Autopsy AFL 2022 Second Elimination Final - Lions v Tigers Thurs Sept 1st 7:20pm EST (Gabba)

[Altum Volantes]

The AFL must either replay the match or overturn the result. It’s clear Lynch’s shot was a goal. This is the goal line vision, don’t forget the umpire called a goal!

View attachment 1496625

Have you considered starting an online petition?

 

[PieLebo87]

Not me. The fact they brought Martin back - who has been cooked all year - was a sign of desperation.

I tipped the Tigers but did tell family you can’t just write the Lions off. Great game. Hopefully Saturday arvo is a bit more one-sided. I can’t deal anymore.

 

[Ginnieboy]

Not exactly of course, but its the 90deg between the two angles that counts.
Heres another take, The third angle at the time also shows it over the post as well.
Its a point.

View attachment 1496555

There’s no depth regarding the flight of the ball though, did it spin past the post? That is certainly a possibility, that IMO is not enough evidence to over rule an umpire.

 

[Andyy]

Watch again. Daniher leaps on Tarrant's side taking him out legally, is about to take the mark, but it's taken by the man in front or him. His teammate marking it doesn't make it an unrealistic attempt.

I agree, it was realistic.

Rich one I'd have to watch again but easier to call if you're an ump.

 

[The Devils Advocate]

The umpiring in the Eels v Storm game tonight was fantastic. You'd think in the finals of the AFL, you might have your most experienced operators.

 

[Farang83150]

How did Bolton not get pinged for dropping the ball in the last minutes at brissys end, so very very blatant.
Lots of very good tackles from Brisbane not paid.

 

[docko911]

Baker cost Richmond 2 clear goals. AFL's defence would be: git gud

Doesn’t mean shit when video umpire has clearly ****ed up

 

[Parasite]

Not exactly of course, but its the 90deg between the two angles that counts.
Heres another take, The third angle at the time also shows it over the post as well.
Its a point.

View attachment 1496555

Top left over post bottom left not over post. Tigerrrrrrrrs we’re roooooobbbbbbed. Should dump a load of manure outside afl house.

 

[Ricketz]

Watch again. Daniher leaps on Tarrant's side taking him out legally, is about to take the mark, but it's taken by the man in front or him. His teammate marking it doesn't make it an unrealistic attempt.

I agree. If they paid those sorts of frees consistently then half the marks wouldn't be paid. Cameron's specky on the flank in front of Hipwood was almost identical. It was a realistic attempt imo.

 

[Andyy]

Not me. The fact they brought Martin back - who has been cooked all year - was a sign of desperation.

Sign of arrogance IMO.

If Graham was fit to play they should have played him as a lockdown on Neale. He at least has match fitness which Dusty 100% does not. Going into a final with a bloke that's hardly played all year is plan stupid.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Hope you enjoyed the umpire jizz fest you cheating campaigner!

Don't worry you'll be back in 35 years

 

[underthestars]

after lynch took that mark the camera moved to show fagan, looked close to tears. my heart went out to him, i think the goal review umpire's did too.
twas a good thing, and luckily twas the right thing.

 

[Kappa]

The AFL must either replay the match or overturn the result. It’s clear Lynch’s shot was a goal. This is the goal line vision, don’t forget the umpire called a goal!

View attachment 1496625

Charlie Cameron was held by the jumper 30 metres out from goal without a free kick.

So after they overturn the decision, they'll have to overturn that decision and get Cameron to come in on Monday night and kick to win the match.

 

[jonnobackpocket]

Melbourne or Sydney will spank Brisbane

Tell you who won’t- Essendon- because it’s finals!!!!!

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

There’s no depth regarding the flight of the ball though, did it spin past the post? That is certainly a possibility, that IMO is not enough evidence to over rule an umpire.

It was a point. And it was blatantly obvious.

 

[Ginnieboy]

He's getting on and has lost a lot of pace but I disagree.

He's had his best season since about 2018 and his leadership has been massive.

Still a better leader than Nank and Grimes even without the captaincy.

He's an absolute must for us in 2023 to help develop kids like Sonsie and Ross but I think that's about after one more year.

I had him in my multi so watched him closely, fumbled almost everything, got little of it.

 

[Ricketz]

He got rid of Tarrant unfairly as he wasn't in the contest and he took him out unfairly. 100% free kick.
View attachment 1496636

That's not the rule though. He had eyes on the ball and was making a realistic attempt at marking.

 

[Randomizor]

Does Cotchin go on?

He does. Bloke never shuts up.

 

[The Devils Advocate]

He got rid of Tarrant unfairly as he wasn't in the contest and he took him out unfairly. 100% free kick.
View attachment 1496636

Nice freeze frame with zero context, a high efficacy move. You could say anything here. Like a seagul dropped a hotdog next to Tarrant and he was hungry and went for a dive.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

The AFL must either replay the match or overturn the result. It’s clear Lynch’s shot was a goal. This is the goal line vision, don’t forget the umpire called a goal!

View attachment 1496625

4 year supporter?

 

[Andyy]

How did Bolton not get pinged for dropping the ball in the last minutes at brissys end, so very very blatant.
Lots of very good tackles from Brisbane not paid.

Yep either blind sided or the pressure got to them and they pooped the bed on that one. Not uncommon given their poor display tonight.

 

[The Devils Advocate]

He does. Bloke never shuts up.

That's Brownlow Medallist Trent Cotchin to you sir.

 

[FourthTimeAround]

Top left over post bottom left not over post. Tigerrrrrrrrs we’re roooooobbbbbbed. Should dump a load of manure outside afl house.

Go forward and back a frame from that one, no difference. Clearly over the post as it passes the goal line.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Sign of arrogance IMO.

If Graham was fit to play they should have played him as a lockdown on Neale. He at least has match fitness which Dusty 100% does not. Going into a final with a bloke that's hardly played all year is plan stupid.

Always an excuse. Can never take a loss gracefully you blokes.

 

[Collingwood 4 eternity]

Please explain AFL

View attachment 1496580

The AFL are on to it