Player Watch #29: Will Phillips - tags N.Daicos vs Collingwood - subbed off at 3/4 time??

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Will also copped a 1 week suspension as part of the fallout from the whole Jimmy Webster situation. Just shows he really becoming a real AFL player.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

This for me is the biggest takeaway from the game. St Kilda took away what had been our advantage v the pies, our inside game. Highlighted by Clarko also. We need to work out how to beat that quickly.
One thing I thought during the game and since is simply get front position at bounces. Take the spot you want at bounces, hold it and force the other sides mids to stand behind you wherever possible. (Unless you have a thing going where X belts it beyond the clearance.)
 
Phillips regardless of how he ends up was the right choice.
The 2020 draft will go down as the worst in history. Covid ****ed it for that year.

Logan McDonald makes CCJ look like prime Paul Salmon.
Ridiculously shit
 
Phillips regardless of how he ends up was the right choice.
The 2020 draft will go down as the worst in history. Covid ****ed it for that year.

Logan McDonald makes CCJ look like prime Paul Salmon.
Ridiculously s**t
And they’ll rip off one of the wa teams in a trade this year
 
Phillips regardless of how he ends up was the right choice.
The 2020 draft will go down as the worst in history. Covid ****ed it for that year.

Logan McDonald makes CCJ look like prime Paul Salmon.
Ridiculously s**t
Just on this. We did well. Phillips, Powell and Laz may not end up being AFL players, or they may. We’ll find out soon enough.
They’ve shown glimpses here and there.

Hollands we were keen on all year has a coke charge hanging over him and has been traded to Carlton.
McDonald is going to be sent back to Perth and IMO will be out of the league by 2026.

Let’s just work with what we have.
I mean looking at the names in the draft, I am going to make the bold prediction and say none will ever be All Australian.

So let’s set our sights on finding a role player instead of deadset guns in our lot.

The draft is horrible. Absolutely horrible.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Just on this. We did well. Phillips, Powell and Laz may not end up being AFL players, or they may. We’ll find out soon enough.
They’ve shown glimpses here and there.

Hollands we were keen on all year has a coke charge hanging over him and has been traded to Carlton.
McDonald is going to be sent back to Perth and IMO will be out of the league by 2026.

Let’s just work with what we have.
I mean looking at the names in the draft, I am going to make the bold prediction and say none will ever be All Australian.

So let’s set our sights on finding a role player instead of deadset guns in our lot.

The draft is horrible. Absolutely horrible.
Errol has been AA.

But he’s academy, so **** him.
 
Reckon you're forgetting someone with this comment

Errol has been AA.

But he’s academy, so * him.
Yeh deliberately left out the Swans academy selections and glossed over those. Just referencing the open draft. They got Campbell and Gulden out of it and its total bullshit as they both are gonna be there for 10 plus years.
The rest of it is literal dogshit
 
Yeh deliberately left out the Swans academy selections and am referencing the open draft. They got Campbell and Gulden out of it and its total bullshit.
But it’s totally unfair that they’ve only had 42 years to gain any traction in that state. 30 of them as the only team there.

It’s absolute AIDS.
 
Just on this. We did well. Phillips, Powell and Laz may not end up being AFL players, or they may. We’ll find out soon enough.
They’ve shown glimpses here and there.

Hollands we were keen on all year has a coke charge hanging over him and has been traded to Carlton.
McDonald is going to be sent back to Perth and IMO will be out of the league by 2026.

Let’s just work with what we have.
I mean looking at the names in the draft, I am going to make the bold prediction and say none will ever be All Australian.

So let’s set our sights on finding a role player instead of deadset guns in our lot.

The draft is horrible. Absolutely horrible.
Eddie Ford was a good pickup I reckon
 
Eddie Ford was a good pickup I reckon
****ing oath he was. At pick 56 too. He was the 4th last player drafted.

I’m looking more closely at the first 2 rounds.

Here’s the 1st round selections at other clubs after our first pick that we had access to:

Logan McDonald
Denver Granger-Barrass
Elijah Hollands
Nick Cox
Archie Perkins
Zac Reid
Luke Pedlar
Tanner Bruhn
Heath Chapman
Connor Stone
Oliver Henry
Ryan Angwin
Finlay McRae
Max Holmes
Jake Bowey
Bailey Laurie
Brayden Cook
Matthew McLeod-Allison

Would you trade one of Phillips or Powell either now or in two years time for a player on that list?
The only ones that look good, are the ones who have been playing in top 4 sides.
That’s Henry and Holmes and Bowey.
Pedlar has shown signs as well.

The rest is underwhelming.
I’ll be keen to revisit this draft again this time next year.
 
The Sydney annual concessions just keep on giving.

The fact they got Gould and Campbell means that the drafting (and now likely loss) of McDonald means zilch to them.
And how painful was it seeing our rightful father-son Blakey, dominating for Sydney last night, when a week ago, we had to sack our academy player - TT, and we get nothing for many years of investment.

Probably, another player who will get to Sydney for free and turn his life around and will be a star. And it will be so good for the game.....

GET STUFFED !
 
And how painful was it seeing our rightful father-son Blakey, dominating for Sydney last night, when a week ago, we had to sack our academy player - TT, and we get nothing for many years of investment.

Probably, another player who will get to Sydney for free and turn his life around and will be a star. And it will be so good for the game.....

GET STUFFED !
To be fair mate Melbourne were dreadful.

He won't get that sort of freedom against a side half switched on.
 
******* oath he was. At pick 56 too. He was the 4th last player drafted.

I’m looking more closely at the first 2 rounds.

Here’s the 1st round selections at other clubs after our first pick that we had access to:

Logan McDonald
Denver Granger-Barrass
Elijah Hollands
Nick Cox
Archie Perkins
Zac Reid
Luke Pedlar
Tanner Bruhn
Heath Chapman
Connor Stone
Oliver Henry
Ryan Angwin
Finlay McRae
Max Holmes
Jake Bowey
Bailey Laurie
Brayden Cook
Matthew McLeod-Allison

Would you trade one of Phillips or Powell either now or in two years time for a player on that list?
The only ones that look good, are the ones who have been playing in top 4 sides.
That’s Henry and Holmes and Bowey.
Pedlar has shown signs as well.

The rest is underwhelming.
I’ll be keen to revisit this draft again this time next year.
I’d trade for Holmes in a heartbeat
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top