Traded Adam Cerra traded to Carlton for pick #6 and F3

[Morro]

If he goes to Richmond, it will be two first rounders. Simple as that.

no

 

[Purple_Turtle]

no

If it's about the go home factor you're competing with about 8 or 9 clubs. I imagine that'll be enough to push the price up.

 

[Morro]

If it's about the go home factor you're competing with about 8 or 9 clubs. I imagine that'll be enough to push the price up.

People say that, but 99% of the time a player selects one club and these auctions and price drives just simply dont exist. It sounds great in theory but just doesnt happen.

 

[tiger_tough]

If it's about the go home factor you're competing with about 8 or 9 clubs. I imagine that'll be enough to push the price up.

8 or 9? Cats? No. Dees? No. Dogs? No. Pies? Don't have any picks and need to find some for Daicos, No. Doubt he'd go to Hawks or North. Saints need to hit the draft badly.

That leaves Tigers, Blues and Essendon. Blues and Essendon will obviously have more cash to offer while we have better picks comfortably. Plus you can rule out a fair trade coming from Dodoro....

 

[THE_GUN]

we may.. we may not.
One thing for sure, is that if he chooses to go home, all 10 clubs will make offers.
Who ever he chooses will get it done. Teams won’t let a guy like Cerra get away, even if it means paying a touch over.

people worry about the draft picks too much. I’ll take a known commodity like Cerra based on his output and his age any day over a speculative top 5 pick.

obviously you get your sure things like Rowell, but they are rare.

Why would they pay ' A touch over'

As you said Cerra makes his choice and doesnt really matter if there is 1 club or 10
Freo & the club of choice deal and get it done

Out of contract and wanting home freo really just take what they are given and will be fair trade but wont be top 5 -6 pick like trade
He is 'nice' player but he is not chris judd buddy franklin dustin martin. pick value roughly #10-#12 is about the best freo will get

He is a nice player and i really hope he stays at freo for another 3-4 years , Not a priority for Richmond in 2022

 

[Rich01]

What would be a fair price to pay (non-tigers and dockers fans)?

We have 2 firsts this year (Richmond and Geelong), two seconds (St Kilda and Richmond) and two thirds (Gold Coast and Richmond).

I’d be happy to start with offering our two firsts and our third. Perhaps a final offer of two firsts and Gold Coasts third.

This would probably see them end up with 2 picks around 13-18, and one around 40.

Seems like a lot for one player and would set Freo up for the future if they like this draft but Cerra is a good one and if he keeps improving, will be worth it.

 

[Freoforever86]

Why would they pay ' A touch over'

As you said Cerra makes his choice and doesnt really matter if there is 1 club or 10
Freo & the club of choice deal and get it done

Out of contract and wanting home freo really just take what they are given and will be fair trade but wont be top 5 -6 pick like trade
He is 'nice' player but he is not chris judd buddy franklin dustin martin. pick value roughly #10-#12 is about the best freo will get

He is a nice player and i really hope he stays at freo for another 3-4 years , Not a priority for Richmond in 2022

because in a stalemate someone has to give, and I guarantee it’s the team who wants the player. Generally if a talent like Cerra wants in, you get it done. Teams don’t tend to try hold others over a barrel, these things bite teams in the ass. Future trades and other teams will notice.

Richmonds 2 firsts plus maybe a 2nd back would be about right.

 

[Freoforever86]

What would be a fair price to pay (non-tigers and dockers fans)?

We have 2 firsts this year (Richmond and Geelong), two seconds (St Kilda and Richmond) and two thirds (Gold Coast and Richmond).

I’d be happy to start with offering our two firsts and our third. Perhaps a final offer of two firsts and Gold Coasts third.

This would probably see them end up with 2 picks around 13-18, and one around 40.

Seems like a lot for one player and would set Freo up for the future if they like this draft but Cerra is a good one and if he keeps improving, will be worth it.

2 firsts probably gets it done tbh. Around that mark of what you said above.

would rather keep him, but yeah.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Love how a former pick 5 with 4 years development is worth a token pick in the teens to some Richmond supporters. Finished 3rd in our BNF ahead of Brayshaw last season, has proven to be an elite user of the ball and is versatile enough to play Back, Mid or forward. Not a chance anyone will get him for a single first rounder in the teens.

 

[THE_GUN]

because in a stalemate someone has to give, and I guarantee it’s the team who wants the player. Generally if a talent like Cerra wants in, you get it done. Teams don’t tend to try hold others over a barrel, these things bite teams in the ass. Future trades and other teams will notice.

Richmonds 2 firsts plus maybe a 2nd back would be about right.

Dreaming , I would say our earlier 1st and possibly St Kilda's 2nd which looks like #23-#25

Richmond will be looking at getting 1 of the west australian tall fowards JVR/Williams/Bazo

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Dreaming

I'm yet to see you have an unbiased Richmond take on anything.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Dreaming

Yeah, there would be no 2nd back.

