Traded Adam Treloar [traded w/ #28 to Collingwood for #7, #65, 2016 first rounder]

[richoatthedisco]

So as part of the PowerPoint presentation Richmond prepare for Treloar to sell their success, will they be including the demoralizing 2013 EF loss to 9th placed Carlton or the 10 goal EF humiliation to Port Adelaide last season?

As I've been very consistent on, making the 8 is one thing but you actually have to demonstrate that you can play deep into September. Richmond so far have failed, and like many, I question whether their club has the ability to take the steps required to remedy that situation.

What a stupid troll of a post. Will Collingwood include the 91-point head kicking Richmond gave them three weeks ago? Or the loss to Essendon?

12th.

You finished 12th.

You are the 12th-best team in a league of 18.

If Treloar is looking at winning flags then he would be far better off staying at GWS that going to either of Collingwood or Richmond.

How's that? We're within touching distance without him.

How would you describe richmond fans?

level headed

humble

Unbelievably good-looking and well-endowed.

Also, humble, level-headed and realistic.

 

[Tiger71]

Touche' Tiger71 but I've got a good mate who's Tiggers fan and he'd probably describe himself that way before anything else. Can't argue with it as fact. I can say a lot of good things about my mate and other Tigers fans - but not some in these forums.

I hear ya brother and the same goes with me. Its like those that Post on BF from other clubs have to try to prove there epeen is huge and they do that by trying to bury the promise of a rival club.

 

[Matty411]

Its like those that Post on BF from other clubs have to try to prove there epeen is huge and they do that by trying to bury the promise of a rival club.

Truer words were never spoken.

 

[nahnah]

We also lost to richmond by 5 (with only 2 free kicks in a half) this year

 

[Tiger71]

You sort of lost any credibility here. Were you alive in 2010 or just conveniently forgotten it? We also made the GF in 2011 by the way.

If my maths is correct that is in the last 10 years.

Seriously, Tigers fans coming out of the woodwork spouting some crap!!

You drunk ?

Like I said, its a long time ago. 5-6 years is ancient history for footy clubs. It has zero, nothing to do with success in the now and future. What has a bearing is Pendles is your best player, he has played over 200 plus games and is on the decline, as is swan, as it cloke...I dont say that, to troll but to counter the rubbish that your future is better then ours.

If the Pies get AT, then you advance by 2 years you normally would take to build. if we get him, we instantly become a realistic top 4 side. Also, I have followed this club longer then you have been alive son, so to suggest I have just come out of the woodwork, is pretty laughable.

 

[richoatthedisco]

We also lost to richmond by 5 (with only 2 free kicks in a half) this year

We had two first-gamers, two second-gamers and a seventh-gamer playing that day. The umpires had no influence - they let you guys throw the ball at will also.

 

[Tbone McGraw]

You drunk ?

Like I said, its a long time ago. 5-6 years is ancient history for footy clubs. It has zero, nothing to do with success in the now and future. What has a bearing is Pendles is your best player, he has played over 200 plus games and is on the decline, as is swan, as it cloke...I dont say that, to troll but to counter the rubbish that your future is better then ours.

If the Pies get AT, then you advance by 2 years you normally would take to build. if we get him, we instantly become a realistic top 4 side. Also, I have followed this club longer then you have been alive son, so to suggest I have just come out of the woodwork, is pretty laughable.

Haha, I pointed out you had your facts wrong and you come out with the old "drunk" comment.

Like I said, you have zero credibility when you say stuff like "Pies have not been close to a flag in the last 10 years"

 

[nahnah]

We had two first-gamers, two second-gamers and a seventh-gamer playing that day. The umpires had no influence - they let you guys throw the ball at will also.

Well that's not a lot of youth compared to the pies

 

[nahnah]

Haha, I pointed out you had your facts wrong and you come out with the old "drunk" comment.

Like I said, you have zero credibility when you say stuff like "Pies have not been close to a flag in the last 10 years"

He's being level headed

 

[millsy29gopies]

Now you mention Premerships, you have not won a flag in a long, oh so very long time now. The reality in the last 10 years, you have not been any closer to a flag then us. You mention win a prelim, well if you want to talk flags I can point out we made a prelim in 2001 .

This is the single dumbest line I have ever read on BigFooty. Never have I seen such stupidity.

 

[SumTingWong]

Don't get so defensive. Richmond have done nothing yet to demonstrate that they are an entrenched powerhouse in the same manner that Collingwood, Hawthorn and Geelong have. Until they do so, they will always be at a disadvantage. I mean you haven't won a final for like 30 years, I don't see how richmond supporters keep on missing that point.

There is a pretty good reason why pretty much everyone in the media (other than KB lol) is backing Collingwood as the strong favorite in the race. Richmond posters just need to accept where they lie in the pecking order

2 finals wins in 1995 and 2001 where we made the prelim both years says otherwise. Go talk crap somewhere else

 

[Tiger71]

This is the single dumbest line I have ever read on BigFooty. Never have I seen such stupidity.

