List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread - No.2

[RWB4life]

Into the ket?

I always assumed that's what it meant.

 

[Minga]

Not all good teams are built with ‘big fish’ - look at what Hawthorn have done with Scrimshaw, Ginnivan, Chol, Meek, Amon, Impey etc.

They’ve done nothing and no reason to believe they’re any better than we were in 2020.

Geelong a better example for mine, they have some big fish yes, but a hell of a lot of role players.

 

[70s sainter]

Didn’t see peatling do anything much in the last 3 q to write home about .

 

[Plugger35]

We are still a chance to land a big fish.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

We are still a chance to land a big fish.

As long as that fish isn't a "trout".

 

[The_Steadier]

Word on the street is a big name player is going to nominate us as his club of choice in the coming days

Welcome to the club
Robert DiPierdomenico!

20 letters is a big name

 

[TheJackal]

I made the mistake of listening to 3AW for a bit today as SEN was talking horses... anyway the topic of Macrae's potential suitors came up.

I can't remember everything but North was the one everyone thought would be a good fit, followed by Geelong.

Eventually the got to St Kilda but said that why would we want him when we just got rid of Seb Ross. That was pretty much it. I can't remember if it was that segment or not but I remember someone saying something like, who doesn't St Kilda chase?

Surely anyone with any knowledge would know that Crouch may never play again. Seb, whilst he was a loyal servant during a period where we were terrible, he well he fell off a cliff and was never in the same category as Macrae.

Realistically, I couldn't think of a list who needed a player like Macrae any mire than ours. We have Steele then a massive gap. In the midfield we have some promising kids, a few injury prone players with ok experience, then nothing. Where's the Crouch replacement? The bloke who can win a clearance and accumulate disposals at will?

I know media can be lazy, but I really can't imagine a better landing spot for Macrae than Moorabbin.

 

[Plugger35]

As long as that fish isn't a "trout".

He's past his use by date but he would give us great leadership in our rehab group which has been lacking since Hanners retired,

 

[HillToKing]

Word on the street is a big name player is going to nominate us as his club of choice in the coming days

Josh Kelly is finally happening.

 

[St Neil]

So basically the pick GWS gave us for sliding back one spot last year, I'm okay with that. If we can convince them to make it a future, even better.

We can’t give GWS the pick they traded to us. The AFL will block that trade.

A club cannot trade back a pick they have previously traded-out.

 

[SG34]

I made the mistake of listening to 3AW for a bit today as SEN was talking horses... anyway the topic of Macrae's potential suitors came up.

I can't remember everything but North was the one everyone thought would be a good fit, followed by Geelong.

Eventually the got to St Kilda but said that why would we want him when we just got rid of Seb Ross. That was pretty much it. I can't remember if it was that segment or not but I remember someone saying something like, who doesn't St Kilda chase?

Surely anyone with any knowledge would know that Crouch may never play again. Seb, whilst he was a loyal servant during a period where we were terrible, he well he fell off a cliff and was never in the same category as Macrae.

Realistically, I couldn't think of a list who needed a player like Macrae any mire than ours. We have Steele then a massive gap. In the midfield we have some promising kids, a few injury prone players with ok experience, then nothing. Where's the Crouch replacement? The bloke who can win a clearance and accumulate disposals at will?

I know media can be lazy, but I really can't imagine a better landing spot for Macrae than Moorabbin.

Yeah, that is not a very nuanced observation by the 3AW lot. Just because Seb doesn’t get a gig, doesn’t mean we wouldn’t be desperate for some decent mids. Sounds lazy.

 

[akaifu]

We can’t give GWS the pick they traded to us. The AFL will block that trade.

A club cannot trade back a pick they have previously traded-out.

I'm pretty sure you can, as long as its not in the same year. Could be wrong though

 

[akaifu]

I made the mistake of listening to 3AW for a bit today as SEN was talking horses... anyway the topic of Macrae's potential suitors came up.

I can't remember everything but North was the one everyone thought would be a good fit, followed by Geelong.

