Game Day 2024 Trade Period - Lian Yu - that liminal space between trade and draft.

[freo1997]

Kane on the footy furnace - very strong that Freo should not pay more than 10 & 18.

• his house in Carnegie is already on the market
• he’s absolutely not going back to richmond
• just sit and wait, for Richmond to accept out already generous offer of 10 & 18
• highlights some stats showing how Bolton really checked out in 2024 compared to 2023

Damo Barrett reckoned 10 & 30 was enough!

Remember Caroline Wilson laughing at the thought of Bolton being two 1st rounders.

10 and 18 is very fair. Probs too fair but I feel we’ll add a future 3rd on top too.

 

[Purple Suit]

Sell half the farm?
Oh...we have to take the Baker too?
OK.

We got 3/4 of a farm from Shultz so I don’t see what the big deal is.

 

[Madas]

It works doesnt it.
Thousands of Bf tragics like us thrashing the servers subliminally absorbing the ads for an extra week...
Time to chill if we can.
"worrying wont change a thing"
I tell myself....

What ads ?

 

[Superkoops]

I always like to value the player independent of other components in these type of deals.
Thats what any half-competent list management team would be doing in this instance.

So what’s Noble worth as a stand alone pick?
I’d say pick 40 in this current, deeper than normal draft, is a reasonable price.
For example, would you be happy of John Noble was selected with a pick inside 40 in this draft by our club, which is in a similar position to Gold Coast in terms of list profile and flag window?

I wouldn’t.

Pick 23 is egregious (what Collingwood seem to be valuing him at).

Pick 13 & 23 in exchange for the Pies F1 and pick 40 (my nominal value for Noble) is a terrible trade, for the suns.

I think Noble is worth a little more than 40. I’d have him around pick 33-37. Where you pick him in the draft is irrelevant and it is especially irrelevant for Freo and myself. Gold Coast obviously will pay a higher price (as they want him as their starting HBF) and I feel they prob would pick him around 29 which by the time that selection is used with be around pick 35.

35,F1 > 13,29

I agree 23 is too high. I also agree that 29 is pushing it but their next pick is 41 which won’t get the deal done. Therefore pick 29 gets the deal done. Gold Coast want a Future pick. Collingwood may well rise but other than Houston what is changing there. Nothing much. They still have an average KPF group. Therefore say they finish say 6th or lower and that future pick isn’t any worse and may be better than 13.

 

[Hammersoup]

We just wait as it looks like we have nothing else on. Bolton for 10-18 is more than fair and is our goal. 11 should be off the table unless they kick in significant late 1st picks or pay. We can always take 10-18 to the draft and trade out 11 on draft night. Nths 1st may be up for grabs and likely get F3 thrown in for academy points.

 

[Ge3ks]

How to block ads if you use an android phone or tablet;
Go to Settings/Connections/More Connection Settings/PrivateDNS
Select Private DNS Hostname and type in dns.adguard.com
Hit save and you are done. No more ads on Big Footy.
You're welcome.

 

[kp junior]

Kevin Sheehan calling as a top 3 draft of the last 20 years.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Heave Ho Bro]

Kane on the footy furnace - very strong that Freo should not pay more than 10 & 18.

• his house in Carnegie is already on the market
• he’s absolutely not going back to richmond
• just sit and wait, for Richmond to accept out already generous offer of 10 & 18
• highlights some stats showing how Bolton really checked out in 2024 compared to 2023

Damo Barrett reckoned 10 & 30 was enough!

10 is being seriously undervalued and the Tigers supporters are delusional about what they should be getting from all these trades. 10 and 18 is more than fair. Win win for all parties.

 

[Heave Ho Bro]

Remember Caroline Wilson laughing at the thought of Bolton being two 1st rounders.

10 and 18 is very fair. Probs too fair but I feel we’ll add a future 3rd on top too.

Can live with a 3rd chucked in but we keep 11 no matter what.

 

[Moo]

Footage of Walls

 

[freo1997]

Can live with a 3rd chucked in but we keep 11 no matter what.

Yeah 11 is for Baker

Hoping for Berry!

 

[Heave Ho Bro]

Footage of Walls

This is why it hasn't happened yet. The man can't fit them through the door to get in to the building.

