Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Laverde says hiThis guy may legitimately be the worst player on our list
Laverde says hi
Zac ClarkeWould have to be up their with worst player this decade getting games on our list
Mate, I think he had 9 awful disposals in the first half and 5 better disposals in the second half. His only genuinely telling disposal was when he kicked to Stringer’s advantage in the third. ‘Much’ better is not how I’d describe his second half but I suppose it’s all relative to how bad his first half was I guess.First half was really bad. Second half was much better.
Mate, he had two GA and a third SI in the second half. First half was terrible. Nobody disagrees. Second half was okay to good.Mate, I think he had 9 awful disposals in the first half and 5 better disposals in the second half. His only genuinely telling disposal was when he kicked to Stringer’s advantage in the third. ‘Much’ better is not how I’d describe his second half but I suppose it’s all relative to how bad his first half was I guess.
Hobbs for me. Tell him his job is to pressure, chase and tackle from half forward.Hind in for this bloke surely
On the spectrum of gun or spud we all know which end he’s occupying right now. I’m sorry Eth but I’ve had enough of his mediocre performances. I’ve never had a whipping boy before, but Menzie is obviously one now. How long do you back your boys in despite weekly below par performances. He has ability and he will do good things at times like goal assists but that shouldn’t gloss over the fact that he has had very very little impact this year.Mate, he had two GA and a third SI in the second half. First half was terrible. Nobody disagrees. Second half was okay to good.
I forget that on Bigfooty you're either a gun or a spud though![]()
Agree, Simply not good enough. A moment here and there doesn’t make a player.On the spectrum of gun or spud we all know which end he’s occupying right now. I’m sorry Eth but I’ve had enough of his mediocre performances. I’ve never had a whipping boy before, but Menzie is obviously one now. How long do you back your boys in despite weekly below par performances. He has ability and he will do good things at times like goal assists but that shouldn’t gloss over the fact that he has had very very little impact this year.
Nah **** off. I fully acknowledge his first half was terrible. The fact that you turn around and can't acknowledge his second half was at the very least was okay to good says plenty.On the spectrum of gun or spud we all know which end he’s occupying right now. I’m sorry Eth but I’ve had enough of his mediocre performances. I’ve never had a whipping boy before, but Menzie is obviously one now. How long do you back your boys in despite weekly below par performances. He has ability and he will do good things at times like goal assists but that shouldn’t gloss over the fact that he has had very very little impact this year.
Hobbs for me. Tell him his job is to pressure, chase and tackle from half forward.
He's played forward as well. We have a lot of inside mids that play a 2nd position. Its almost a requirement to be successful at AFL levelHobbs is an inside mid. There’s a reason why they are giving him an extended run in the magoos.
Eth, his - in your words - 'much better' second half was 5 disposals, 2 tackles and 3 total score involvements (not 3 involvements in the 3rd Q).Nah **** off. I fully acknowledge his first half was terrible. The fact that you turn around and can't acknowledge his second half was at the very least was okay to good says plenty.
No in between. His first half was very bad. His second half okay to good. Overall it was a bad day but it's honestly a bit pathetic that nobody can acknowledge the second half. I guess the "play the kids" mantra applies to all the kids apart from him.
I never said 3 GA. I said 2 with 1 other SI. His second half was okay to good.Eth, his - in your words - 'much better' second half was 5 disposals, 2 tackles and 3 total score involvements (not 3 assists in the 3rd Q).
Not really worth writing home about.
Played Archie Perkins role with less production than Archie. 0 goals, 6 inside 50's. Weird sort of game