Eventually the got to St Kilda but said that why would we want him when we just got rid of Seb Ross. That was pretty much it. I can't remember if it was that segment or not but I remember someone saying something like, who doesn't St Kilda chase?

Surely anyone with any knowledge would know that Crouch may never play again. Seb, whilst he was a loyal servant during a period where we were terrible, he well he fell off a cliff and was never in the same category as Macrae.

Realistically, I couldn't think of a list who needed a player like Macrae any mire than ours. We have Steele then a massive gap. In the midfield we have some promising kids, a few injury prone players with ok experience, then nothing. Where's the Crouch replacement? The bloke who can win a clearance and accumulate disposals at will?

I know media can be lazy, but I really can't imagine a better landing spot for Macrae than Moorabbin.

Any analyst/journo/media 'expert' that's not from AFL Media/Fox Footy/SEN is utterly clueless. No one listens to them so they have zero accountability for making uninformed assumptions

We are the front-runners for Macrae. Geelong shouldn't even be in the conversation, they've ruled themselves out. North are only interested if Parker doesn't arrive

 

[malevu]

Riley Garcia and Owies, not exactly the big fish we are after, I would probably throw both of them back into the sea.

More like frozen fillets

 

[snails13]

We can’t give GWS the pick they traded to us. The AFL will block that trade.

A club cannot trade back a pick they have previously traded-out.

GWS received that pick from Adelaide

 

[Geezington]

??

sorry mate I’ve got no idea

 

[Geezington]

You know trade season is close when Choomah comes back dropping bombs like this.

Were finally getting spud burrito as a replacement for Josh battle

 

[BrutThough]

I made the mistake of listening to 3AW for a bit today as SEN was talking horses... anyway the topic of Macrae's potential suitors came up.

I can't remember everything but North was the one everyone thought would be a good fit, followed by Geelong.

Eventually the got to St Kilda but said that why would we want him when we just got rid of Seb Ross. That was pretty much it. I can't remember if it was that segment or not but I remember someone saying something like, who doesn't St Kilda chase?

Surely anyone with any knowledge would know that Crouch may never play again. Seb, whilst he was a loyal servant during a period where we were terrible, he well he fell off a cliff and was never in the same category as Macrae.

Realistically, I couldn't think of a list who needed a player like Macrae any mire than ours. We have Steele then a massive gap. In the midfield we have some promising kids, a few injury prone players with ok experience, then nothing. Where's the Crouch replacement? The bloke who can win a clearance and accumulate disposals at will?

I know media can be lazy, but I really can't imagine a better landing spot for Macrae than Moorabbin.

Would loved to have called up and asked them to name our 2nd best midfielder.

That simple exercise is all thats needed to explain why we are chasing Macrae.

 

[Coconut_twirl]

Didn’t see peatling do anything much in the last 3 q to write home about .

Spot on. Good player, but don’t overpay for him.

 

[seasonedsainter]

No Giants players thanks. All mentatally broken.

 

[pebblesofsand]

Did you watch the game?

Peatling got 2 kicks for two goals in the first qtr and after that had a total of 8 possessions for the rest of the game.

After the first qtr he didn't do much when he was in the midfield and Zorko then torched him when he went forward.

Anyway it doesn't matter - he'll be staying at GWS.

 

[snails13]

No Giants players thanks. All mentatally broken.

Have you checked our history

 

[Hayes4PM]

Geez Monty is such a good commentator. Always quality insights....the polar opposite of Jordan Lewis

Ahhhh yes but, Jordan Lewis puts on those horn-rimmed glasses and smiles smugly.

 

[SG34]

I am assuming if the GWS coaching staff and the players themselves, could not arrest that slide last night, particularly given what had happened the previous week, then few of us mortals would have a clue. I’m just gonna say bad luck. It was a case of bad luck and every conceivable dice roll went Brisbane’s way. Is there any other way to see it?

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

Rors

Rors has great contacts in Sin City (especially out West)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk