Traded Adam Saad [traded to Carlton with #48 and #78 for #8 and #87]

[FairKouta]

Saad would be fantastic for St Kilda, Brings good pace and skills and would allow Clark to become a full time mid

Apparently saints are into him wouldn’t be surprised if you guys get him. Be great for the saints building nicely. Love clarke and big max king

 

[Juddernaut08]

There's Covid -19 and then there's Carlton supporters dishing out advice on how to win grand finals. My god have a spell mate.

You of all people should listen up. Things have changed since the Vietnam War.

 

[Juddernaut08]

Would our second rounder get it done? If dodo bird asks for pick 7 Id rather Saad go elsewhere.

 

[Juddernaut08]

Saad would be fantastic for St Kilda, Brings good pace and skills and would allow Clark to become a full time mid

how do u have so much cap space. big acquisitions last year and still hunting. kudos

saad for your firstcpick?

 

[Stan_Darsh72]

how do u have so much cap space. big acquisitions last year and still hunting. kudos

saad for your firstcpick?

St Kilda front ended a lot of contracts due to being crap and only paid 95% of the cap for years allowing us to be able to use 105% for when we need it.

I think this season St Kilda is still only paying 95% of the cap

 

[THE_GUN]

Cant see him coming to Richmond for many reasons

* We have Houli ,Short,Markov,Egg-Smith all as running HBF'ers with Houli still there 2 more years imo plaus a bunch of kids like Naish/English/Turner
so not really a desperate need and cant see Richmond giving up anymore than our 1st rounder which DoDo would not accept
Then there is the $$$$ Thinking he would be on $600k+

Just cant see it, He can still work with houli in the muslim academy and nga and doesnt have to play for the tigers to do this

 

[Yoda_]

Ok dad, i'm very sorry to offend you. I'll be a good boy now and just let all of the other supporters sh*t on our club whilst you sip on a nice chianti.

Grow up


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Yoda_]

If he leaves, a future first would probably do it


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Linda_Lovelace]

If he leaves, a future first would probably do it


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Umm the only chance of that is if a side feels he is what they need to flag. Other than that, a second rounder at best. Aint that good. Essendon always over rate their players.

 

[Juddernaut08]

Ideally we do a Jack Martin and walk him to the PSD but worried North may pounce

 

[Peel67skin]

Ideally we do a Jack Martin and walk him to the PSD but worried North may pounce

If you do a jack Martin you just need to paid him more than North nothing to worried about .

 

[Brutalitops]

If you do a jack Martin you just need to paid him more than North nothing to worried about .

I dont think theres a dollar figure that would deter North. Even before they decided to cast Brown into the wind.

 

[HBF]

Carlton have a solid enough list, they still have holes in it, but they need to dump Plowman ASAP.

Based on what?

 

[eth-dog]

Based on what?

He's the worst 1-on-1 player interested AFL?

 

[HBF]

He's the worst 1-on-1 player interested AFL?

LOL.
Go and watch his game against Brisbane last week. He took Charlie Cameron to the cleaners.
Sure he's not perfect, but he gets all the tough matchups every week.

 

[eth-dog]

LOL.
Go and watch his game against Brisbane last week. He took Charlie Cameron to the cleaners.
Sure he's not perfect, but he gets all the tough matchups every week.

Yeah. He's lost more defensive one on one's than any other player in the AFL. I watched him get monsters by Jacob Townsend and Bayley Fritsch. Guy is trash.

 

[HBF]

Yeah. He's lost more defensive one on one's than any other player in the AFL. I watched him get monsters by Jacob Townsend and Bayley Fritsch. Guy is trash.

If you say so. Once you've finished watching the Lions game, have a look at the job he did on Papley a couple of weeks ago as well. Took him right out of the game. Also, just between you and I, if I was you i'd be more concerned about whats going on at your footy club than worrying about one player at ours.

 

[eth-dog]

If you say so. Once you've finished watching the Lions game, have a look at the job he did on Papley a couple of weeks ago as well. Took him right out of the game. Also, just between you and I, if I was you i'd be more concerned about whats going on at your footy club than worrying about one player at ours.

I like how my club being shit means I can't comment on a player from another being shit.

 

[Kenny Hunter09]

Yeah. He's lost more defensive one on one's than any other player in the AFL. I watched him get monsters by Jacob Townsend and Bayley Fritsch. Guy is trash.

The mind boggles as to how the Adam Saad thread become a discussion about the Plow.
That said...
I guess you can be thankful he doesn't play for Essendon then. As a Carlton fan, I most definitely see his value. I watch Carlton closely every week - and in particular, Plowman - and see him as an important part of our backline. I'd strongly assume you've based you opinion on a large amount of 'vibe'.

 

[HBF]

I like how my club being sh*t means I can't comment on a player from another being sh*t.

Comment all you like. Its just an incorrect comment.
Yes Plow has had some poor games this year, but he has also had some very good games as well.

 

[eth-dog]

The mind boggles as to how the Adam Saad thread become a discussion about the Plow.
That said...
I guess you can be thankful he doesn't play for Essendon then. As a Carlton fan, I most definitely see his value. I watch Carlton closely every week - and in particular, Plowman - and see him as an important part of our backline. I'd strongly assume you've based you opinion on a large amount of 'vibe'.

I'm thankful he plays for you guys too. I know plenty of Carlton supporters who agree with my view, in fact I agreed with you until they pointed it out to me that he's trash one on one. Never thought he was that bad honestly until I started to pay attention.

 

[PrinceCharles]

I just can't see him in a Saints guernsey, think he ei

Yeah. He's lost more defensive one on one's than any other player in the AFL. I watched him get monsters by Jacob Townsend and Bayley Fritsch. Guy is trash.

8th in the comp for contested one on one contests, not even another small to mid defender in the top 20.

 

[citizen-erased]

in the craziness of 2020, at least the s**tfighting on the draft/trading board can be relied upon come september

 

[Kenny Hunter09]

I'm thankful he plays for you guys too. I know plenty of Carlton supporters who agree with my view, in fact I agreed with you until they pointed it out to me that he's trash one on one. Never thought he was that bad honestly until I started to pay attention.

He's a polarizing player. I know plenty of Carlton supporters that are misguided like yourself too. There is no doubt he makes mistakes, that cost goals (like any defender). In my opinion however, he does plenty more good than bad, and as HBF has pointed out, he's taken down high quality forwards of all sizes this season.

 

[eth-dog]

8th in the comp for contested one on one contests, not even another small to mid defender in the top 20.

So? He's still lost more than any other player in the league.