait on teams section to make the final call ..

 

[Changa10]

Awful pick? Got 95 last week? Is he bad or that Fagan hates him too?

Problem is the 95 wasn’t good enough for Fagan. I was happy with the 95, and thought it might secure him another 3-4 games, so I think it’s more Fagan hates him.

 

[buttox]

I'm interested to get some different opinions on what to do next with this side.

Injured rookies in the backline a concern, albeit not this week. The rest all look to have a few weeks worth of cash gen.
Not sold on swapping Coffield to Pink. I have considered Coffield to Carroll via Dawson to NWM but think a big Dawson score is just around the corner.

185k in the bank.

View attachment 1941346

Berry to Powell.
Move Jordan forward for laz play sanders over laz.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Berry to Powell.
Move Jordan forward for laz play sanders over laz.

Will Zas zero be sub ,?

 

[54Dogs]

Something’s got to change in our midfield as it clearly hasn’t worked the first two rounds. Hopefully it gets Newcombe back to winning some contested footy! I’m holding, but if I wasn’t a Hawks supporter I’d probably ditch him.

Surely HH in this week to change the mix?

 

[buttox]

Will Zas zero be sub ,?

I was surprised he was last week.
I actually think he will be dropped for Phillips. He had a good VFL game

 

[54Dogs]

I was surprised he was last week.
I actually think he will be dropped for Phillips. He had a good VFL game

If Phillips comes in that is horrendous news for Powell and I would not trade Powell in. As it is I have Powell as number 1 target.

 

[Changa10]

Surely HH in this week to change the mix?

For the Hawks sake, and mine, I certainly hope so. Really like the look of HH. For SC purposes, he could wait a week or two yet and let the mid rookies moo

 

[buttox]

If Phillips comes in that is horrendous news for Powell and I would not trade Powell in. As it is I have Powell as number 1 target.

Makes no difference to Powell.
Simpkin going down moved Powell to hff to cover Simpkin. Simpkins back as is ford no need for him to move. Phillips would take lazs minutes. Powell has been a first choice mid all preseason