Traded Adam Treloar [traded w/ #28 to Collingwood for #7, #65, 2016 first rounder]

[Calcium Man]

If they redid the draft he would be top 20 easy. Actually reminds me a lot of how Rance started out. end derail

Off the top of my head

Boyd
Kelly
billings
Bont
KK
Aish
Sheed
Salem
Lennon
Crips
mccarthey
Jones
Dunstan
Impey
Hartung
Crouch
Mcstay
Merrett
Taylor
Lobb
Dumont
j kolo
Ben brown

That doesn't even include scharenberg who has barely played and a handful of others that are highly regarded.

 

[richoatthedisco]

I think he has Marsh mixed up with Frost

No. Frost is truly woeful.

Well it will be interesting to see how it goes but I've watched a lot of his games in the vfl this season and his rate of improvement from where he's was in his draft year has been massive.

Yeah, let's see. I'm open to it.

Well I'll be. It looks like KB has started World War 3.

Which is only fitting seeing as though he was alive for the first 2.

Our mutual hatred brought us both to our knees last time. let's hope this ends better.

 

[dlanod]

And as for the (once again) team pissing contests, here's a handy link.

Since it didn't work last time, let's try it again... Adam might decide who to go to based off the record and future of the club, but come on - focus on not resorting to the repeated "mine is bigger than your's".

 

[MightyPage025]

Sam McClure Twitter

Adam Treloar will tomorrow inform GWS that he will seek a trade back to Victoria.

 

[captainMyCaptain]

 

[Colonial]

Wow.

I can see why we would be keen but Treloar wanting to go there?
Must be one hell of an offer.

 

[Defacto]

if treloar and kruzer are going to the pies...where is aish going?

 

[Dez!]

Wow.

I can see why we would be keen but Treloar wanting to go there?
Must be one hell of an offer.

It says SOS is keen, doesn't say anything about Treloar being keen.

 

[pinot]

Wow.

I can see why we would be keen but Treloar wanting to go there?
Must be one hell of an offer.

Being a Blueboy is in the blood.

 

[Colonial]

Being a Blueboy is in the blood.

Wonder how many $$$ does it take for him to realise that.

 

[magpies53]

I forgot Williams also

C

Says who? Apart from Moore and De Gooey, which of your youth has shown much?


Can we just have one post from you that isn't complete trolling? Please just be reasonable.


Speaking of outlandish statements... where is this "far deeper depth of quality younger players" you speak of? Please name them.

Grundy Adams marsh maynard crisp Elliott shazz broomhead langdon Williams fas just name a few

 

[pinot]

Wonder how many $$$ does it take for him to realise that.

If he wants to come to Carlton I doubt it would be much more than what any other club would be offering. We have the currency to get the deal done.

Docherty was another Blues supporter that got his way. Bulldogs had to offer $1 mln to Boyd to keep him out of our sights.

 

[Colonial]

If he wants to come to Carlton I doubt it would be much more than what any other club would be offering. We have the currency to get the deal done.

Docherty was another Blues supporter that got his way. Bulldogs had to offer $1 mln to Boyd to keep him out of our sights.

If you guys are offering the same type of grand father deal then of course he will want to be there.

And we will happily take your top picks.

 

[rfctiger90]

If he wants to come to Carlton I doubt it would be much more than what any other club would be offering. We have the currency to get the deal done.

Docherty was another Blues supporter that got his way. Bulldogs had to offer $1 mln to Boyd to keep him out of our sights.

Keep dreaming buddy.

 

[pinot]

If you guys are offering the same type of grand father deal then of course he will want to be there.

And we will happily take your top picks.

GWS will be suitably compensated for sure.

 

[rice_matt]

If they redid the draft he would be top 20 easy. Actually reminds me a lot of how Rance started out. end derail

you are actually deluded .. marsh is no good at all

 

[Tiger71]

Has he actually nominated a club or is it open slather for any vic team with the best picks ?

 

[inamedthegiants]

Poor bastard was born with rubbish looks, and if he chooses Carlton, no bloody brains either.

 

[Rustin Cohle]

Would lol for days if Carlton sold the farm for Treloar. Would be such a Carlton thing to do, looking for a quick fix over smart drafting.

 

[Colonial]

Poor bastard was born with rubbish looks, and if he chooses Carlton, no bloody brains either.

Still would love that pick 1

 

[Hagla]

GWS won't want to miss out on Witts, he'll be a Pie.

 

[PicaBoo]

Poor bastard was born with rubbish looks, and if he chooses Carlton, no bloody brains either.

I think that both Richmond and Collingwood supporters would rather see him end up at Carlton then at either side. 1 player in return for no future picks and a bloated salary cap should see them spooning for long time to come.

 

[captain cotch 9]

Carlton would be silly not to offer the #1 pick for Treloar IMO.
Treloar is a proven gun.
They will also, most likely have the #2 pick as well.

 

[pinot]

Still would love that pick 1

You wont be getting pick one - Weitering is a lock.

 

[Colonial]

You wont be getting pick one - Weitering is a lock.

So what would you have you offer besides 1?