3rd ODI Australia v Pakistan, November 10 1400hrs @ Perth Stadium

Who will win?


  • Total voters
    6
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

$ is also why India's blatant dissent with the umpire was swept under the carpet the other day. Integrity came a distant second.
Ishan Kishan will get disciplined by the BCCI, but now is not the time.

Also, if you read what happened, there were extra marks on the ball, whilst it was in possession with the Australian umpires. If this happened in elsewhere in the world, I reckon you'd be putting the blame straight on the umpires.
 
so if you're giving ratings out of 10 to the Australian players for the series, does anyone warrant a 5+? (maybe Morris based on his 1 game?)
Smith and Inglis with the bat in the first two games
 
Didn't care much about the ODI series and will not care about the T20s. Will lose that comfortably as well.

Yes, it's candy cricket until we play the real stuff, but still, the guys have a national uniform on and we're entitles to expect better.

There seems to be little pride amongst the players for representing their country, even if it is lolly cricket.

Our team used to play with fierce pride and skill once. Atm it seems to just be going through the motions.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Ishan Kishan will get disciplined by the BCCI, but now is not the time.

Also, if you read what happened, there were extra marks on the ball, whilst it was in possession with the Australian umpires. If this happened in elsewhere in the world, I reckon you'd be putting the blame straight on the umpires.

The BCCI will do nothing.

They're holding world cricket to ransom because everyone is scared to upset them.

If any other player for any other national side called an umpire 'stupid' and displayed the clear dissent shown by Kishan they'd be sent home. But CA didn't want to upset the BCCI on the cusp of India's tour ($$$) so they swept the matter under the rug.
 
Before responding I'll preface by saying, at least in Australia, the batting is way down There's no doubt it's harder- but that's not an excuse entirely, I still think the batting talent is lower than previous generations. It's just exacerbated now that batting is harder so it's more glaringly exposed when it's not up to standard.
Has zero to do with talent - talent has never been and is not the problem - neither are the other factors you listed are anyway near the main reason our batting had declined
 
$ rules world cricket.

$ says T20 and the IPL is king. They are far more lucrative than Test cricket. Players are bought for millions and play for their financial retirement.

$ is also why India's blatant dissent with the umpire was swept under the carpet the other day. Integrity came a distant second.
Yes but nobody cares outcomes limited over cricket
There will be another game next week
It's all meaningless

Only Test cricket carries any significance these days
Players probably feel same
 
The BCCI will do nothing.

They're holding world cricket to ransom because everyone is scared to upset them.

If any other player for any other national side called an umpire 'stupid' and displayed the clear dissent shown by Kishan they'd be sent home. But CA didn't want to upset the BCCI on the cusp of India's tour ($$$) so they swept the matter under the rug.

A year ago David Warner was given out by his good friend Joel Wilson and reviewed it in Sri Lanka. He not only demanded an explanation from Wilson as to why he was given out while he waited for the DRS review to happen, when it confirmed the decision, he walked off and gave him a gobful on his way.

He wasn’t sent home. Now this isn’t calling an umpire stupid, I understand that, but dissent etc is not the sacred cow that it used to be where if you breach it, you are automatically ostracised. So it’s not just being Indian that helps you get out of trouble, much as it probably doesn’t hurt.
 
Yes but nobody cares outcomes limited over cricket
There will be another game next week
It's all meaningless

Only Test cricket carries any significance these days
Players probably feel same

I'd agree re: cricket purists.

But many these days want instant entertainment, and hence the flourish of T20, of which the IPL is king.

It's a massive money spinner.

Money equals influence and power.

Anyhoo, it is what it is I guess.
 
The BCCI will do nothing.

They're holding world cricket to ransom because everyone is scared to upset them.

If any other player for any other national side called an umpire 'stupid' and displayed the clear dissent shown by Kishan they'd be sent home. But CA didn't want to upset the BCCI on the cusp of India's tour ($$$) so they swept the matter under the rug.
Kishan has already been warned by the BCCI for the lack of Ranji Trophy that he has recently played, and as a result has lost his central contract with the BCCI. So, I'd expect the BCCI to caution him on this as well.

As for CA not wanting to discipline Kishan, yeah you could say that CA are scared of the BCCI. Even though I am an Indian supporter, I still don't like the way BCCI bully others boards like this
 
A year ago David Warner was given out by his good friend Joel Wilson and reviewed it in Sri Lanka. He not only demanded an explanation from Wilson as to why he was given out while he waited for the DRS review to happen, when it confirmed the decision, he walked off and gave him a gobful on his way.

He wasn’t sent home. Now this isn’t calling an umpire stupid, I understand that, but dissent etc is not the sacred cow that it used to be where if you breach it, you are automatically ostracised. So it’s not just being Indian that helps you get out of trouble, much as it probably doesn’t hurt.

Didn't see that incident, and happily agree he should've been sent home.

And I'd far rather have the BCCI behind me than the CA in such a matter.

No-one defies the BCCI.
 
Good to see Johnson and Morris having a crack.....same old same old with Stoinis doing his familiar Tarzan/Jane act, Maxi and his Big Show/No show act, and the Aust top 6 batting as though it is a 20 over match, with George and Ronald....blissfully unaware in the background
 

Remove this Banner Ad

3rd ODI Australia v Pakistan, November 10 1400hrs @ Perth Stadium

Back
Top