 

[THE_GUN]

Yeah, there would be no 2nd back.

Because the 2 x 1st are not happening
keep Cerra he is no Judd mate

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Because the 2 x 1st are not happening
keep Cerra he is no Judd mate

Picks 1 and 2 = 2 x first rounders
Picks 12 and 17 = 2 x first rounders.

There's a massive difference between the two.

 

[THE_GUN]

Picks 1 and 2 = 2 x first rounders
Picks 12 and 17 = 2 x first rounders.

There's a massive difference between the two.

Thanks for that as i thought they were exactly the same

Now lets look at his value , and to be he is a Pick #10-#12 value player
As i said i hope he stays and we stay away if he is leaving

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Because the 2 x 1st are not happening
keep Cerra he is no Judd mate

What do you honestly see his value as, for perspective, you've seen neutrals say him and Bolton are close to worth the same in value. Would you let Bolton go for pick 12?

With their age and output, both are worth a pick around 5, both are young stars. Richmond nuffies will say Bolton is worth more, Freo nuffies will say Cerra.

I shit you not, if Cerra does go to Richmond, and Bell doesnt get at least your two first picks this year (which are picks in the teens), I will find Bell, I will kick him in the nuts and will never give Freo another dime until they kick Bell out.

Edit: He is absolutely not a pick 10-12 player

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

What would be a fair price to pay (non-tigers and dockers fans)?

We have 2 firsts this year (Richmond and Geelong), two seconds (St Kilda and Richmond) and two thirds (Gold Coast and Richmond).

I’d be happy to start with offering our two firsts and our third. Perhaps a final offer of two firsts and Gold Coasts third.

This would probably see them end up with 2 picks around 13-18, and one around 40.

Seems like a lot for one player and would set Freo up for the future if they like this draft but Cerra is a good one and if he keeps improving, will be worth it.

Not found

Player not found

I’m presuming that the two firsts are going to be late and only a few picks off being seconds so I’ll say two firsts. If Geelong and Richmond both don’t make the preliminary finals then that might change.

 

[Freoforever86]

Dreaming , I would say our earlier 1st and possibly St Kilda's 2nd which looks like #23-#25

Richmond will be looking at getting 1 of the west australian tall fowards JVR/Williams/Bazo

the west Australian fwds that may be gone by the time you have a pick?. Haha.

literally not dreaming, it’ll likely happen if he nominates

 

[THE_GUN]

What do you honestly see his value as, for perspective, you've seen neutrals say him and Bolton are close to worth the same in value. Would you let Bolton go for pick 12?

With their age and output, both are worth a pick around 5, both are young stars. Richmond nuffies will say Bolton is worth more, Freo nuffies will say Cerra.

I sh*t you not, if Cerra does go to Richmond, and Bell doesnt get at least your two first picks this year (which are picks in the teens), I will find Bell, I will kick him in the nuts and will never give Freo another dime until they kick Bell out.

Edit: He is absolutely not a pick 10-12 player

I would hate that and wouldnt want to let him go for pick 5 but uncontracted and wanting to go home to a particular player you dont have a choice
Wave good bye and there is a very likely chance that will happen in the future

Oh and i rate Bolton higher than Cerra

 

[THE_GUN]

the west Australian fwds that may be gone by the time you have a pick?. Haha.

literally not dreaming, it’ll likely happen if he nominates

I wouldnt say no to making a bet with you 1 of the 3 are still on the board at our pick

 

[Taylor]

no

You're correct. If the picks are in the teens it will be three first round picks.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

I would hate that and wouldnt want to let him go for pick 5 but uncontracted and wanting to go home to a particular player you dont have a choice
Wave good bye and there is a very likely chance that will happen in the future

Oh and i rate Bolton higher than Cerra

So why did Saad go for pick 8, he was uncontracted and not worth near that. At a point in quality, the contract status means little, what means more is the picks the buying team has. Cerra is young quality, Bolton is young quality, both would go for a pick around 5 at minimum. They are both in similar boats as Treloar when he left GWS

 

[THE_GUN]

So why did Saad go for pick 8, he was uncontracted and not worth near that. At a point in quality, the contract status means little, what means more is the picks the buying team has. Cerra is young quality, Bolton is young quality, both would go for a pick around 5 at minimum. They are both in similar boats as Treloar when he left GWS

Ill ask you the same question "So why did Mitchell go for #14 " on bigger $$$

 

[THE_GUN]

You're correct. If the picks are in the teens it will be three first round picks.

No


we could do this all day

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Cerra isn’t getting past North or the Hawks if he goes to the draft. This will ensure a fair price is paid by Richmond/Carlton/Bombers/whoever.