 

[freo_leo29]

No late leaks on a Sunday breakthrough from Bolton

My Monday prediction is getting shaky

 

[Dockernut]

Reckon we absolutely must hold on to 11 to secure Bo Allan. I know I’ve previously spruiked going for Alix Tauru, but seriously Allan is a player! He has all the speed, x-factor and athleticism we want, is a good size and also has some much needed mongrel. There’s one tackle he lays on Jai “shit-truck” Culley in the WAFL game v WCE and absolutely destroys him. I’m all in on Allan.

 

[s_wd6]

No late leaks on a Sunday breakthrough from Bolton

My Monday prediction is getting shaky

To be fair we've had like no leaks throughout this whole thing. Every day it's "Fremantle believed to have offered 10 & 18. Richmond believed to want 10 & 11." Even the recent "leaks" about all three for Baker and Bolton came out well before Baker even nominated WC.

 

[freo_leo29]

To be fair we've had like no leaks throughout this whole thing. Every day it's "Fremantle believed to have offered 10 & 18. Richmond believed to want 10 & 11." Even the recent "leaks" about all three for Baker and Bolton came out well before Baker even nominated WC.

I'm basing my prediction off previous years, whole reason I picked the Monday after the weekend to begin with (lots of people on here were thinking it was almost done before the period started)

 

[freodog]

I haven't watched any Draft videos but all this talk of Berry I had to have a look. Is it just me or does he remind you of Jayden Pitt

Jayden Pitt

Age

32

Ht

188cm

Wt

83kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

10.5

3star

K

7.5

3star

HB

3.0

3star

M

2.6

3star

T

1.0

3star

No current season stats available

D

13.6

4star

K

10.2

4star

HB

3.4

3star

M

3.0

3star

T

1.0

3star

?

 

[freo1997]

Would Carlton be dumb enough to give us 12 & 14 for 10 (they get a more competitive pick for Houston) and we give pick 30 + a later.

We then hold 11, 12, 14 and 18.

 

[Purple Suit]

Reckon we absolutely must hold on to 11 to secure Bo Allan. I know I’ve previously spruiked going for Alix Tauru, but seriously Allan is a player! He has all the speed, x-factor and athleticism we want, is a good size and also has some much needed mongrel. There’s one tackle he lays on Jai “shit-truck” Culley in the WAFL game v WCE and absolutely destroys him. I’m all in on Allan.

Why though? He has no spot in the team. It would be similar to a gun key defender or KPF being available.

We need to plug holes, not get best available for once.

 

[Superkoops]

Would Carlton be dumb enough to give us 12 & 14 for 10 (they get a more competitive pick for Houston) and we give pick 30 + a later.

We then hold 11, 12, 14 and 18.

Carlton are only interested in trading right up the draft order for Finn O’Sullivan. Moving up to 10 will not achieve that desired result.

 

[freo_leo29]

Would love to get our hands on 28 from the bombers (when they get it) with maybe our F2 and 66, they probs need more though

If they actually get 28 and 40 from Dees then they will have enough to match Kako (especially after Stringer)

 

[DocT]

Got to be the first time I've ever agreed with Kane

I agree with Damo, 10 and 30 is fair.

 

[theGav56]

I reckon Smith will go down to wire. Cal Twomey has predicted that and I reckon he is spot on. WB want top 10 pick and Geelong are offering only 17. So quite a gap there.

Knee issues and a lack of recent games. There is risk involved, but 17 seems bargain basement

 

[Dockernut]

Why though? He has no spot in the team. It would be similar to a gun key defender or KPF being available.

We need to plug holes, not get best available for once.

I don’t know - I watched that Port game where our season was on the line and saw JHF jog it out of the guts with little or no resistance from our mids, Fyfe being the key contributor to that lack of defensive pressure. Sorry to say it, but Fyfe also let us down on the inside. When I look at Allan’s defensive presence as an 18 year old as well as a clear inside-to-outside transition game I think maybe he would have a spot.

Naturally that assumes the Coach / match committee decides to prioritise winning over historical performance.

 

[The Feeder Club]

I agree with Damo, 10 and 30 is fair.

It doesn't matter if Dumbo Damo thinks it's fair. Or any else for that matter. If, as is almost universally believed, we've already put 10 and 18 on the table as our opening offer you can forget 10 and 30.
That's why i still believe, as I said on day 1, it most likely will be 10 and 11 with something in the 20s coming back. Once 10 and 18 was on the table as the opening bid, it was only going in one direction from there