You obviously must never post on your own board then ?

 

[Tiger71]

Haha, I pointed out you had your facts wrong and you come out with the old "drunk" comment.

Like I said, you have zero credibility when you say stuff like "Pies have not been close to a flag in the last 10 years"

What facts ?

Your post was full of nonsense, outside your flag win, which was years and years ago, it has no relevance to your success this year or in the future. Are you suggesting that is a incorrect statement or are you trolling or just drunk ?

 

[Rich01]

We also lost to richmond by 5 (with only 2 free kicks in a half) this year

Free kicks in a half as an excuse for losing. LOL.

 

[Schraderbrau]

2 finals wins in 1995 and 2001 where we made the prelim both years says otherwise. Go talk crap somewhere else

so it now appears Richmond supporters are talking about 2 preliminary finals in 20 years as some kind of an achievement?

 

[Tbone McGraw]

What facts ?

Your post was full of nonsense, outside your flag win, which was years and years ago, it has no relevance to your success this year or in the future. Are you suggesting that is a incorrect statement or are you trolling or just drunk ?

What are you talking about? I think you are confusing me with someone else. Probably read posts before you try replying.

And I am the troll?

 

[Apex36]

We had two first-gamers, two second-gamers and a seventh-gamer playing that day. The umpires had no influence - they let you guys throw the ball at will also.

Richmond Games Collingwood
8 Less than 50 12
5 50 to 99 2
6 100 to 149 5
3 150 or more 3

Don't be fooled in to thinking you had a less experienced side on the field than us on the day, old chum. More than half our side had less than 50 games experience on the day.

 

[SumTingWong]

so it now appears Richmond supporters are talking about 2 preliminary finals in 20 years as some kind of an achievement?

Or we'll talk about 2 premierships in 60 years as a dynasty

 

[richoatthedisco]

Well that's not a lot of youth compared to the pies

You didn't have any first-gamers playing. Or any second-gamers.

Richmond Games Collingwood
8 Less than 50 12
5 50 to 99 2
6 100 to 149 5
3 150 or more 3

Don't be fooled in to thinking you had a less experienced side on the field than us on the day, old chum. More than half our side had less than 50 games experience on the day.

Average Attributes
Richmond Attribute Collingwood
189.7cm Height 189.5cm
87.9kg Weight 89.7kg
24yr 2mth Age 24yr 3mth
83.1 Games 80.3

Your average age was older than ours, by a month per player. Our players were more experienced, by 3 games per player. Collingwood is not some wunderkind youth team like some of its fans are trying to make out.

 

[nahnah]

You didn't have any first-gamers playing. Or any second-gamers.


Average Attributes
Richmond Attribute Collingwood
189.7cm Height 189.5cm
87.9kg Weight 89.7kg
24yr 2mth Age 24yr 3mth
83.1 Games 80.3

Your average age was older than ours, by a month per player. Our players were more experienced, by 3 games per player. Collingwood is not some wunderkind youth team like some of its fans are trying to make out.

No that would be the Western Bulldogs, but we are about 3rd for best youth and could potentially steal a gun young player from the 2nd best young team

 

[Schraderbrau]

Can we just have one thread on this board that isn't hijacked by Richmond supporters bloviating over their recent unprecedented success of finishing in the eight. Please just be reasonable.

 

[Prochard123]

What facts ?

Your post was full of nonsense, outside your flag win, which was years and years ago, it has no relevance to your success this year or in the future. Are you suggesting that is a incorrect statement or are you trolling or just drunk ?

You're still talking?

 

[pieman85]

You drunk ?

Like I said, its a long time ago. 5-6 years is ancient history for footy clubs. It has zero, nothing to do with success in the now and future. What has a bearing is Pendles is your best player, he has played over 200 plus games and is on the decline, as is swan, as it cloke...I dont say that, to troll but to counter the rubbish that your future is better then ours.

If the Pies get AT, then you advance by 2 years you normally would take to build. if we get him, we instantly become a realistic top 4 side. Also, I have followed this club longer then you have been alive son, so to suggest I have just come out of the woodwork, is pretty laughable.

Sorry but how many premiership players are currently playing for richmond??

The pies have a far deeper depth of quality younger players than richmond do, your window is open now but i doubt it will be open for aslong as collingwoods will be, i like richmond but i just dont get how some people on here can make outlandish statements that the pies havent been anywhere near a flag in the last 10 years, tiger71 you are making your own supporter base look stupid, maybe think before typing next time buddy

 

[Tbone McGraw]

Sorry but how many premiership players are currently playing for richmond??

The pies have a far deeper depth of quality younger players than richmond do, your window is open now but i doubt it will be open for aslong as collingwoods will be, i like richmond but i just dont get how some people on here can make outlandish statements that the pies havent been anywhere near a flag in the last 10 years, tiger71 you are making your own supporter base look stupid, maybe think before typing next time buddy

I think our friend may have a thread ban

 

[Tiger71]

You're still talking?

typing actually but i guess in the meth haze you hear my voice ?